Welcome, Guest! - or
Easy to remember!  »  VinNews.com

Rishon Lezion - Court: Rabbi Must Explain Referrals Of Marrying Couples To Private Firm

Published on: February 1, 2013 10:01 AM
By: Jerusalem Post
Change text size Text Size  
Bookmark and Share
Rishon Lezion Chief Rabbi Yehuda David WolpeRishon Lezion Chief Rabbi Yehuda David Wolpe

Rishon Lezion - The High Court of Justice demanded on Thursday that Rishon Lezion Chief Rabbi Yehuda David Wolpe explain why he sends couples seeking to register for marriage to a private company for clarifications about their Jewish ancestry.

ITIM, a religious rights lobbying group, filed a petition with the court against Wolpe and the Am Levadad company earlier this week. They have till March 10 to respond.

Jews seeking to marry in Israel must provide proof of their Jewish ancestry to register for marriage. In general, this requires the presentation by each prospective spouse of his or her parents’ marriage certificate.

But many people, especially immigrants; people whose parents married abroad; and converts, encounter serious obstacles in this process from local rabbinates, ITIM said.

Advertisement:

If in doubt, the Chief Rabbinate allows local rabbinates to refer a couple to a rabbinical court to clarify the details of their Jewish ancestry through the presentation of various documents, and this is the only authorized address for such matters.

ITIM’s petition said that Wolpe has for years referred such couples to Am Levadad and that he conditions their marriage registration on the company’s approval. Am Levadad charges each couple NIS 250.

“This procedure entails not inconsiderable costs in time and money and, according to the plaintiffs, is accompanied by serious injury to personal dignity, privacy, confidentiality and the right to marry,” the petition claimed.

It demanded that the court ask Wolpe to explain the practice and asked for an interim injunction against the rabbi to prevent him referring anyone else to Am Levadad until the matter has been ruled upon.

The court did not, however, grant the injunction in Thursday’s decision.

In one case involving one of the seven co-plaintiffs with ITIM to the petition, a person seeking to register for marriage who had been formally confirmed by the Tel Aviv Rabbinical Court as Jewish was referred by Wolpe to Am Levadad.

“It is unconscionable for a municipal rabbi not to accept the authority of a rabbinical court,” said ITIM director and Orthodox rabbi Seth Farber. “It’s an outrage that municipal and state taxes go to pay his salary, and the State of Israel needs to have normal marriage registration bureaus which are not controlled by renegade rabbis.

“Allowing Rabbi Wolpe to continue with this practice evinces a complete lack of will to stop isolationists and fundamentalists from imposing their own will on the system,” Farber added.

Wolpe told The Jerusalem Post he had not received any notification of the High Court petition against him and that he did not wish to comment on the matter.

Rabbi Naftali Shraiber, one of the owners of Am Levadad, claimed in conversation with the Post that local rabbinical courts and rabbinates had in the past not carried out sufficient background investigations into people whose Jewish status was in question, and continued to do so.

Am Levadad deals almost exclusively with people originating from the former Soviet Union or the former Eastern bloc.

“Thousands of approval certificates of Jewish status were handed out in the past without sufficient checks, and unfortunately some of them were given to people who were not Jewish,” said Shraiber, himself from the former Soviet Union.

He also argued that rabbinates and rabbinical courts sometimes rule against the advice of their investigators, and that forcing the decision of these bodies on the municipal rabbi was against the law.

Shraiber added that he and the two other Am Levadad employees were experts in the field of clarifying questions of Jewish status, specializing in the history and languages of Jewish communities in FSU.

He added that the firm was a professional organization and that it provided an approachable and pleasant service.

Shraiber added that neither he nor Am Levadad had received notification of the petition.


Content is provided courtesy of the Jerusalem Post


More of today's headlines

New York - A look at some of the famous lines over the years from former New York City Mayor Ed Koch: —"How'm I doing?" —"I'm not the type to get ulcers. I... Washington - Friday's jobs report shows the U.S. economy is improving, but Congress needs to act on policies that promote growth and avoid deep cuts slated to take...

 

Total4

Read Comments (4)  —  Post Yours »

1

 Feb 01, 2013 at 01:29 PM I am not sure Says:

Was there a financial incentive to do this? If not it sounds good to me. I had quite a challenge getting married in EY because my family came to the US after the war and besides being FFB it was hard to prove things. I bear no anger nor animosity to the Rabanut for the hardship.

2

 Feb 01, 2013 at 04:43 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #1  
I am not sure Says:

Was there a financial incentive to do this? If not it sounds good to me. I had quite a challenge getting married in EY because my family came to the US after the war and besides being FFB it was hard to prove things. I bear no anger nor animosity to the Rabanut for the hardship.

Its all part of the hurdles that many yidden encounter when seeking to marry in EY if they cannot provide "documentation". The net outcome is that they simply marry under civil law in Cyprus, somewhere in Europe or the U.S.

3

 Feb 03, 2013 at 12:27 AM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #2  
Anonymous Says:

Its all part of the hurdles that many yidden encounter when seeking to marry in EY if they cannot provide "documentation". The net outcome is that they simply marry under civil law in Cyprus, somewhere in Europe or the U.S.

if they choose to marry under civil law, they obviously don't rely on a rabbi to marry them off kedas moshe v'yisroel. all the more reason for the rabbis to be more stringent in certifying that they are jewish. intermarriage is common in Ukraine, etc. so some of these people are really not jewish.

4

 Feb 03, 2013 at 03:45 AM I_Am_Me Says:

I too married in Israel & had to prove I was Jewish & I understand it. If I want to marry a religious man/woman then I need to prove I am married & I'm thankful for such an idea. Think about it, there are many races that find Israel a haven (ie India, Russia, Africa & others) & sometimes in order to stay in the country, or simply make it easier to stay in the country they find they need to marry a citizen, but if they're not jewish they need to fabricate it & this stops them. On the other hand, if it's a marriage to non religious couples then I understand the problem & think that this should only be for this who want a religious lifestyle &/or marriage, even if it's just slightly

5

Sign-in to post a comment

Scroll Up
Advertisements:

Sell your scrap gold and broken jewelry and earn hard cash sell gold today!