Jerusalem – Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu believes that all Jewish settlers should have the right to remain in their homes in a future Palestine, an official in his office said Sunday, offering a novel approach to one of the stickiest issues in Mideast peace talks.
Subscribe to our Daily Roundup Email
In years of negotiations, it has been assumed that any Jewish settlers not inside Israeli territory under a future peace deal would have to be removed. But Netanyahu believes there is no reason for a future Palestinian state to be “ethnically cleansed,” the official said.
The comments expanded on Netanyahu’s comments over the weekend in Davos, Switzerland, where he told reporters at the World Economic Forum that he did not intend to uproot any Israelis in a peace deal.
More than 500,000 settlers live in the West Bank and east Jerusalem, territories that Israel captured in the 1967 war and which the Palestinians now hope will be part of their future state. East Jerusalem and the West Bank, known to religious Jews as Judea and Samaria, are parts of the biblical land of Israel. Hard-line Israelis object to ceding either area on both spiritual and security grounds.
Netanyahu already has said he wants to retain major settlement “blocs,” home to the vast majority of settlers, as part of any deal. The Palestinians have signaled they would give up their claims to the lands where the blocs are located under a land swap giving them additional territory from what is now inside Israel.
But experts believe roughly 100,000 settlers live outside of these blocs, and their fate under any final peace deal is unclear. Many of these settlers likely would evacuate their homes in return for fair compensation. Others, however, are deeply ideological and would resist any forcible eviction.
The Israeli official said Netanyahu believes there is no reason to uproot them against their will.
“The prime minister believes that in peace, just as Israel has an Arab minority, there is no logical reason why the Palestinian state could not contain a Jewish minority and that Jews living in Judea and Samaria would be given the option to stay,” he said. “It should not be accepted a priori that in peace the Palestinian state must be ethnically cleansed.”
The Israeli official spoke on condition of anonymity because the issue remained under discussion and hadn’t been formally accepted as policy by the government.
The Palestinians consider settlements built beyond the 1967 borders to be illegal land grabs and rejected the idea of incorporating them in a future state.
“Anyone who says he wants to keep settlers in the Palestinian state is actually saying that he doesn’t want a Palestinian state,” Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat said. “No settler will be allowed to stay in the Palestinian state, not even a single one, because settlements are illegal and the presence of the settlers on the occupied lands is illegal.”
Is he kidding me? We should be able to? the settlers would be killed in the blink of an eye!!!!
Just like the settlers at Gush Katif!
brilliant idea. find one settler who is interested in living under arab rule. who would protect them from their beast neighbors? this is laughable plus mr.abbas said palestine cant have jews in it
This just sounds crazy. Which settlers will want to live under palestinian rule. They’ll be dead before you know it. We’re not dealing here exactly with “peace loving people”. Bibi is out of his mind.
I’m pretty sure Netanyahu knows that settlers would not want to live under Palestinian rule (many Palestinians don’t either) and that the Palestinians don’t want them there anyway. It’s part of the political game.
I think Bibi is brilliant. The palestinians will never allow this so there will be no deal.
he obviously doesnt mean it seriously.
hes just trying to expose the hypocrisy of the un, eu, us whitehouse thugs. unfortunately though conceptually netanyahu is right, it does not matter. eisav sone lyaakov, tiime grow a pair, have bitachon in Hashem and make some moves for Israle security instead of waiting forever for the world to go against their ‘nature’.
I think this is a very smart move, he wants to show the world that the Palestinians , by rejecting his proposal , don’t want any peace
Reply to 1,2,3 &4:
What Bibi is doing is pulling their bluff. If they respond that no jews are allowed to be in their territory, then no Arabs should be allowed to remain in Israel. They must then give up their demand for the right to return to their pre ’48 or ’67 homes.
On the other hand they cannot say that they will allow Jews to remain, because it goes against everything they have said until now.
Brilliant negotiating stance.
Bibi has to say this to look “inclusive”. I don’t believe he believes this will happen.
They are not settlers they are Israelis living on israeli land. I hate the word settler
It’s a brilliant move on his part. It puts the shoe squarely on the other foot. Now the Arabs have to defend their position in front of the world as to why they should be allowed to eliminate the Jews.
problem is the olam couldnt care less about jews not being permitted in palestine, or anywhere else. so calling the bluff is smart but not effective
Obviously, Jews now live as minority in Islamic and Christian countries. This is the case now, in the past and will be in the future.