Jerusalem – Rabbi Amnon Yitzhak Says Kidnapping, Rockets On Israel Divine Punishment For Gay Parade

    88

    Jerusalem – A Controversial Israeli Charedi Rabbi says rockets fired toward Tel Aviv by Palestinian terrorists is a punishment by god for holding the Gay pride parade in its city on June 13.

    Join our WhatsApp group

    Subscribe to our Daily Roundup Email


    In his speech given Tuesday night, Rabbi Amnon Yitzhak said “This “punishment is a blessing, because to atone for sins.” “What is happening now – the punishment for what we allow ourselves too much. Precisely because of this, the Almighty sends us Hamas. Violence is rife with the land of Israel,”

    As a confirmation of his words, Rabbi Yitzhak gave the example of the kidnapping and murder of three Israeli teenagers. According to him, killing them on the day of Tel Aviv pride parade is not coincidental.


    Listen to the VINnews podcast on:

    iTunes | Spotify | Google Podcasts | Stitcher | Podbean | Amazon

    Follow VINnews for Breaking News Updates


    Connect with VINnews

    Join our WhatsApp group


    88 Comments
    Most Voted
    Newest Oldest
    Inline Feedbacks
    View all comments
    HeshyEkes
    HeshyEkes
    9 years ago

    Certainly the Gay Parade was an abomination; but to say that that was Hashem’s reason for the killing of the children; how does he know? Did the Ribono Shel Oilem tell him? I’m sure that Amnon Yitzchok believes what he says, but it seems presumptuous when ANYONE claims to speak for G-d. There are no recognized Neviim today.

    hamevakesh
    hamevakesh
    9 years ago

    I guess he knows why these boys were killed Good thing Hashem has him to tell him what to do

    Taxbucky
    Taxbucky
    9 years ago

    Does Amnon feel better now?

    9 years ago

    Sadly, more of our kinder may commit suicide because of his crazy words. And his followers believe him even though they have gay children.

    9 years ago

    We all be leave that this land “Eretz Yosroel” belongs to Hashem. When the people in Eretz Yisroel behave like the people did in “סדום” acting dirty Gay. Then Hashem will Punish like he did to Sedom.

    JamesDean
    JamesDean
    9 years ago

    Can someone ask R’ Amnon to post a סלפי video when he discusses this kind of thing with Shomayim? It would probably improve his credibility.

    9 years ago

    Another know it all. Hashem came to him and told him exactly why this tragedy happened…

    posaikacharon
    posaikacharon
    9 years ago

    bh there are still some leaders among us who are not afraid to speak their minds loud and clear, without trying to be politicaly correct. if he is right or wrong….only hashem knows. but he is entightled to (and possibly, as a leader for multitudes, obligated to) offer his opinion!! on the chance that there is some truth to his words, we should not dare ignore them……

    9 years ago

    This makes the most sense

    MBD358
    MBD358
    9 years ago

    Why does God get a lowercase ‘g’ and gay gets an uppercase ‘G’?

    barbaabba
    barbaabba
    9 years ago

    Never call this clown a “Rabbi”
    NO ONE can say with certainty what G-D is doing and why
    I’m sick and tired of them so called “Rabbis” who feel it is their duty to make a mockery out of the Torah and its real scholars

    viess
    viess
    9 years ago

    “Controversial chariedi Israeli Rabbi” wow OK if you wanna say so do so…
    Its clearly a message from hashem and a punishment, that’s nothing to argue about. Harav Amnan says nothing about that “it” happened “cause” of this!! I just said its a punishment, and that’s very understandable!!

    anonymous613
    Trusted Member
    anonymous613
    9 years ago

    The 3 Israeli boys HY”D were kidnapped on June 12. The parade was June 13th. I don’t know of any source for HKB”H punishing someone before he/she commits the aveira.

    SandmanNY
    SandmanNY
    9 years ago

    If the rockets pointed toward Tel Aviv are because of the gay parade, what do the rockets falling in the south on Sderot and other areas mean? This is an example of how correlation isn’t causation. Just because two things happen in a common time or space doesn’t mean one caused the other.

    9 years ago

    I don’t believe you are actually debating this person’s stupid statements.

    RebKlemson
    RebKlemson
    9 years ago

    everything is cuz of the gays

    bennyt
    bennyt
    9 years ago

    I thought that the Satmar rebbe cornered the market on knowing why Hashem does things.

    TruthIsIt
    TruthIsIt
    9 years ago

    Finally, someone is saying it like it is !

    OpenMindedJew
    OpenMindedJew
    9 years ago

    Well, woo hoo. God came to me to and revealed the secrets of the universe to me. I’ll make millions just step right up and tell me what you want to know.

    GevalDigeh
    GevalDigeh
    9 years ago

    Him and satmar rebbe should go competition on who knows better what Hashem is doing and why he’s doing!!!

    mythoughts
    mythoughts
    9 years ago

    I think its because of gay people not dressing tzniusdik while talking losh horah about rabbonim. Prove me wrong.

    yidmonsey1
    yidmonsey1
    9 years ago

    Let’s not throw put the baby with the bathwater. What he is saying … Re the gay parade is certainly correct. But the quid pro quo? Does he have a direct line.

    9 years ago

    Another elite know-it-all mischief hurts the future condition of hate for the record of Jewish living. It is true that Evil Toevah is not higher form for anyone in this world. However, Torah teaches us that the one who is cursed for their own sin is that person him or herself. Have you not read Deuteronomy Chapter 28?

    Clearly, this is that persons issue. Israel as a whole chooses as its intelligent prayer to let Hashem dictate who will live and who will die. If we let our own conditioned hope get into the idea of banning the wicked from being wicked; perhaps we are going to be blessed; but perhaps Hashem will deem us wicked as well and our entire people can feel the grudge of a G-d who is himself in control and our people who are just playing for our own deceitful plans against the stranger.

    True it is horrendous to see disease and death exonerated, but it is a chivalrous world and we must as Israel strive to keep the winning hope in the trust of Torah Values.
    So let the kiddie fools do their snapper lie. We will just teach our children that our values are True.

    This rabbi is just a placekicker for his own indescribable fear of new cages of pain.

    9 years ago

    Read what Haahem Yisborach said to Moshe in Parshat Haazeenu perek 32. There you will see why this is happening.

    Buchwalter
    Buchwalter
    9 years ago

    Maybe this heiliger rav has answer for the burning, gassing , shooting of a total of 1 million Jewish children by the Nazis, the Einsatzgruppen in Russia and Galicia, and in the gas chambers in Birkenau, Minsk, Treblinka and Belcez

    CommonSense
    CommonSense
    9 years ago

    How does this even make the news?

    9 years ago

    Rabbi Amnon Yitzchok is a million per cent correct. The Bostoner rebbe of har nof said same thing last week. Many of the commentators here are from atheistic blogs who come to make fun of Torah values. The fact is that the gay tel aviv celebration began a week before the Friday gay parade. They were kidnapped Thursday and killed Thursday but the gay flags were flying all over tel aviv. Friday morning as the gay parade began is when the news broke all over israel about the kidnapping. Did they cancel the parade. NO. They could of sent the hundreds of police to search for the boys instead of having them hang out Friday night on the beaches of tel aviv spitting on the Torah with their immoral behavior. We chareidim are also guilty. We allow a gay parade in yerushalayim the last ten years and have not done much. Rav Amnon thank you for having guts while everyone is fast asleep. I wish you would become prime minister.

    9 years ago

    This guy’s comments or opinions are newsworthy? He has been ignored by everyone in responsible positions of the Torah world for a few years already. Why should any media pay attention to him?

    9 years ago

    Ill news. Maybe this rabbi can do some repentance for suggesting that G-d is going to pelt Israel after humanity which has new faces is giving your world new credence. Nemesis evil.

    9 years ago

    Nor does anyone know the identity of moshiach for sure!

    True_Chassid
    True_Chassid
    9 years ago

    Words such as these paint an image of an angry, intolerant and bloodthirsty God, everything which our G-d is not. Rabbi Yitzchak should learn some Chassidus and get in touch with the G-d of Israel and lose the image that he has been promulgating poisonously to others via the media who sadly give him a platform.

    9 years ago

    He is actually correct. If you remember last year something major happened the day of or after that parade. three years ago, the Israelis had a big loss in the war on Lebanon. the war started on the day the parade was scheduled.
    check it out.

    Alzuko
    Alzuko
    9 years ago

    I guess when Jews were killed in Israel in a terrorist attack several years ago on Purim it was a punishment for observing Purim. We are truly fortunate to have in our midst such individuals, who, like Bilaam, are “yodei’ah daas Elyon….”

    yaakov doe
    Member
    yaakov doe
    9 years ago

    A 21st century Navi in our midst!

    9 years ago

    He should move to Iran and be with his soul mates.

    The_Truth
    Noble Member
    The_Truth
    9 years ago

    Other than actually saying ‘this’ happened because of ‘that’ – he is 100% correct in what he has said.
    I actually think he is one of the Gedolei Hador, a Torah True Jew and knows what he is talking about. All the Neveim were mocked in their time, until it was too late. We should listen to our present day Greats.

    Ariel_Gold
    Ariel_Gold
    9 years ago

    Rabbi Amnon Yitzhak–

    Why did you not tell us about the Gay Rights parade before the second and first intifadas. And before Kristallnacht. And before the Chmielnicki-led murders in the Ukraine. And on the eight of Av before the fall of Jerusalem and destruction of the temple.

    And why not explain how God arranged that the lives of three observant yeshiva boys be taken. Since the Rabbi can speak for Hashem, perhaps I can speak for the Rabbi. If Hashem arranged that three gay marchers were kidnapped and murdered, it might not take a brilliant mystic to divine the meaning of Hashem’s actions.

    sissel613
    sissel613
    9 years ago

    look, we all know that this gay business is awful and an abomination. Please remember in the Torah it says “it is an abomination”–it being the things that gay people do. It does NOT say that the person is an abomination.

    I used to like Rabbi Amnon, but in the last number of years, he has come out with statements that I can no longer abide by. Hashem did not have a conversation with him, nor did He appear in a dream. People like him will confuse the population he is attacking even more. There are too many people like that who are otherwise shomer shabbos and mitzvos, but this yetzer hara is something they struggle with every day, I am sure. I would have hoped that Rabbi Amnon would have given them chizzuk instead of the message that he did. If this toevah is mentioned in the Torah, it just shows that this isn’t a new phenomenon, that Hashem understands these issues. so all of you out there, you need to try to be more tolerant towards these people. I’m not saying invite them to your home and introduce them to your children. But bear in mind that in today’s society, no one is exempt from this–it could be your child or grandchild, chalilah.

    yochy
    yochy
    9 years ago

    so all the commentator here think gd does things for no reason? or by mistake? He is suggesting a possibility. so if he is wrong there are others things to improve on. why does every time some suggest something , perhaps a plausible one, as an explanation for something bad that happened all the people jump on him? So maybe we should ignore this and perhaps it was an accident what gd did? no reason. just forget it. Don’t try learn anything. Fools.

    hashomer
    hashomer
    9 years ago

    Evangelical xtian ministers also blame gays for natural disasters. I guess we are more like them every day. Gevalt.

    9 years ago

    Maybe things are happening because people ( so called Rabbis) are talking
    They should learn to keep quiet

    9 years ago

    Perhaps Hashem is doing this because He wants to awaken all his beloved children to do Teshuva for whichever misdeeds may need atonement for. A good start for us all might be to try to rein in the Lashon hara. Just a thought…

    Meekeamcha
    Meekeamcha
    9 years ago

    If someone is inspired to do teshuva because he sees the murder of the three boys on the day of the toeva parade as a sign from Hashem than it was a sign from Hashem!!!!

    Mark Levin
    Mark Levin
    9 years ago

    That’s the problem with this generation. We think we’re smarter than God. We won’t accept mussar from anyone because we “know” better.

    Secular
    Secular
    9 years ago

    … Sefardim…

    FranZ
    FranZ
    9 years ago

    I used to listen to Amnon’s lectures but no more. I think he’s an idiot. What will he do if his own son or daughter turns out to be gay? This same “Rabbi” has said that women shouldn’t drive.

    Shmuelhart
    Shmuelhart
    9 years ago

    It is unfortunate that more Rabbonim are not crying out from the roof tops – or anywhere else where they could be heard – that Hashem HATES public officials who are supportive of homosexuality. Rabbi Amnon Yitzhak’s comments are solidly founded in the Tenach. Those who find fault in this are Reshayim.