Welcome, Guest! - or

Jerusalem - Orthodox Jewish Community Tackling The Challenges Of New Technologies

Published on:   Oct 06, 2008 at 04:37 PM
News Source: BBC News
Change text size Text Size  


Jerusalem- When Israeli father Avi tried to register his 6-year-old twin daughters for his local Ultra-Orthodox school this year, he was happy to sign a form saying his children do not watch television or use the internet at home.

But he was surprised to discover he had to give a "kosher cellphone number". He did not have one.

Avi lives in Har Nof, one of the main Ultra-Orthodox, or Haredi, neighbourhoods of Jerusalem.

The community separates itself from mainstream society through its traditional religious practices and distinctive attire of black hats, coats and sidelocks for the men and long skirts and sleeves for the women.

Like most other men in his community, Avi studies the Jewish scriptures daily, keeps the Sabbath and eats only kosher food.

But he has not yet opted for the new religious adaptation to modern technology that has swept the Haredi world in Israel.

Advertisement:

Badge of observance

The kosher cellphone looks like an ordinary cellphone, can make and receive calls, and may have a calculator and alarm clock.

But it cannot send or receive text messages, browse the internet or take photos - all activities that could potentially involve behaviour considered "immodest" among Haredis.

For example, SMS capability could lead to the unwitting receipt of mass text messages publicising secular events. It could also be used as a method of illicit communication between male and female teenagers.

And all photos of women are forbidden, as is accessing websites with content deemed inappropriate.

The phone's other defining feature is a rabbinical stamp of approval, similar to those seen on kosher food items.

One of the defining features of kosher mobiles is a rabbinical stamp
One of the defining features of kosher mobiles is a rabbinical stamp

All the major Israeli cellphone companies have accommodated the powerful Haredi constituency by providing kosher phones, and cheaper-than-normal packages which only connect with other Haredi numbers.

As the companies have created distinct code prefixes to accompany the kosher phone plans, the phone numbers have quickly become a badge of religious observance.

Not only do some Haredi newspapers refuse to publish ads with non-kosher phone numbers, but parents are worried their children will be blacklisted by the shadchan, or matchmaker, if their numbers are not kosher.

Banana filtered

"What do you associate with the Haredi community? You wear black trousers, a white shirt and some sort of hat, but today the things that define you have changed," says Avi.

He says he feels there is a sense that anyone who does not have a kosher phone "should be excluded from society".

"If you say you are associating yourself with us, please act according to our codes, otherwise do not call yourself Haredi and do not send your kids to our schools."

But while they have managed to adapt the cellphone to their lifestyles, Haredis have had a harder time with the internet.

Last year, an Orthodox rabbi and an Israeli technology executive established an internet service provider (ISP) called Rimon, which claims to be the only filtering service provider in Israel that offers customised surfing packages.

The company says it cuts out pornography, violence, and gambling, and then provides the user with five levels of further filtering, from the "protected" level that blocks images of women in intimate apparel to the "hermetic" level, which allows users to view only unchanging, vetted websites like encyclopaedias.

"If your kid puts 'banana' into Google, some of the first sites he'll get are porn," explains Chairman Moshe Weiss. "Put banana into Google on Rimon, and you get all the same sites without the porn."

One Haredi sect, the Belz, which normally forbids online access, has partially endorsed the use of Rimon, but only for those who need the internet for business purposes.

The general rule for the local Haredi community still remains no radio, no TV, no internet and no movies - though Rimon is hoping that once it starts targeting the Haredi market that will change.

For now, its 15,000 subscribers are mostly secular and modern Orthodox.

Self control

Miriam, a teacher living in Jerusalem, is one of many Haredi Jews who do not have home web access.

She expresses concern over the amount of time people devote to surfing the net, wasting time they could spend learning Torah or doing good deeds.

Her main worry, however, is over the lack of control over content.

"There are many things on the internet that are not appropriate for me as a Haredi woman, things I would prefer that my family and I didn't see or hear, like violence, pornography and inappropriate sexual relations," she says.

For Haredis, "inappropriate" means any physical contact between a man and a woman who are not married.

But Avi, who says he needs the internet for his work in the tourist industry, has unfiltered online access.

"I'm not afraid of the negative aspects because I grew up with internet and I feel I can control myself not to use the bad features," he says.

"But do I trust my children?" he wonders aloud.

"When they are old enough to use it I will definitely have to re-evaluate. I think then I might put filters on or use Rimon, or maybe then I'll even disconnect internet from the house altogether. It's just not worth the risk."


More of today's headlines

Crown Heights, NY - The battle lines are being drawn between The People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) organization and the National Committee for... Williamsburg, NY - The application process for 346 affordable rental apartments being constructed has now opened, according to Vincent Abate, chair of Community Board...

 

Total15

Read Comments (15)  —  Post Yours »

1

 Oct 06, 2008 at 05:47 PM Chossid Says:

I just googled banana and there are no inappropriate sites on at least the first three pages. Just sayin.

I'm afraid that the askanim that are responsible for moves like these have absolutely no faith in the ability of yidden to control their taivos.

2

 Oct 06, 2008 at 07:33 PM jj Says:

using religion to make millions is a disgrace. tell them next time that you dont have a cell phone period!

3

 Oct 06, 2008 at 07:12 PM Anonymous Says:

Chossid says: "I'm afraid that the askanim that are responsible for moves like these have absolutely no faith in the ability of yidden to control their taivos."

Actually the Torah itself has had that concern for over 3500 years and this Yom Chamishi at both Shachris and Mincha we will hear once again what the main issues are. The Al Chet's are devoted, more than half, to taivos, because we have no control and need to ask Hashem to forgive us for our humanity. There is nothing wrong with being human. We aren't tzaddikim or malachim. But, we should acknowledge that we all have limits and that our ecceldig Torah leaders are helping us to not exceed those limits.

4

 Oct 06, 2008 at 07:50 PM fahrfrumt Says:

"If your kid puts 'banana' into Google, some of the first sites he'll get are porn," explains Chairman Moshe Weiss.
This guy has got some fantasies. This is just not true.

5

 Oct 06, 2008 at 07:50 PM Stop Telling Us What to do! Says:

I have a regular cellphone with text messaging and internet, and all I use it for is to make and receive phone calls. I am not interested in the other uses and I do not wish to pay for them. I only text my immediate family members if they can't answer the phone when I call them. I don't know what the big deal on kosher phones is all about. Can't the internet or texting be blocked? Some people need the unternet feature for their jobs.

6

 Oct 06, 2008 at 08:26 PM Anonymous Says:

Now you know why we have a shidduch "crisis". We are creating it and making it worse by the day. Soon enough if the family does not wear a burka they wont get a shidduch either.

7

 Oct 06, 2008 at 07:52 PM Anonymous Says:

This was a VERY anti-semitic article, trying to spread hatred of frum people.

8

 Oct 06, 2008 at 10:36 PM robroy560 Says:

Reply to #6  
Anonymous Says:

Now you know why we have a shidduch "crisis". We are creating it and making it worse by the day. Soon enough if the family does not wear a burka they wont get a shidduch either.

What brocha do we make on a kosher cell phone?

Seriosuly, great post... what about computers? If we can't trust man to behave and make the right decisions, we have very serious problems.

Besides, I am always suspect of a few tellign the many what to do. Who is checking up on them?

9

 Oct 07, 2008 at 04:44 AM Anonymous Says:

Moshe Weiss; like many or most kanoim, have a weird attraction to porn.

Try googling banana. The first 40 items that come up have nothing inappropriate on them.

Just another example of kanoim having their head in the sewer 24/7

10

 Oct 07, 2008 at 10:12 AM Yehuda Berlinger Says:

You believe what the BBC writes? Without a single source other than "Avi"?

Yehuda

11

 Oct 07, 2008 at 10:08 AM Anonymous Says:

You can try to shelter your family, but when it's overdone, they just look elsewhere. If they don't have internet at home, then they go to a friend or even to the library. If a boy and girl can't text, then they'll just call eachother more or hang out more. Trust me. I'm a teenager. I know. And I see it more among my friends who are so sheltered that they're just dying to know what's out there. So they go find it in places where there's no supervision at all.

12

 Oct 07, 2008 at 01:24 PM Joseph Says:

All the dirty/horros stories brought down in Tanach happened thousands of years before all these enabling tools. Folks who want to sin will always figure out how to.

13

 Oct 07, 2008 at 02:01 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #4  
fahrfrumt Says:

"If your kid puts 'banana' into Google, some of the first sites he'll get are porn," explains Chairman Moshe Weiss.
This guy has got some fantasies. This is just not true.

I saw "illicit" for cross-gender text-messaging contact, and "inappropriate" defined as physical contact. Did the author mean to distinguish between the two?

With no physical contact through text-messaging, except perhaps a silent ringer, how is it illicit, or any worse than getting a postcard?

According to how these standards are set up, Is there no way for someone with children of each gender for them to share a cell phone or receive instructions by text messaging?

14

 Oct 07, 2008 at 01:58 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #4  
fahrfrumt Says:

"If your kid puts 'banana' into Google, some of the first sites he'll get are porn," explains Chairman Moshe Weiss.
This guy has got some fantasies. This is just not true.

Was the article quoting Rimon's leader as saying they alter the Google output? Or just that they block access to links which Google provides?

15

 Oct 07, 2008 at 10:27 PM bigwheeel Says:

Reply to #1  
Chossid Says:

I just googled banana and there are no inappropriate sites on at least the first three pages. Just sayin.

I'm afraid that the askanim that are responsible for moves like these have absolutely no faith in the ability of yidden to control their taivos.

...Or they have a [financial] ax to grind....!!!

16

If you wish to post anonymously do not fill out this field.
Says:

Your email address will not be published.

Reply to #  
Says:

Important: Please read the rules before submitting your opinion.
Scroll Up
Advertisements: