Denver, Co - Rabbi Dr. Tzvi Hersh Weinreb’s Address at the Democratic National Convention |
|
How do we understand love, how do we understand neighbor?
Listen to the Audio here
It is best to begin with a story; a two thousand year old story; a story about Hillel, one of the great sages of the Jewish people who was known for his wisdom, for his commitment to study; but, above all, for his patience.
The Talmud relates several stories illustrating the great patience of Hillel. In one of those stories, a Pagan approaches Hillel and tells him that he would like to study, to learn, the entire Torah, all of God’s teachings, while standing on one foot.
But Hillel welcomed the Pagan and said, “Fine. Stand on one foot, and I’ll teach you the entire Torah.” And he told him in his native Aramaic, “Ma da’alach sanei, lechavrach lo sa’aveid. That which is hateful to you do not do unto your neighbor.”
This was Hillel’s understanding of the Biblical “Love thy neighbor as thyself”. “What is hateful to you do not do unto your neighbor.”
But Hillel continued and said, “That’s the entire Torah. That’s all of God’s teachings. The rest is commentary.”
And finally, he said, “Go out and study the commentary.”
The Jewish people, for two thousand years since Hillel, have studied that commentary.
Judaism stresses the need to study lifelong study: “Ki hem chayenu v’orech yameinu. Study is our life, the length of our days.”
What have we, as a people, the Jewish people, learned about this commentary, a commentary on “What is hateful to you do not do unto your neighbor”?
I would like to share some of these teachings that Jews have learned throughout the four corners of the earth and share them with each of you here, with all of you who are listening through the media, directly or indirectly, and with all those whom we will be choosing at this convention to lead us into the future.
Because I think that what the Jewish people have learned throughout the past two thousand years can contribute greatly to our ability to function as loyal and contributing citizens, as grateful citizens to this wonderful nation; but also to share with you a Jewish vision which merges with the vision of the other faiths that have spoken and that will speak and have not spoken today. A vision that will merge with the vision of the true democracy; of true democratic society.
First of all, we have learned who is our neighbor.
Our neighbor is not merely the person who lives next door to us or across the street or even down the lane. Our neighbor may be very distant from us.
Distant geographically. Our neighbor may be a victim of a tsunami halfway across the world. Our neighbors may be the suffering people of Darfur. Our neighbors may be those that are victims of the cruel war now going on in the country of Georgia, so far away geographically. As distant as they are, they are our neighbors.
Our neighbors may be distant from us culturally.
They may be different from us ideologically.
They may be different from us in their color, in their race, in their language, in their behavior, in their dress, but they – each and every one of them is our neighbor.
”What is hateful to yourself,” again, the words of Hillel, “do not do unto your neighbor.”
What does it mean to love your neighbor? The rabbinic commentaries struggle with this. Love? Love is a very precious commodity. It’s been cheapened, perhaps, in literature, in the cinema. But love is the highest of all emotions. Can you expect us to love each and every other neighbor that we have?
Our rabbis teach us to love means to feed and to clothe the poor. Behavior, action, is what counts.
Sometimes our neighbor is poor, and then we must feed and clothe him.
Sometimes our neighbor, she is ill, and then we must cure her and heal her.
Sometimes our neighbor, he is bereaved, and he requires us to console and to comfort him.
And sometimes our neighbor has been traumatized, and then we must render her whole.
Sometimes our neighbors are victims of human violence. And then we, all of us, must unite to do what we can, to transform our culture, to surgically remove from it the violence that permeates our society, that permeates our media, that permeates our literature. We must excise that violence, and we must fashion a culture which is defined by loving kindness and by compassion.
(Crowd calls out “Amen” using standard pronunciation. ) Let’s try the Hebrew “Amen”. “Omein.” Now I feel more at home.
Our neighbor may be unemployed, or she may be unfairly employed, and then we must find her employment or create meaningful employment for her, and we must redress the inequities of the workplace.
And sometimes, our neighbor is ignorant, and then we must educate him or her.
We must educate those who are challenged by poverty, by cultural deprivation, by disability, by illness, by prejudice, by intolerance, by learning difficulties, and by emotional hindrances - we must educate all those who are challenged, whatever they are challenged by.
And we must allow, especially in this pluralistic, diverse, and multicultural society, we must allow for freedom of choice in education so that our neighbor can instill in her children the values of her faith, the language of her people, the culture of her ancestors, the traditions of her family, while not blocking their path to full participation in the society at large.
And sometimes our neighbor is of a different religious faith entirely, and then we, of other faiths, must work together to assure him the ability to worship as he chooses and to conduct his life in accordance with the precepts and customs of his religion in the workplace, in the public space, without shame and without hardship.
I close with the words of one of my personal spiritual heroes, Rabbi Abraham Isaac HaCohen Kook, once along ago the Chief Rabbi in the land of Israel. And he wrote: “Tzadikim gemurim einam kovlim al horah elah mosifim ohr. The truly righteous do not bemoan ignorance; but they spread knowledge and wisdom.”
They are not crippled by doubt or despair, but they inspire faith and encourage hope. And they are not defeated by darkness nor ugliness or evil, for they shed light, they spread beauty, and they promote and foster all that is good.
More of today's headlines
“Jerusalem - Joy erupted throughout Ohel Sarah as news Shmuel Veisfish's release to his home spread Wednesday. His friend Binyomin Blatt was likewise freed after having...”
Jerusalem - 'Mishmeres Hatznius' Claims Victory With The Prison Release Of Its Members
New York - New Miracle Fruit Sweeping The Nation




Total31
Read Comments (31) — Post Yours »
1
Aug 27, 2008 at 12:32 PM Anonymous Says:
Does the esteemed Rabbi also approve the Democratic platform on abortion and gay rights.
2
Aug 27, 2008 at 12:43 PM Anonymous Says:
Why the snide comment, 12:32? Of course Rabbi Weinreb does not approve the Democratic platform on abortion and gay rights. It seems like a great opportunity to convey our values to America.
3
Aug 27, 2008 at 12:49 PM Anonymous Says:
Anon 12:43
If that's the case then why no mention of it in his speech.
4
Aug 27, 2008 at 01:00 PM Anonymous Says:
I think he should have used the opportunity to positively convey that the Jewish definition of marriage is between a man and a woman.
5
Aug 27, 2008 at 01:00 PM anonymous Says:
Terrific messages. Thank you, R. Weinreb!
6
Aug 27, 2008 at 01:03 PM The Constitution Says:
This Rabbi believes in separation of church and state. Abortion and gay rights is a religious issue and should be determined by your church or synogage, not by our government.
If you want to live in a country that the government is controled by religious people move to Iran
7
Aug 27, 2008 at 01:18 PM Torah Yid Says:
It is a shundah that the Rabbi spoke such words at a convention of people devoid of morals and values... A people who support late term abortion, a people who support gay marriage etc... Not to mention we are 100% FORBIDDEN TO TEACH TORAH TO GOYIM!!! chagiga 13a and sanhedrin 49, Rambam and numerous others..
8
Aug 27, 2008 at 01:27 PM Kusnetz Says:
A wasted opportunity: Rabbi Weintraub, representing orthodox Jewry preached love and peace and the most pareve message that no one could take umbrage at. Great for a politician, a wasted opportunity for a representative of am haKadosh. What was the point in all of that? Our charge vis a vis the umos ha'olam is to teach the pillars of a just society: the seven noachide laws. There is surely room for doing that in a respectful way that contrasts the immorality present in much of society with the vision that G-d has for a righteous one. Grade C-.
9
Aug 27, 2008 at 01:31 PM Anonymous Says:
Dear Torah Yid,
How can we be an Ohr L'Goyim if we cannot communicate our values to non-Jews? Rabbi Weinreb used the same formula as Hillel, who answered the Pagan's question by saying "What is hateful to you, do not do to your neighbor." Try not to be a chosid shotah when citing various gemorohs. If it is good enough for Hillel, it's good enough for Rabbi Weinreb.
10
Aug 27, 2008 at 01:34 PM murray Says:
Why would any self-respecting Rabbi want to immerse himself in the filth that is the Democratic Party. Its Not the once respected party of the past, today it is controlled by the liberal,radical extreme left, such as Move-ON.org, Obviously the Republican party is no panacea, and has its extremists, but nothing as destructive to our way of life as the Demon Rats.
11
Aug 27, 2008 at 02:16 PM DUDI Says:
WHAT A BUSHA! THE "RABBINIC" DELEGATION TO THIS DEMOCRATIC CONVENTION CONSISTED IN PART OF MALE AND FEMALE REFORM RABBIS. IT IS A DESPICABLE DISGRACE THAT THESE SO CALLED ORTHODOX RABBIS ATTENDED AND THEREBY APPROVING THIS TRAVESTY. UGGHHHH. THE PRESIDENT OF THE ORTHODOX UNION SHOULD ACCEPT AN INVITATION TO BE PART OF A REFORM -NOT TO MENTION FEMALE REFORM- DELEGATION IS A DISGRACE. HE DOESNT REPRESENT ME IN ANY WAY.
12
Aug 27, 2008 at 02:28 PM Torah Yid Says:
Anonymous 1:31
Some points for you to consider. For one thing, when Hillel said what he did it was to a pagan who came to him because the pagan was interesting in learning the Torah. The DNC is hardly full of people who are asking about Torah because they want to learn and get to know Hashem. This withstanding they do have a free condom booth, which suggests rampant sexual activity like the pagans in Hillels day.
Secondly, Hashem says HE(reapeat HE) will make us a light to goyim NOT that WE are. Do you understand the difference? Thirdly, yermiyahu says the goyim will repent for the lies they inherited and come to recognize Hashem. And remember what the prophet zachariah says, gentiles will grab ahold of the tzitzis of a Jew to learn about Hashem. In other words THEY will come to us after they have admitted they inherited lies (see yermiyahu)of their forefathers.
The way we are a light in the world is by keeping Torah which brings kaddusha in and Hashem closer to the world. Then goyim WHO WANT TO KNOW about Hashem come to us. They become NOAHIDES first, and then if they want become ger tzedek etc... The main point is that it is through a sample that goyim will want to be like us. Not through words but actions.
Lastly, What the rabbi could have done is told a mussar story that wasnt Torah. That wouldnt have broken the prohibition by chazzal to teach Torah to goyim. By teaching the words of Hillel to people who support gay marriage and abortions they will now pevert the emess of Torah. THis is what the xtians and muslims did when they learned Torah. Just think, now a liberal goy can respond to a yid who says gay marriage is against Torah with " Hillel said, what is hateful to you, do not do unto your neighbor." I hope now you can understand my mussar...
13
Aug 27, 2008 at 02:33 PM Baltimorean Says:
Maybe your ignoramus castigating Rabbi Weinreb neaver heard that in Belzec , Sobibor , Teblinka and Birkenau orthodox, non-orthodox were all gassed together and their ashes mingled in the creamtoria. Probably these edle men never heard of adjective pronounced by a gentleman named Baker regarding Jews. They are too ignorant to heave heard of Senators Hickenlooper and Borah violently protesting during WW II the admission of Jews to the U.S. and a gentleman named Breckenridge refusing Jews U.S. visa.
The biggest Hillul Hashem is two brothers of a distinct Hasidic dynasty appearing before N.Y. District Court to settle their claim to hundreds of millions of dollars
14
Aug 27, 2008 at 02:52 PM halachakup Says:
Interesting...Yahoo.com, on their convention page, has videos of all the speakers, but does not have this one?!?!?
15
Aug 27, 2008 at 02:52 PM Baltimorean Says:
why don't these heilige yidden castigating Rabbi Weinreb look at the Neturei Karta website where yidden dressed in the terrorist kefiya are praying with Palestinians for the downfall of Israel. I guess Hamas , Al Aksa and other terrorists will bombard Israel with kosher jelly beans
16
Aug 27, 2008 at 02:57 PM Baltimorean Says:
One of the contributors to this discussion speaks about the Constitution. What a nonsense , Believing is the constitution is treife what is ehrlich is only accepting cash but not a check so we can cheat the IRS, selling treife meat in Monsey and of course cursing Yidden as the Neturei Karta. Talking about Hillul Hashem, how about these characters
17
Aug 27, 2008 at 03:07 PM Baltimorean Says:
I forget to mention that Hizbullah in the future will only murder reform yiden and non-religous Jews, based on the comment I read
18
Aug 27, 2008 at 03:16 PM Disgusted Says:
Anyone care to compliment R. Weinreb on his pitch for private school education / tuition and property tax credit? Nah, I didn't think so. If Moshiach himself personally invited you on a trip to Eretz Yisrael to rebuild the Bais Hamikdash, you all would probably take potshots at his fashion sense, his accent, the shape of his hat, his political naivete, the weather, his insistance on including the yeshivish, the litvish, the chassidish etc. in the geulah. Ahm kishei oreif, a stubborn people? We don't even deserve that nickname. I realize it's fun to snipe on blogs, but you all have turned it into an art form. You deserve yourselves.
19
Aug 27, 2008 at 03:24 PM Milhouse Says:
I'm more concerned that R Weinreb agreed to share a platform with a representative of the Islamic Society of North America, which is a front for the Moslem Brotherhood, and was named as an unindicted conspirator in the biggest terrorist-financing trial in American history.
http://www.nysun.com/national/islamic-groups-named-in-hamas-funding-case/55778/
20
Aug 27, 2008 at 04:44 PM murray Says:
This "esteemed' Rabbi ( I am getting "steamed', myself!)would probably trip all over himself to meet the Pope, as well. When you are in a position such as he, or are thought of as a leader or spokesperson your mere presence at such an event lends it a dignity it doesn't deserve, and gives it an air of respectability and validation. What was the point of it all?
21
Aug 27, 2008 at 05:29 PM DUDI Says:
R U KIDDING ME? First, many gedoilim believed that the holocaust happened to us because of the Maskilim/Reform/neolog. Second, whoever said that Satmar did'nt commit a Hillul Hashem by going to court? What does that have to do with my previous comment? U surely hate Satmar more than the reform!
22
Aug 27, 2008 at 06:03 PM YANKEL Says:
Would all of you critics rather have a reform female "rabbi" speak of her faith and beliefs? Too often the only exposure the general American public to frum Yiddin is negative news.
23
Aug 27, 2008 at 06:17 PM Sid Says:
yankel,
YES I would 100% prefer a reform rabbi speak at the convention instead of ANY Orthodox Rabbi so that WE FRUM NOT be associated with such immoral drek.
24
Aug 27, 2008 at 07:49 PM Baltimorean Says:
The ranting and raving anti-democratic torah yiden do you ever realize that the spare parts for F 16 supplied to Israel come from the goyim in the U.S. , Teva the largest generic drug manufacturer has its largest market in the U.S. and Israeli soft ware companies depend on the U.S. As survivor of Nazi terror who lost in my entire family you should be ashamed of the Hillul Hashem I read on this website. The ad regarding Barak Obama was generating by the same people of the swift boat ads . Jews never had it so good as in this country and the ranting and raving about the goyim is sickening. Shame on you when the Neturei Karta went to the grave of Yassar Araft and has picture with known terrorist who murdered Jewish children. You remind of a posuk eynayim lohem veloi yiru and osnayim lohem veloy yishmuu, shame on you, the ignorance is so gross I am appalled. The immoral drek are some of your contributors. I risked my life with other boys in concentration camp to daven with a minyan and you have the arrogance about speaking of drek. Don't you have any appreciation where you live and instead of associating with the biggest liers
25
Aug 27, 2008 at 09:43 PM Anonymous Says:
It surprises me to learn that the OU aligns itself with the Democratic party, whose values clearly conflict with Torah (lehavdil).
26
Aug 27, 2008 at 09:43 PM anon Says:
Baltimorean,
While I respect what you went through in the shoah I dont respect anything you have written on VIN. What does criticism of Barack Obama, the DNC or goyish values have to do with your time in any camp? Jews have the right to criticize other Jews who cast their lot with goyim who support gay marriage and abortion. Now if you are telling me that you are a supporter of these goyish values then please NEVER daven for me...
27
Aug 28, 2008 at 02:19 AM DUDI Says:
Boltimorean,
u have to stop hating urself so much. We r entitled to our opinions and interests just like any other interest group in this country. What the hec does spare F16 parts have to do with this whole issue? Who cares about Israel? We speak for ourselves as Americans and our domestic interests. The Torah does'nt allow us to align ourselves with reform and conservative "Jews" under any banner!
Why does Teva's dependence on the American consumer mean that we have to endorse a "knecht" who stands for everything immoral? Abortion, Gay rights, etc...
U r disillusioned and It's about time uacknowledged it.
28
Aug 28, 2008 at 03:40 PM the dee Says:
baltamorian Senator Hickenlooper wasnt a senetor until 1945 and Borah died in 1940
29
Aug 28, 2008 at 04:01 PM Anonymous Says:
"And sometimes our neighbor is of a different religious faith entirely". Since when? (See Rambam Hilchos Avel Perek 14:1) Is it the OU the Orthodox Union or the Multi-Faith Union?
In the highest offices of the OU you will find pictures of the Clintons. The Democrat connection has been there for a while.
30
Aug 28, 2008 at 09:10 PM JBC Says:
"Disgusted Says:
Anyone care to compliment R. Weinreb on his pitch for private school education / tuition and property tax credit?"
Great message, but to the wrong crowd. The Democrats for the most part are against that. He should be at the Republican convention for that. I am dissappointed that he chose to align himself with a party that represents almost everything that is opposite of what we believe in. I am in no way a straight Republican but the Democrats have ventured way too left. This will not bode any good.
31
Sep 08, 2008 at 09:19 PM skokie Says:
I do not plan to vote democratic. I, personally, would not have spoken before the convention, because it does give the impression of endorsement. I do not feel this is what was meant, and I do feel the message was a generic one trying to teach mankind in general, especially ourselves. I can only imagine the delicate situation Rabbi Weinreb found himslef in, and I am sure he didn't ask for it. I am sure had the Republican party asked him to speak, he would done so, and still felt uneasy. He doesn't want anyone thinking that he or the OU endorses any one candidate. I feel we are hurting ourselves tremendously by speaking the way we are. Look at history and see how the Rebono Shel Olam has rewarded us in the past for our divisivness, our lashon hara, our hatred towards our fellow Jew. I think it is time to start standing together, speaking with respect, even in dissention, and listen to each other. We can present our views and reasoning without such spiteful words. I respect your right to feel the way you do, but not the way you have aired it.A talmid chacham, a lamdin is only as good as the way he conducts himself and is nothing when he forgets his learning and doesn't act accordingly.