Text Size

Email Post

Print Post

Comments (16)

Save Article

And is it even proper, ahead of a court’s final judgment, to refer to the controversy surrounding America’s largest kosher meat processor as a “scandal”?

An Orthodox colleague and I have been debating this. I had expressed outrage over the long list of allegations at Agriprocessors and said they suggest a pattern of worker abuse that is shameful in itself and shaming the Jewish community.

He reminded me that no company officials — owners and managers — have been charged with wrongdoing and that the community has rushed to judgment based on the allegations of hardly disinterested parties. He didn’t specify which ones, but other defenders of Agriprocessors have hinted at dark motives by labor organizers, grandstanding U.S. immigration officials, and non-Orthodox Jews interested in embarrassing the Orthodox or gaining a larger stake in the kosher industry.

And while the courts have yet to speak on the issue, there’s a pattern here. Would a rabbi advise his readers to refrain from a “rush to judgment” if the allegations about Agriprocessors were about kashrut, pure and simple? If there were reports from reputable parties and government officials that a local restaurant or store was violating its kosher supervision, would he tell his folks to keep eating there until due process had run its course?

The engagement and outrage demanded by unmistakable signs of injustice would be stifled if all activism waited on the grind of the justice system. And while we wait for the courts to confirm or deny the well-documented allegations emanating from the press, government agencies, eyewitnesses, and community activists, what of the potential victims? Is there no category in Halacha for intervening in a situation where there is the strong suspicion of bodily or emotional harm?

Great injustices have been remedied in this country thanks to the heroic spadework of investigative journalists, fervent activists, and crusading lawmakers. They don’t have the power to put people behind bars, thank goodness, but they can goad the public to apply the kinds of pressures that will force changes even before the courts have spoken. The labor movement itself, so closely associated with Jews in the first half of the 20th century, is a testament to the power of moral suasion applied by those to whom many courts were actually hostile. The great muckraking journalists inspired revolutionary reforms by publishing exposés that might be condemned under Jewish conceptions of “lashon hara” — harmful gossip.

Agriprocessors certainly deserves it day in court. But something stinks in the state of Iowa, and it’s not too early for kosher consumers to demand higher standards from everyone associated with the industry. At stake is the integrity of kashrut itself — and the credibility of any Jew who quotes the Torah on justice.

More of today's headlines

“Springfield, NJ - Springfield’s observant community marked a milestone with the dedication of a mikva, or ritual bath. Completed on April 30, Mikvah Yisroel of...” Springfield, NJ - First New Kosher 'Mikvah' A Milestone For The Frum Community “Odessa, Ukraine - Jewish community leaders in southern Ukraine have protested to the central government over a real estate project planned on a Holocaust grave site The...” Odessa, Ukraine - Jews Protest Planned Construction on Holocaust Grave Site