Mumbai - U.S.: We Have Evidence That Pakistan Army And It's Intelligence Involved In Attack |
|

A resident takes cover as National Security Guard commandos fire at suspected militants holed up at Chabad House in Colaba, Mumbai, Friday, Nov. 28, 2008. (Saurabh Das/AP Photo)
The names of trainers and the places where meticulous training took place are also known to the government, the sources said.
The United States is believed to have even more evidence, some of which it has shared with India, they said.
Chairman of US Joint Chiefs of Staff Admiral Mike Mullen, who was in Pakistan on Wednesday, is believed to have told his Pakistani interlocutors that Washington had enough evidence to show a Pakistani hand in the attack, the sources said.
Sources here also refuse to believe that the Pakistani army did not have knowledge of the Mumbai operation given that ISI is controlled by it.
At the same time, sources do not believe that the civilian government in Pakistan is involved in the attack. In fact, one view is that the civilian government itself may be a target of the strike which may be used by the army to heighten tensions with India to return to power.
Washington has asked Pakistan to crackdown on Lashkar-e-Taiba, which now goes under the name of Jamaat-ud-Dawa, and to arrest its chief Hafiz Mohd Saeed because it has evidence of their involvement in the attack, the sources said.
The attack was planned, equipped and organised in Pakistan where the terrorists were trained and provided logistical support.
Contrary to the version that the terrorists used a hijacked Indian fishing boat to reach Mumbai after sailing from Karachi, the view here is that much more sophisticated means were used.
The sources spoke of a clear disconnect between the Pakistani civilian government and the all-powerful military establishment, which is causing difficulties for India in dealing with the situation.
Islamabad's about-turn on sending the Director General of ISI to India is cited as an instance of this disconnect.
During a telephone conversation Prime Minister Manmohan Singh after the Mumbai attack, President Asif Zardari had referred to an earlier Pakistani proposal for a meeting between the ISI chief and the head of India's external intelligence agency, RAW.
Singh told Zardari that this was acceptable to India, after which Pakistan government had announced that the ISI head would travel to India.
After a post-midnight call on Zardari by Army chief Gen Ashfaque Kayani this decision was reversed with the President taking cover under a "mis-communication" with the Indian prime minister. Instead it was decided to depute a Director-level officer to India.
When the terror attack took place Pakistan Foreign Minister Shah Mehmood Qureshi was in India and had consciously decided not to cut short his visit. However, the Indian government was told at 2.30 am that a special aircraft was being sent less than 4 hours later to take him back to Pakistan.
In what observers see as a clear message to the civilian government, the Pakistan army chief's plane was sent to Delhi to pick up Qureshi, who boarded the flight around 7 am.
The view here is that the Pakistan army is using the current developments as a way out of the difficult situation it faces in the areas bordering Afghanistan where its writ does not run. Some 900 desertions are said to have taken place from the army.
More of today's headlines
“Barack Obama sent condolences to the Chabad-Lubavitch community on the slayings of its emissaries in Mumbai. Rabbi Gavriel and Rivkah Holtzberg "were taken from us by...”
New York - Obama Sends Letter To Chabad
India - Forensic Experts: Several Jews Slain in Mumbai Attacks Brutalized, Suffered



Total11
Read Comments (11) — Post Yours »
1
Dec 04, 2008 at 02:31 PM Anonymous Says:
And India is doing NOTHING about it!!!!!
2
Dec 04, 2008 at 02:50 PM Michal Says:
I wonder whether the US Gov't knew of an impending attack since they have all this evidence on Pakistan.
3
Dec 04, 2008 at 03:16 PM Anonymous Says:
Jews never ecountered anti semitism all the years in India. It took muslims to introduce hate, death and destruction in India.
4
Dec 04, 2008 at 03:11 PM Anonymous Says:
“ I wonder whether the US Gov't knew of an impending attack since they have all this evidence on Pakistan. ”
I would not be surprised at all that the US knew about it in real time (meaning as it was about to happen). With todays tecnology satellites, the US can literally see whats going inside houses as well with thermal imaging. But of course, they will never admit it in case there is real all-out war so that the enemy will not take evasive action.
5
Dec 04, 2008 at 03:06 PM Anonymous Says:
I've said this before, and I'll say it again. When faced with such fanaticism, the only solution is complete vaporization. How did the US win against the suicidal and much more fanatical Japan in WWII? Two atomic bombs did the trick. When 9/11 happened, the US should have given the Taliban an ultimatum that if they did not hand over Bin Laden and his cohorts, the country (Afghanistan) would be completely vaporized. If that would have happened, there would no terrorism for the next thousand years. Guaranteed!! You might ask why kill so many innocents collectively? This is total war, and you do what needs to be done to win. It worked against Japan in WWII and it would've worked right after 9/11.
6
Dec 04, 2008 at 05:39 PM No Einstein, but Says:
“ I would not be surprised at all that the US knew about it in real time (meaning as it was about to happen). With todays tecnology satellites, the US can literally see whats going inside houses as well with thermal imaging. But of course, they will never admit it in case there is real all-out war so that the enemy will not take evasive action. ”
You give too much credit to technology. Thermal imagers cannot see inside buildings, unless the windows are open. In any case, they cannot see inside buildings from orbit.
The US probably was NOT aware of the attack before the fact.
7
Dec 04, 2008 at 05:59 PM MOTTY Says:
“ And India is doing NOTHING about it!!!!! ”
THEY KILLED 9 OUT OF 10 TERRORISTS.....
8
Dec 04, 2008 at 06:15 PM murray Says:
“ THEY KILLED 9 OUT OF 10 TERRORISTS.....
”
You can't be serious. Tell us you are Not saying that the indian response was proportionate, and appropriate. They need to attack at least 100 of the enemy FOR EACH Victim killed. Like the other poster said- (so far) They have done NOTHING!
9
Dec 04, 2008 at 10:04 PM Anonymous Says:
“ I wonder whether the US Gov't knew of an impending attack since they have all this evidence on Pakistan. ”
I didn't read the full atricle, but I saw a headline (maybe in Drudge) that the US warned india about an attack back in October.
10
Dec 05, 2008 at 09:12 AM Moshe Says:
I agree with comment # 9 -
It has been reported that the US warned India twice of an impending attack.
11
Dec 09, 2008 at 02:24 PM awacs Says:
“ You give too much credit to technology. Thermal imagers cannot see inside buildings, unless the windows are open. In any case, they cannot see inside buildings from orbit.
The US probably was NOT aware of the attack before the fact. ”
Telephone conversations, maybe? Radio transmissions?