Cleveland, OH - Judge: U.S. Hate-Crime Law Also Applies To Violent Disputes Between Different Religions
Cleveland, OH - A federal judge has rejected a challenge of the federal hate crimes law by Amish sect leader Sam Mullet and 15 followers charged with beard- and hair-cutting assaults in Ohio Amish country last year.
U.S. District Judge Dan Polster ruled that the indictment against Mr. Mullet, brought by the U.S. Justice Department under the 2009 Hate Crimes Prevention Act, does not violate the U.S. Constitution as the defendants’ lawyers had argued.
Mr. Mullet’s attorney, along with lawyers for the others, said the beard-cutting attacks were not hate crimes because they did not involve an anti-Amish bias but rather a dispute within a religion.
Judge Polster said the Hate Crimes Prevention Act doesn’t limit acts of violence to disputes between different religions.
“While hate crimes are often committed by members of one religious (or racial or ethnic) group against another, history is replete with examples of internecine violence,” he ruled. “By the defendants’ logic, a violent assault by a Catholic on a Protestant, or a Sunni Muslim on a Shiite Muslim, or an Orthodox Jew on a non-Orthodox Jew, would not be prohibited by this statute.”
The lawyers had also argued that the hate crimes law violated the defendants’ rights to religious expression under the First Amendment.
More of today's headlines“Washington - Remember all those phony emails that purport to be from your bank, asking you to click on a link and turn over your account information? Cyber experts...” Washington - Cyber Criminals Using New Tricks For Break-Ins “New York, NY - Mayor Michael Bloomberg says an audit on New York City's 911 system shows "a new level of intellectual dishonesty" by Comptroller John Liu. Liu said...” New York, NY - Mayor Bloomberg Calls 911 Audit 'Stupid'