New York – OpEd: Display The American Flag From Every Jewish Home On The Fourth Of July

    26

    Ezra Friedlander hoisting the American flag on his porch in honor of American Independence Day which is observed on Saturday, July 4th.New York – As July Fourth approaches, I feel it is incumbent upon me to properly acknowledge our national holiday of independence. This is especially significant to us as members of the Jewish American community.

    Join our WhatsApp group

    Subscribe to our Daily Roundup Email


    Human nature being what it is, we tend to criticize, to complain, and to highlight the shortcomings and inadequacies of our system. But it’s the Fourth of July, and while I will admit that the government in this country is far from perfect, it is a far cry better than that of any other country or government in the world.

    The world is in turmoil. There is a real and ever-present danger to Jews in many part of the world. Anti-Semitism is rearing its ugly head and remains largely unrestricted in so many areas. One need not look too far to realize that we can only feel tremendous gratitude that there is a United States of America.

    There are those among us, including many Americans, who criticize the United States. They point to the issue of immigration as one of this country’s great challenges. But I say that we have an immigration issue precisely because this country is so great. The promise of freedom and liberty here is so appealing that everyone wants to come here.

    My friend Senator Marco Rubio, in a recent tribute presented at the Jewish American Heritage Month, reiterated these sentiments: “Ours is not the story of a perfect country or a perfect people,” he said. “But it’s the story of a county and a people who are struggling to be better and we have the freedom here to accomplish that.” He continued to say that, “In every part of the world there are people who were trapped in difficult circumstances in their country and were able to accomplish great things here. Being an American is not just a title. It’s a blessing and along with that it’s a responsibility.”

    As grateful as we are for this country’s benevolence, we sometimes forget that we are still in golus. We don’t have a license to flaunt our successes or to express our dissatisfaction in an excessive manner. Our country allows us to practice our religion and we are thankful for that. But it is incumbent upon us to live in a modest fashion and to conduct ourselves with humility. We need to be careful not to arouse the ire of our neighbors and the general population. There will be times that we will not be successful in achieving our goals, politically or socially. When that happens, let’s not measure our failures by attribute them to anti-Semitism or hatred. Instead, let’s focus on generating goodwill, an affirmative outlook, and a positive demeanor.

    Lest I be misunderstood, let me be clear. Just because we need to recognize the importance of living in a subdued fashion, that doesn’t mean that we need to live a clandestine lifestyle. Living a subdued lifestyle doesn’t mean diminishing our allegiance to Torah. On the contrary. We should proudly demonstrate our commitment to Torah. We are grateful for the freedom that has mandated to us by the Constitution of the United States to live as proud Jews.

    In years past, there was a feeling among many of our brethren that it was necessary to discard the Torah way of life in order to become good Americans. That was unfortunate and today we know that it is simply not true. Being a good Jew and being a good American are two concepts that work very well together. It’s a balancing act that we need to internalize and understand as we approach this Fourth of July.

    As we celebrate this Fourth of July, what goes through my mind? For starters, I believe our community should re-engage ourselves to consider our civic responsibility. That could mean something as simple as registering to vote. Or, perhaps, to engage in civic duty as good upstanding citizens. Let’s recognize that America became the greatest country on this planet because it recognizes innovation and improvement. Our responsibility as citizens is to engage our community in our civic duty while at the same time remaining committed to practicing our Faith.

    Here’s another idea. As proud Americans, why not display the American flag from our windows? How delightful it would be if, when I wake up on the morning on July 4th, I would see the flag proudly fluttering in front of the homes of our fellow Jews in Boro Park, Monsey, Lakewood, Williamsburg, Monroe, and elsewhere. Let there be tens of thousands of American flags waving in our communities, testimony to the fact that we are grateful for what this country has provided us. Let there be no mistake about it. The fact that we have today hundreds of thousands of frum observant families raising our children in the pathways of our ancestors is only possible due to the protection of our constitutional guarantee. Waving the flag, a simple demonstration of patriotism, would serve as a tremendous Kiddush Hashem. The nation at large would understand that we are rooted here in the United States and that we take pride in our country. And that we are willing to contribute as proud, loyal, and productive citizens.

    There are other steps we can take as well. Our youngsters need to be better educated about the history of this great country. We need to allow them to develop a better appreciation of their duty as citizens. We need to teach them to speak and write properly in English. We need to help them develop as contributing members of the society. And the best way to do that is to make them fully cognizant and aware of the workings of our democratic process.

    Finally, let’s bring back the tradition of reciting the ‘Pledge of Allegiance’ in our community’s yeshivos and schools. It’s a practice that was done years ago, but has been abandoned over time. What a difference it would make if our children would recite these timeless words:

    “I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America. And to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under G-d indivisible with liberty and justice for all!”

    These are my thoughts as I sit back and reflect upon the many different ways we as a Jewish community and American citizens can celebrate this upcoming Fourth of July holiday.

    Ezra Friedlander is the CEO of The Friedlander Group, a New York City and Washington DC based Consulting Firm.


    Listen to the VINnews podcast on:

    iTunes | Spotify | Google Podcasts | Stitcher | Podbean | Amazon

    Follow VINnews for Breaking News Updates


    Connect with VINnews

    Join our WhatsApp group


    26 Comments
    Most Voted
    Newest Oldest
    Inline Feedbacks
    View all comments
    Secular
    Secular
    8 years ago

    If you are a proud American, learn English and pay taxes!!

    Shimon
    Shimon
    8 years ago

    Yasher Koach.

    I look forward to wearing my american flag pin on my label and flag cuff links to shul tomorrow.

    We have so much to be thankful for.

    MosesKahan
    MosesKahan
    8 years ago

    Very well. Let me add to your point about “excessive”. We shouldn’t expect or even ask elected officials, Jew or not, to agree with us all the time. It’s not the way it works, especially when it’s not religion related. If some1, once an a while, differs from our opinion he is not the enemy or even an opponent. An elected official who caters us unequally loses my vote.

    8 years ago

    Are you biased? You did not mention modern orthodox neighborhoods like Teaneck five towns Riverdale west Hempstead.

    kehati
    kehati
    8 years ago

    Wonderful op ed. Let’s not also forget that civic duty also extends to serving on a jury, and not seeking every possible excuse to avoid it.

    tehillim_119_72
    tehillim_119_72
    8 years ago

    I wonder if he means the Rainbow American Flags that were very prominent this past week?

    8 years ago

    “Finally, let’s bring back the tradition of reciting the ‘Pledge of Allegiance’ in our community’s yeshivos and schools. It’s a practice that was done years ago, but has been abandoned over time.”

    Did the writer recite it when he attended the Bobover Yeshiva in his youth?

    8 years ago

    “What a difference it would make if our children would recite these timeless words:
    “I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America. And to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under G-d indivisible with liberty and justice for all!”

    One nation under G-d?

    Who are you kidding?

    With the Supreme Court ruling last week, changing the definition of marriage, and legitimizing what G-d called abomination/toeivah in his holy Torah/Bible, how can you say that it is a nation under G-d?

    On the contrary, it is a nation in open rebellion against G-d now (not the whole nation of course, but a significant portion thereof), especially the elites.

    ffopinion
    ffopinion
    8 years ago

    The Rebbes of the Chasidic Yeshivas as well as some Roshei Yeshivas are perpetuating a great injustice by not properly preparing their students to be productive citizens

    Realistic
    Realistic
    8 years ago

    The US is a far cry better than that of “any other country” or government in the world.

    What an overstatement, in what sense is the US better than Canada, Australia, UK, France, Netherlands, Germany, Japan and New Zealand. If anything, the US is more corrupt than all these countries.

    OH, I forgot, the writer of this article is a lobbyist, and for them the legal corruption (read: unlimited campaign donations) allows their industry to flourish, for them the US is really the best it could be.

    For all of us plain people, as a result of this “great country”, we have the tax burden shifted on the middle class, the highest income inequality than any other developed nation, government policies that don’t represent the opinions and needs of most citizens, but just the ones with money.

    These good feelings of being better than anyone else are preventing people from looking at facts in the way they really are

    We do have to appreciate the government we live in, and the freedom they provide us. But thoughts about being better than anyone else, is foolish and childish.

    Anominous
    Anominous
    8 years ago

    As of now, until I understand otherwise (yes, my opinion can change if I gain a better sense), I think we should not have a display of the American flag outside our homes because: 1) Many of us don’t even want to put the flag of Israel because we “are not there yet”, so why should we put the American flag out? Yes, we appreciate America very much and its support of Israel and religion, but we should not be proud to be here, in galus. We have to be happy that America is friendly, but so was Germany. Our main focus should be that “we are not there yet” and not celebrate to be in a land that is not ours, despite all the momentary good that comes from it.
    2) I don’t think that politician opinion will change much by this act. I don’t think Obama and other anti-semites will become more friendly towards Israel by this act; and I don’t think our friends will become more or less friendly by this either.
    3) We are being punished for our lack of love for each other. There is reason to celebrate a land until the punishment is removed.
    4) I think the cheter for being here is due to parnassah, shiduchim and Torah. If you can get all those three in Israel, then you should be living there.

    pinktfarkert
    pinktfarkert
    8 years ago

    While you’re at it, have in mind the Kedoshim from the St. Louis. In case you weren’t good at history…The MS St. Louis was a German ocean liner most notable for a single voyage in 1939, in which her captain, Gustav Schröder, tried to find homes for 915 Jewish refugees from Germany, after they were denied entry to Cuba, the United States and Canada, until finally accepted in various European countries, which were later engulfed in World War II. Historians have estimated that, after their return to Europe, approximately a quarter of the ship’s passengers died in concentration camps. America not only refused their entry but even fired a warning shot to keep them away from Florida’s shores”.

    bsnow
    bsnow
    8 years ago

    I’m not show sure with this anti-America in he White House.

    8 years ago

    To #8 - Your remark was despicable, in lieu of the fact that the photo of Mr. Friedlander clearly shows him raising the Stars and Stripes! Incidentally, after 9/11/01, many Yeshivahs and other frum institutions raised American flags, on their buildings. I personally don&#8 217;t raise an American flag on July 4th, as I keep one permanently in the window of my front door, all year long. Tonight and tomorrow, while my fellow gentile neighbors (and some Yidden) will be celebrating the 4th with fireworks, and parties, I will be going to Shul.

    ffopinion
    ffopinion
    8 years ago

    While the US Govt helps subsidize most of charedi jewry ie boro park, williamsburg, monroe thru section 8 and food-stamps, they dont feel the need to thank the”system”! SHAME!

    ralph1527
    ralph1527
    8 years ago

    This year its a problem though .July 4 is Shabbos , To put it out today before the Zman ?…Not good .Can’t leave the flag out overnight .What to do ? Is it a Melacha to put it out on Shabbos ?Is it Muktza ? This is a question for Rabbi Yair Hoffman .Stay tuned …………No critique please .All for a smile .

    Wise-Guy
    Wise-Guy
    8 years ago

    Btw, I’ve heard, numerous times, Rabbi Avigdor Miller Z”L advise/encourage his listeners to display the U.S. flag on July 4th.

    He didn’t say anything about it being a matter of pride.
    He said it’s a matter of “Hakoros Ha’Tov” (being appreciative).

    Regardless of the faults and shortcomings of the U.S. the fact remains that:

    a) The U.S.’s “report card” is still much better overall than any other country (IMHO).
    b) Many other “good” countries” also have the U.S. to thank for their freedom and/or stability.
    and
    c) Us Jews have never been afforded greater religious freedom and safety (on a permanent basis) in the last 2,000 years!

    So a display of recognition and gratitude (on the day the government established a “birthday celebration”) is proper and in order…..

    mutti
    mutti
    8 years ago

    politics politics politics

    8 years ago

    To #14 -While it is true that the St. Louis was denied permission to land in the USA, it should be noted that the USA sacrificed thousands of soldiers in defeating Germany, during World War Two. Many Yidden were liberated from concentration camps, by American soldiers. On April 29, 1945, while liberating Dachau, the US Army lined up over 100 SS guards against as wall, and killed all of them. General Patton dismissed all charges against those GI’s. Also, the US Army liberated Mauthausen, Buchenwald, and scores of other slave labor camps.

    8 years ago

    Tomorrow is the birthday of the Golden Medinah. Had our zaidahs and their zaidahs emigrated here rather than to the anti-Semitic centers of Eastern Europe, we would have another 10 million yidden in the world today. The Alte Heim may have arguably produced some big talmeidei chachamim but wouldn’t it be wonderful if the biggest yeshivos today were name after Las Vegas, San Francisco and East Hamden rather than Mir and Breslev

    Ha-arah
    Ha-arah
    8 years ago

    I’ll wave an American flag on July fourth, if you write the same article before Yom Ha’arzmaot and tell all the chassidim there to waive the Israeli flag. Whatever you wrote in this article applies to everyone living in Israel. You can publish this article in an israeli news site and just replace the word “America” with “Israel”. Good luck! I’d like to see what happens after you do that.