Paris – The late former editor of French weekly Charlie Hebdo condemns “Islamophobia” as thinly disguised racism in a posthumously published book that was completed two days before he was killed in France’s worst terror attack in years.
Join our WhatsApp groupSubscribe to our Daily Roundup Email
Stephane Charbonnier, known as Charb, was one of 12 people killed by gunmen in the Jan. 7 attack against the Paris office of the satirical newspaper. The two attackers, who were apparently motivated by anger over the paper’s caricatures of the Prophet Muhammad, died in a gunfight with police two days later.
Charb’s 88-page book, whose title translates as “Letter to tricksters of Islamophobia who are playing the game of racists,” was released in France on Thursday. It criticizes those who exploit anti-Islam sentiment for their own ends.
Unlike the newspaper, the book contains only words, not caricatures — Charlie Hebdo’s signature offering.
Like the newspaper, known for lewd and often insensitive humor, the book takes on many sacred cows. He pillories the unquestioning use of the term “Islamophobia” by some journalists either out of laziness or commercial interest, and decries politicians who fan what he considers an unfair debate on national identity.
In an opening poem that targets preconceived notions, Charb writes that his intended audience includes those who “think it’s written in the Quran that drawing the Prophet Muhammad is forbidden … think caricaturing a jihadist in a ridiculous position insults Islam … think a drawing is more dangerous than an American drone.”
But Charb also condemns people who demonize Muslims: “If one day all Muslims in France converted to Catholicism … these foreigners or French of foreign origin would still be seen as responsible for all ills,” he wrote.
He suggests that such attitudes should be characterized as “Muslim-o-phobia” — since it amounts to an irrational fear of people — instead of “Islamophobia,” which would be an attitude against a religion.
In what some might consider poignant prescience, Charb muses at one point about how “one day, just for laughs, I should publish all the threat letters that I received at Charlie Hebdo from Catholic fascists and Muslim fascists” alike.
Charbonnier was not Jewish, but he acted like one- alienating his friends and strengthening his enemies because of some wrong-headed liberal philosophy.
The the hapless Charb learned his lesson that Islam must be opposed, but the men who taught hims this lesson killed him as part of the tuition. How ironic!
Also, the title of his pamphlet (they call it a book, but 88 pages?) “Letter to tricksters of Islamophobia who are playing the game of racists,” as almost everything French, makes one’s ears hurt.
Stephane Charbonnier will not be missed, neither for his utter lack of any literary talent, nor for his moral obtuseness.
So when was the last time a catholic fascist shot up a magazine or a museum for their anti-catholic art? Which catholic leader has the equivalent of the fatah against Salman Rushdie floating around for the last 30 years?
Although he is right that the french are xenophobic and bigoted regardless of the underlying issue of Islam.
good riddance.