Jerusalem – Hundreds Of Thousands Of Jews Flock To Israel To Sages’ Tombs Seeking Miracles

    38

    FILE - In this Sunday, May 22, 2011 file photo, an Ultra-orthodox Jewish youth covered in a prayer shawl take part in prayers on the grave of Rabbi Shimon Bar Yochai during Lag Ba'Omer celebrations at Mt. Meron in northern Israel.  These believers are part of a peculiar and growing phenomenon in Israel, where hundreds of thousands of people from starkly different backgrounds flock to the tombs of ancient biblical figures or modern day rabbis, seeking blessings and claiming they've witnessed miracles. (AP Photo/Ariel Schalit, File)Jerusalem – One man prays to heal the legs he broke in a car accident. An older woman pleads for grandchildren. Another visitor has come to see “God’s secretary.”

    Join our WhatsApp group

    Subscribe to our Daily Roundup Email


    These believers are part of a growing phenomenon in Israel, where hundreds of thousands of people from starkly different backgrounds flock to the tombs of ancient Biblical figures or modern-day rabbis, seeking blessings and claiming they’ve witnessed miracles.

    At many of these sites there is scant proof that any sage is actually buried there. Some are even believed to be co-opted Ottoman or Muslim burial places. But to the faithful, the lack of hard evidence is irrelevant. It’s the deep spiritual experience or, for some, the desperate desire to be blessed, that matters.

    “Coming here is being able to speak to God’s secretary. It’s the closest you can get,” said Suzy Shaked, a 55-year-old teacher from central Israel who visited the tomb of Rabbi Yisrael Abuhatzeira, one of the most popular pilgrimage sites.

    Shaked said she sees Abuhatzeira, better known as the Baba Sali, as God’s envoy. A visit to his tomb puts her requests in God’s earshot. She was praying at the Baba Sali’s tomb for her son to marry.

    While there are no firm statistics on how many Israelis visit sites like the Baba Sali’s tomb, researchers say the number is growing.

    They cite the rising power of religious political parties, the influence of Israelis of north African descent who traditionally practiced these kinds of pilgrimages, and a growing desire by even secular Jews to find meaning in their lives through a spiritual act. Prominent businessmen and politicians are known to make appearances at the sites.

    “It’s hard for (people) to be satisfied with prayer in a synagogue to a God who is very abstract, who is unclear, who is not accessible,” said Doron Bar, a historical geographer who studies the sites. “I think visiting a grave like this gives believers a line through which demands can be made.”

    Bar believes that the number of pilgrimage sites has grown into the hundreds.

    The phenomenon has spawned a tourist trade, where busloads of faithful are ferried from one burial site to another to make a variety of wishes.

    “People see results,” said Benny Barzilai, who runs monthly trips to tombs. “That’s why this tour succeeds.”

    Morroccan-born Abuhatzeira was revered even in life as a mystic and performer of miracles. After he died in January 1984, he gained rock star-like fandom.

    Today, his tomb in the blue-collar town of Netivot in southern Israel draws an estimated hundreds of thousands of pilgrims. The anniversary of his death is especially popular, a time that is believed to grant the worshipper a heightened closeness to God.

    It’s the second-most visited tomb in Israel, after that of Yonatan ben Uziel in northern Israel. That site, which reportedly draws half a million people a year, is believed to answer prayers for marriage.

    At the Baba Sali compound, believers of all stripes could be seen during the recent anniversary commemorations— mildly religious young women in tight jeans and red nails, pious elderly women in long floral skirts and head coverings, silver-haired politicians in pinstriped suits. The tomb was packed with a mass of wailing worshippers, which swelled gradually into the evening.

    The day was joyful and festive, with barbecues, picnics and vendors selling candles and clocks bearing the Baba Sali’s image. The faithful hurled candles into a large furnace, a ritual with pagan tinges meant to immortalize the sage’s soul.

    “I take advantage of any opportunity to go see a sage,” said Shimon Kaslessi, a truck driver, who walks with crutches but was told he likely wouldn’t walk at all after a car crash two years ago.

    “When you’ve seen miracles, when the sage makes a handicapped person walk, you believe,” he added, a tear streaming down his face.

    Although the burial place of modern rabbis like Abuhatzeira are not questioned, those of more ancient sages are not always investigated or recognized by any official body, meaning anyone can theoretically designate a place as holy and spark a following.

    A site near the central town of Modiin is believed by some to be the tomb of the Jewish priest Matityahu ben Yohanan, one of the heroes of the Hasmonean Revolt against the Greeks more than 2,000 years ago. While not officially recognized, the site draws hundreds of pilgrims a year.

    Similarly, a tomb in a Jerusalem mosque is sacred to Jews, Muslims and Christians, yet each claims a different holy woman is buried there.

    Researchers believe the grave of the prophet Havakuk in northern Israel was possibly deemed to be there because the prophet’s name rhymed with a nearby village, Yakuk.

    It’s unclear how the phenomenon took root. Traditionally in Judaism, prostrating oneself at graves was forbidden, as it was likened to the prohibited custom of idol worship.

    Some studies believe that after Israel gained independence in 1948, many important Jewish sites beyond Israel’s boundaries were out of reach. Jews in turn assigned greater importance to less significant sites inside Israel or co-opted what was known to be, until then, an Ottoman or Muslim tomb.

    Over time, myths surrounding the different graves emerged, and Jews began making pilgrimages to these sites. The custom is practiced at tombs of Jewish sages around the world as well, including a massive yearly pilgrimage to Ukraine.

    Many are nondescript tombstones while some are grand domed mausoleums. Each sage is typically associated with different requests, whether for health, wealth, love or fertility.

    More than 100 such sites are considered official holy places by Israel’s Tourism Ministry, meaning they are maintained with government funds. New sites are rarely added to the ministry’s list because they “lack proof” that anyone of importance is interred there, said Mina Genem, a ministry official.

    Nonetheless, these tombs attract Jews from all backgrounds who return year after year because they say their prayers have been answered.

    Sarah Cohen, 69, said her daughter became pregnant after she prayed for her at the Baba Sali’s tomb.

    “I’ve been coming here for 20 years,” she said, after flinging a candle into the red furnace. “My daughter came too because she saw that my prayers were answered.”


    Listen to the VINnews podcast on:

    iTunes | Spotify | Google Podcasts | Stitcher | Podbean | Amazon

    Follow VINnews for Breaking News Updates


    Connect with VINnews

    Join our WhatsApp group


    38 Comments
    Most Voted
    Newest Oldest
    Inline Feedbacks
    View all comments
    curious
    curious
    12 years ago

    Davening is great but asking for outright miracles at a kever is Lo sinachashu an issur dioraysa. I know people will try to bring proof from stories, but look it up, it is clearly ossur.

    12 years ago

    ‘a growing phenomenon in Israel’ …… yeah, like when did it start?

    jonkamm623
    jonkamm623
    12 years ago

    I think that this like a glatt kosher avoda zara.If anybody calls out to hashem himself in truth he will be answered right away.Sometimes the answer is no or later however he will be answered.Hashem is infinitely greater than his prophets.

    12 years ago

    “It’s hard for (people) to be satisfied with prayer in a synagogue to a God who is very abstract, who is unclear, who is not accessible,” said Doron Bar

    Mr. Bar, G-d is involved in our lives 24/7 and is very accessible. All one need do is pray to Him.

    12 years ago

    This is new. New as in Yehoshua and Calev davened at kever Rochel when they went to Cana’an with the meraglim. So we know that this is a recent phenomenon.

    Babishka
    Member
    Babishka
    12 years ago

    “At many of these sites there is scant proof that any sage is actually buried there. Some are even believed to be co-opted Ottoman or Muslim burial places.”

    This is totally not true. The locations of these kevorim have been known for hundreds of years. If they have been co-opted, it was by the Muslims, not FROM the Muslims.

    menachemwh
    menachemwh
    12 years ago

    Mitoch shelo lishma bo lishmah………But they are davening the way one should daven. Halevy I should follow suit

    Avi613
    Avi613
    12 years ago

    Anyone who lives in the US can go to the ohel of the Lubavitcher Rebbe in queens where many people have seen many yeshuos…

    The zohar says That a tzadik can do even more after his passing.

    #3 the gemoro actually says that if someone has somone sick yelech lechacham he should go to a Rabbi so clearly there is a point of turning to a rabbi, of course ultomately the yeshuah comes from Hashem but the rabbi has the zechus as it says tzadik gozer veH”kbh mekayem..

    basmelech
    basmelech
    12 years ago

    Hashem is here, Hashem is there, Hashem is truly everywhere. I daven at home, and I believe if I am worthy Hashem will answer my tefilos right here.

    12 years ago

    There is no greater yichus from traveling long-distances and davening with kavanah and sincerity at the kever of some chashuve rav or gadol than davening with same kavanah and sincerity at the kever of a lesser-known tzadik close to home. I’ve confirmed that the Ebeshter will listen with equal attention at either location and will respond accordingly. Much of the stuff discussed in the article is borderline avodah zoroah.

    Avi613
    Avi613
    12 years ago

    #12 what if u are not worthy???

    Well maybe u can wait until u become worthy.. But many will ask a tzadik who is worthy to intercede for us.

    #13 so calev and yehoshua were cha”v doing avoda zara and rashi approved of it?
    Also u showed your lack of basic knowledge when u said “no where in the text, Torah, does Rachel weep for her children. This is commentary and it is important to make the distinction.” it is not a commentary it is a clear pasuk in Yirmiyahu 31 14
    … שנאמר (ירמיה לא יד) קול ברמה נשמע רחל מבכה על בניה וגו’, והקב”ה משיבה (ירמיה לא טו) יש שכר לפעולתך נאם ה’ …

    Anon Ibid Opcit
    Anon Ibid Opcit
    12 years ago

    It won’t be long before they start sawing relics off the bodies

    12 years ago

    The way it is portrayed in this article may smack of avoda zora, yet praying to G-d at the graves of tzadikim is an age-old practice. Calev , for example. but all our gedolim have gone to the kevorim of the greats before them to daven.

    LGinsburg
    LGinsburg
    12 years ago

    # 15, let’s assume for a moment you meant “#14”, when you responded to my comment that Rachel doesn’t weep in the Torah. I misspoke /miswrote – the quote you bring from Yirmiyahu is in fact in the text, though it’s used as imagery in a prophecy and not in the Torah (yes, I make the distinction) it is in text. The story of either/both Yehoshua and Calev praying at K’ver Rachel or Hevron I’ve yet to find in the text – please take a moment to educate an “am ha’aretz”.

    ChachoMoe
    ChachoMoe
    12 years ago

    For all you scholars out there, there is a gemarah bavli in the end if Yavamot, indiacting pilgrimge at the Yom deHelulah of tanayim…so it is by far new! I will post the exact page later. As for avoadah zorah’ that is only if you pray directly, not when your intention is nothing less than as the deceased one being a “maylitz” on ones behalf.

    Avi613
    Avi613
    12 years ago

    #26 so rashi is not good enough for you?
    And u speak of apikursus!
    I rest my case.

    And btw so the half million of people who go rashbi on lagbaomer among them many great tzadikim and pray by the kever its all avodah zara?!?!?!
    R u people out ur minds???!!!

    12 years ago

    The issue is praying to G-d by the grave of a Tzadik, in order to invoke the merit of the Tzadik. One does not pray to the Tzadik directly, C”V.

    eighthcomment
    eighthcomment
    12 years ago

    If someone does not believe that Torah shebaal peh is just as holy as Torah shebechsav- yes they are heretics. they were both given at mt Sinai-