Kentucky - Death Row Inmate Loses Lawsuit Over Shabbath
Kentucky - If Kentucky’s lone Jewish inmate on death row wants to mark the Sabbath, he’ll have to do it from a cell in a secure unit for now.
The Kentucky Court of Appeals on Friday ruled that prison officials are not violating the religious freedom rights of 40-year-old William Harry Meece, who is awaiting execution for the slayings of three people in Adair County in 1993, by having him pray in his cell.
Judge Laurence VanMeter, writing for a three-judge panel, concluded that prison policy correctly prevents Meece from being allowed into the Institutional Religious Center at the Kentucky State Penitentiary in Eddyville because of security concerns. As a death row inmate, Meece lives in the Special Security Unit near the other condemned inmates and apart from the other 800-plus inmates.
Meece sued the Kentucky Department of Corrections in 2007, accusing the agency of violating the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act, which prohibits burdens on the ability of prisoners to worship as they please.
Meece had claimed that it was a burden to pray in his small cell and that prison policies kept him from covering up the toilet or praying near it. The judge disagreed, saying Meece can pray near a toilet and cover it with a sheet.
The inmate also claimed he should be allowed to go to the prison’s chapel on his own or with other Jewish inmates on the Sabbath, which goes from sundown Friday to sundown Saturday. He is currently allowed to join Roman Catholics on death row for Thursday services and Protestants on Sunday.
“These restrictions can best be described as an inconvenience to Meece’s desired approach to practice his religion, but in no way inhibit his expression of religious beliefs,” VanMeter wrote.
Meece, in letters to The Associated Press before the ruling came down, railed against the Corrections Department policy saying “I’ll die or get killed” rather than follow the state’s rules.
“Aren’t you proud of your tax dollars at work?” Meece wrote. “Emotionally, it deprives even that basic spiritual recharge. And I fight on.”
Prosecutors say Meece shot and killed Joseph and Elizabeth Wellnitz and their son, Dennis, at their home on Feb. 26, 2003, in Columbia in Adair County. The daughter, Meg Wellnitz Appleton, pleaded guilty last year to three counts of complicity to murder and is serving life in prison.
Police say Wellnitz’s surviving daughter contrived the murder plot to collect an inheritance. The case lingered for a decade without suspects before police received a tip that Meece and Appleton had talked about being involved in the killings. Meece’s case remains on appeal in federal court.
Kentucky is implementing a new execution method, which should be in place later this year.
In letters to The Associated Press, Meece has denied taking part in the slayings and said police forced a confession from him.
“I. Did. Not. Murder. The Wellnitz Family,” Meece wrote.
More of today's headlines“Providence, RI - A federal judge in Rhode Island has told lawyers for the oldest synagogue in the United States and the nation's first Jewish congregation not to speak...” Providence, RI - Lawyers in Touro Synagogue Bells Dispute Ordered Not to Speak with Media “New York - A co-founder of Reddit and activist who fought to make online content free to the public has been found dead, authorities confirmed Saturday, prompting an...” New York - Internet Guru Online Activist, Programmer Swartz Dies In NY