New York - Ed Koch Slams The Orthodox Community For Denouncing Informant Dwek |
|
New York - The news story that incensed me the most in many years involved the alleged corruption of 44 people in New Jersey, about 15 of whom are identifiable as Jewish. A majority of those arrested were not Jewish. They are accused of various crimes, including money laundering, the selling of body parts, i.e., a kidney for $160,000 while paying the donor $10,000, and other crimes. Three mayors of New Jersey towns were arrested and two have since resigned, but still proclaim their innocence.
Those who will immediately point to our well known maxim of the presumption of innocence until proven guilty, should know that in no way relates to the court of public opinion. We are entitled to have our own opinions on innocence or guilt before the trial based on what we conclude from the media reports on the government charges. The maxim of presumption of innocence relates to the burden of the government to prove its allegations in court beyond a reasonable doubt. The burden of proof is not on the defendant to prove his innocence.
We all know that mistakes are made and that innocent people are on occasion found guilty and criminals occasionally go free. The best example of the public disagreeing with a criminal case outcome would be the O.J. Simpson verdict of not guilty in the case involving the murders of his wife and a young man. So let me say up front that I believe the government will succeed in proving its case against most, if not all, of the defendants.
The Jewish defendants are members of the Syrian-Jewish community living along the Jersey seashore. They were turned in by one of their own members, Solomon Dwek, who cooperated with the police after having been convicted in a different matter.
That is the background for the incident which followed. Dwek’s father, Rabbi Issac Dwek, a prominent member of the Syrian-Jewish community, is reported in the media as having stood up in his synagogue and declared his son to be dead for having denounced a fellow Jew to the police. I was outraged by his actions which were reported in the New York Post as follows:
“Issac Dwek plans to sit shiva for his son because he is so disgusted with his turning on other Jews. The father citing ‘the Talmudic Law of Moser that prohibits a Jew from informing on another Jew to a non-Jew’ renounced his son from the pulpit at his synagogue in Deal, NJ, on Saturday.”
[EDITORS NOTE: Perhaps if Ed Koch did a little research, the story in the NY Post of Rabbi Dwek sitting Shivah was totally erroneous, as reported by VIN News here. Mr Koch before you write up a bashing editorial please verify your information.]
I am familiar with the religious reasoning. Indeed, I believe the killer of Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin made the same outrageous defense of his dastardly deed, claiming Rabin was betraying the Jewish nation to the Arabs.
In countries where the government engages in anti-Semitism, the best illustration would be Czarist Russia, I have no doubt that Jews reluctantly ever helped the Czarist government to punish a fellow Jew and send him to Siberia. I have no doubt that African-Americans in this country during the days of Jim Crow rarely would help the white society injuring them every day to help convict a fellow black. I doubt that many Chechens are cooperating with Russia or its Quisling government against fellow Chechens.
I understand such actions and sympathize with the victims of prejudice and hostility directed at them by the government. But that cannot be a defense in a country like ours where the rights of all of our citizens without regard to race, ethnicity or religion are guaranteed. I call upon the prestigious Board of Rabbis in New York and the Board of Rabbis in New Jersey to denounce Rabbi Issac Dwek for his statement. Those boards, made up of Orthodox, Conservative and Reform rabbis, have an obligation to make clear that it would be unacceptable for a Christian not to cooperate with the police in bringing a Christian who committed a criminal act to justice and that the same rule of law applies to Jews.
We are an ethnic society and, while we are not our brother’s keepers, we do rejoice in their successes and are embarrassed by their crimes. That applies whether we are black, Irish, Jewish, Italian, etc. The law of the land is the law.
More of today's headlines
“Cairns, Australia, - A man who sparked a controversy about a Jewish prayer at an Anzac Day service has been accused of being a fake war veteran. Richard Ben Serai...”
Cairns, Australia, - 'War Hero' Who Sparked Controversy over Jewish Prayer Labelled A Fraud




Total67
Read Comments (67) — Post Yours »
1
Aug 05, 2009 at 07:59 PM halaivi Says:Report as Inappropriate
Who cares what a reform jew has to say about how we should conduct our life. this is the same koch that bought a plot in a non jewish cemetary, and dosen't belive in hashoras hanefesh.
We will follow daas torah not daas koch.
2
Aug 05, 2009 at 08:00 PM halaivi Says:Report as Inappropriate
Who cares what a reform jew has to say about how we should conduct our life. this is the same koch that bought a plot in a non jewish cemetary, and dosen't belive in hashoras hanefesh.
We will follow daas torah not daas koch.
3
Aug 05, 2009 at 08:05 PM tzoorba Says:Report as Inappropriate
He says to follow American law but he ordered that it not be followed in the case of illegal immigrants. He is afflicted with Liberal insanity.
4
Aug 05, 2009 at 08:13 PM formally Says:Report as Inappropriate
problem is you are not following dass Torah there are many who agree with Koch.
By giving such a simple retort you it makes no sense what you say and that he is right.
good for him to stand up and show the world that not all Jews only think about their own kind and believe they are part of a bigger society that has been great for the Jews.
again go to the places where it is written about mosser from gedolim about 500 years ago and you will koch seems to know halcha than many of today's rabbonum.
sad but true
5
Aug 05, 2009 at 08:10 PM Best Koch Line Ever Says:Report as Inappropriate
Meir Kahane was once attacked by Koch as a terrorist.
When asked for his response Kahane replied, "Ed Koch is not a happy man. He may be GAY but he's not happy."
6
Aug 05, 2009 at 08:09 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Why shouldn't he denounce his son that 'set up' a bait for a high religios leader?
7
Aug 05, 2009 at 08:15 PM Yoel Says:Report as Inappropriate
Mayor koch you could still buy a burial plot in a jewish cemertary. You could still do teshuvah ,but untill then do not lecture me on jewish values
8
Aug 05, 2009 at 08:26 PM shlemiel Says:Report as Inappropriate
there's soooo much to answer this article.. ill just touch one of them, Drek didn't "rat" them out, he ENTRAPPED them. even in koch's world where halacha is ignored, entrapping ur own is disgusting & deserves to be sit shiva on.
9
Aug 05, 2009 at 08:25 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Who cares what a reform jew has to say about how we should conduct our life. this is the same koch that bought a plot in a non jewish cemetary, and dosen't belive in hashoras hanefesh.
We will follow daas torah not daas koch. ”
so i guess if a reform jewish doctor diagnoses you with some seious ilness, you would just ignore him . right?
10
Aug 05, 2009 at 08:32 PM KOCH TO TESHIVA Says:Report as Inappropriate
The Torah doesn't change Mr Koch whether you like it or not.Vzos Hatorah lo chai Michalefes.Stick to politics Mr Koch.
11
Aug 05, 2009 at 08:29 PM Derech Eretz Kodmu L'Torah Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Mayor koch you could still buy a burial plot in a jewish cemertary. You could still do teshuvah ,but untill then do not lecture me on jewish values ”
Derech Eretz Kodmu L'Torah
12
Aug 05, 2009 at 09:06 PM Shades of Gray Says:Report as Inappropriate
" I call upon the prestigious Board of Rabbis in New York and the Board of Rabbis in New Jersey to denounce Rabbi Issac Dwek for his statement."
I agree that the former Mayor should have done more research, but I see another point.
The Jewish community has not yet recovered from the shock and the damage done to our image. Right now we need to pull together, and see how we can repair our image, and let our strengths shine to the world.
I understand Mr. Koch's strong feelings, and perhaps I'm nitpicking, but "denouncing" is not what we need at the time.
I think we will look better for the world if we all take more care in our public statements at this time--including us commentators(I include myself!).
13
Aug 05, 2009 at 09:15 PM MDshweks Says:Report as Inappropriate
What's so hard for him to understand that as wrong as those crimes are, if there's Jewish law, and Jewish rabbinical authorithies, it's our obligation to first try to stop them through Rabbinical channals, worning them etc. and not to run to the FBI where they'll be ponished through a man-made law...
14
Aug 05, 2009 at 09:04 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Koch first say what u had deliverd for any jewish comunity when u was mayor then u could start lectureing us about other things that u don't evan practise
15
Aug 05, 2009 at 09:01 PM formally Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ there's soooo much to answer this article.. ill just touch one of them, Drek didn't "rat" them out, he ENTRAPPED them. even in koch's world where halacha is ignored, entrapping ur own is disgusting & deserves to be sit shiva on. ”
again and how many times do peole have to tell you this
the rebbies where on the radar of the FBI for years
Dwek it is on tape telling rabbi Kassan that I have money from illegal activities and from selling counterfeit goods that I need to kosher. He DID not say I need to cash a 25,000 check to feed my family
The rebbies boasted they have done this for years and laundered millions of dollars.
Their own word incriminate them.
No where did dwek beg them to cash the check to feed his family that is an urban myth. To feed your family you cash a 500 dollar check not 25,000.
I wish if the rabbies where really innocent I could not be happier, but I cannot and will not blind myself to the writing on the wall and the vast amount of evidence
Also I would like quote where exactly does it say in the Torah about mosser
16
Aug 05, 2009 at 09:00 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Ed Koch doesn't come to Rabbi Dweck's toenails in Jewish knowledge, in middos tovos, in Torah scholarship, in self-sacrifice for his fellow Jews. Who is HE to give n opinion on this matter anyway? Really not even worth my breath to comment on such an outrageous editorial. He must be bored....
17
Aug 05, 2009 at 08:50 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ so i guess if a reform jewish doctor diagnoses you with some seious ilness, you would just ignore him . right? ”
but if the doctor says your hairstyle is old you ignore him the point being halacha isnt exactly his expertise shoemaker not more than the shoes
18
Aug 05, 2009 at 08:36 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
i guess the burial place he bought is the society where he belongs.
19
Aug 05, 2009 at 09:21 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
You say that Rabbi Dwek did not sit shiva.... but I heard him on an audio recording, where he says "a former member of my family" and then says "Baruch Dayan Emett" which is a typical phrase used when someone has "died". If someone can clarify this please do.
20
Aug 05, 2009 at 09:48 PM bingo Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ i guess the burial place he bought is the society where he belongs. ”
You said it right and with the perfect phrase !!
21
Aug 05, 2009 at 09:34 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
It is irrelevant what Koch's level of Jewish observance is or what his sexual orientation is; as the former 2 term mayor of the great city of New York we should all listen to what he has to say and show him some Kavod, whether we agree with him or not.
22
Aug 05, 2009 at 09:32 PM Hmm.. Entrap Koch? ;) Says:Report as Inappropriate
Let's see someone entrapping Koch and his family and then we'll see how he feels about it, its very easy to judge others.
23
Aug 05, 2009 at 10:04 PM a reader Says:Report as Inappropriate
'kabel es ha'emes mi'mi she'amro' - accept the truth from whoever says it.
bottom line - kotch is right. there is no excuse in this case for breaking the law. all of the personal attacks on kotch (calling him 'liberal', etc.) do not take away from the truth of his message, just as the 'righteousness' of the rabbis does not make their crimes any better.
instead of responding with nonsensical knee-jerk defenses ('mosser!', etc.), we should all take a step back and cry in shame from the fact that even after this horrific chillul hashem, we still have not learned the lesson. we keep perpetuating it by blaming the messenger, as opposed to doing the serious cheshbon hanefesh we sorely need.
24
Aug 05, 2009 at 09:42 PM sumgai Says:Report as Inappropriate
rabin's killer made the same defense because it is an accurate defense al pi torah. no way is some reform jew going to pasken halocha! dwek is guilty of mesira, and there's no two ways about it.
25
Aug 05, 2009 at 09:36 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Who cares what a reform jew has to say about how we should conduct our life. this is the same koch that bought a plot in a non jewish cemetary, and dosen't belive in hashoras hanefesh.
We will follow daas torah not daas koch. ”
You may not care what a reform jew has to say because you follow daas torah, but yet it dosen't change the fact that the way all these being arrested acted was definately not daas torah
26
Aug 05, 2009 at 10:14 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
so koch wakes up when he can critisize the orthdox with idiots like him who needs enemys he is a sinile old bag let him go back to the nursing home
27
Aug 05, 2009 at 10:26 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ again and how many times do peole have to tell you this
the rebbies where on the radar of the FBI for years
Dwek it is on tape telling rabbi Kassan that I have money from illegal activities and from selling counterfeit goods that I need to kosher. He DID not say I need to cash a 25,000 check to feed my family
The rebbies boasted they have done this for years and laundered millions of dollars.
Their own word incriminate them.
No where did dwek beg them to cash the check to feed his family that is an urban myth. To feed your family you cash a 500 dollar check not 25,000.
I wish if the rabbies where really innocent I could not be happier, but I cannot and will not blind myself to the writing on the wall and the vast amount of evidence
Also I would like quote where exactly does it say in the Torah about mosser
”
Please read the indictment of Rabbi Kassin it is on the internet. B4 making your stupid comment.He said he was in bankrupcy & had a wife & five kids to feed & no monet=y was to be on his name. They are going after him for aiding a bankrupt guy. He spoke about Guci & Parad the Rabbi doesn't know what they are though they where his brand name.The have nothing on the Rabbi.Look B4 writting.
28
Aug 05, 2009 at 10:43 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ You say that Rabbi Dwek did not sit shiva.... but I heard him on an audio recording, where he says "a former member of my family" and then says "Baruch Dayan Emett" which is a typical phrase used when someone has "died". If someone can clarify this please do. ”
Boruch Dayan Emes is said upon hearing any bad news
29
Aug 06, 2009 at 12:25 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
What is amazing here is how everyone is bashing Koch. Koch is literally repeating what daas torah said at the asifa last week in boro park. Look at the video.
So much for bashing the former mayor when the guy is making sense. The only part where koch is wrong is with the fatehr sitting shiva for his son.
Even here the orginal reporting was a mistake but was corrected upon by vosizneias so credit to vosizneias for getting the story correct.
30
Aug 06, 2009 at 12:23 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Dear ex-mayor Koch, its ironic that you are calling on NYBOR to denounce the frum yidden. We frum yidden are not affiliated with NYBOR, nor do we care what they stand for. They accept people who are not born to a Jewish mother as yidden. Torah Jews who live a torah lifestyle don't......
We denounced you while you were mayor and we don't look to you now for Hashkafa either.
The New York Board of Rabbis has recently given a statement regarding the arrest of the Rabbis, but when a so called "Rabbi" of their own office was arrested by an online FBI sting I don't remember a statement from them denouncing that Chilul Hashem....
Mr Koch, we wish you well on your recuperation from Cardiac Surgery, but its time to find room in your heart not to denounce others without doing your due diligence.... Since Rabbi Dwek didn't denounce his son either. Please continue with your physical rehabilitation and leave torah issues to the true torah scholars who know the Dinim of Mesirah!
31
Aug 06, 2009 at 12:01 AM Shlomo Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ It is irrelevant what Koch's level of Jewish observance is or what his sexual orientation is; as the former 2 term mayor of the great city of New York we should all listen to what he has to say and show him some Kavod, whether we agree with him or not. ”
Correction Sir: Koch was a three term Mayor. He served as Mayor of NYC for 12 consecutive years.
32
Aug 05, 2009 at 11:58 PM Liepa Says:Report as Inappropriate
This is the same Ed Koch that once approached a chasidishe yid in full garb, in the subway and said, Why would you still wear these old fashioned jewish clothes in this day and age. The person responded.I'm not jewish I'm Amish. In then case it's ok, Koch responded.
33
Aug 05, 2009 at 11:36 PM stormin Says:Report as Inappropriate
siyog Lchochma shitika
34
Aug 06, 2009 at 12:31 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ again and how many times do peole have to tell you this
the rebbies where on the radar of the FBI for years
Dwek it is on tape telling rabbi Kassan that I have money from illegal activities and from selling counterfeit goods that I need to kosher. He DID not say I need to cash a 25,000 check to feed my family
The rebbies boasted they have done this for years and laundered millions of dollars.
Their own word incriminate them.
No where did dwek beg them to cash the check to feed his family that is an urban myth. To feed your family you cash a 500 dollar check not 25,000.
I wish if the rabbies where really innocent I could not be happier, but I cannot and will not blind myself to the writing on the wall and the vast amount of evidence
Also I would like quote where exactly does it say in the Torah about mosser
”
The fact is that he went to people begging to cash checks he went to some ppl who never did this before and if they didn't wanna do it he cried he has a family etc and what u said 500 not 25000 yes the 25k he gets 500 in pocket however regarding messireh I think it says on a musser " who ever kills him the first has no blood on his hand" I am not possitive but if someone knows this mamar chazal please correct me
35
Aug 05, 2009 at 11:12 PM Charlie Hall Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ What's so hard for him to understand that as wrong as those crimes are, if there's Jewish law, and Jewish rabbinical authorithies, it's our obligation to first try to stop them through Rabbinical channals, worning them etc. and not to run to the FBI where they'll be ponished through a man-made law... ”
What would you do if it is the Rabbinical channels themselves who are violating halachah and secular law?
36
Aug 05, 2009 at 11:11 PM Charlie Hall Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ He says to follow American law but he ordered that it not be followed in the case of illegal immigrants. He is afflicted with Liberal insanity. ”
Would that more people had not followed American law in the case of illegal immigrants between 1933 and 1945.
37
Aug 06, 2009 at 04:35 AM Knowing Halacha! Says:Report as Inappropriate
Fools!
If any of the rabbanim knew the level of fraud going on, they would not need coercion from the FBI to get them to inform. The halacha is clear!
I would have gone straight to the authorities!
We can not allow 'chamas' to prevail in our society!
That is the utter breakdown of culture! (See medrash Rabba in beg. of parshas Noach)!
38
Aug 06, 2009 at 02:58 AM Heimishe Yid Says:Report as Inappropriate
Dear Mr. Ed. Koch,
I am addressing this to you Mr. former Mayor of the greatest city in the world. I am addressing this to You Mr. Ed Koch, who is a Jew, who's mother is a jew, who's grandmother and great grandmother was jewish and so on. You Mr. Koch who recently suffered a major heart attack and survived. You Mr. Koch who went ahead and purchased a plot in a non'jewish cemetery. Where is your "pintele" yid? Where is your "spark" of being a jew? Is this what you truly want? Doesn't your heart, your soul, yearn to be buried with others who share your heritage? Whose mother brought you on this world as a jew and your soul will go back to its maker as a jew? Or are you so embarrased of your life that you do not feel worthy to lie between other jews? Yes, look back in history and see how much Jews have suffered and gave up their lives, so that they can be buried amongst jews! We are all here today and gone tomorrow, we are all born on this world to fulfill our mission. While we are alive we have a chance to change, correct, and fulfill our duties as a "Jew". However once we die as we all must, all the mistakes we have made in our lives can not be corrected. Mr. Ed Koch,this issue has nothing to do if you are religious or not. You are a Jew, as a jew you have an obligation to your heritage, to yourself, and to your mother,grand mother, great grandmother to be buried as a jew in a Jewish Cemetery! Its still not to late, go ahead I challenge you! Buy a plot in a jewish cemetery!
39
Aug 06, 2009 at 06:36 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
38,
Koch saw what terrible conditions Jewish cemeteries are in so he didn't want to be buried in one.
40
Aug 06, 2009 at 06:34 AM me Says:Report as Inappropriate
For the most part Dwek did inform on criminals. he created crimes. He went around to politicians and offered "contributions in exchange for favors. others he offered bribes. There no report that a politician solicited a bribe that Dwek then provided. he went to gemach that are set up to aid needy people. if he said "here's $100,000 cash, deposit in the gemach." The gemach has no requirement to ask where it came from. If he says "here's $100,000 that I made in the insurance scam in LA". The gemach has now become an accessory after the fact to a crime in LA. If he says "hold this in the gemach so i don't have to pay taxes on it". The Gemach has now become an accomplice to income tax evasion, even if the guy taking the money doesn't speak English and has no idea what he said. Dwek is no tzaddik HE COMMITTED CRIMES AND ATTEMPTED TO EASE HIS CRIME BY ENTICING OTHERS TO COMMIT CRIMES, THAT IS THE LOWEST OF THE LOW.
41
Aug 06, 2009 at 06:58 AM Avi Segal Says:Report as Inappropriate
Koch is right! Dwek is not a moser. He is worse then a moser. A din moser is only m'din d'gemorah. Dwek, however, trampled a d'oraysoh. "Lifnei iver lo sitain michshol". That is a posuk that even children know. Of course the posuk concludes "v'yoraisah m'Elokecho", something that Koch has zilch of. What do you expect of such a maskil sterile of any trace of yiras shomayim, Torah and kedusha?
42
Aug 06, 2009 at 01:14 AM EMES Says:Report as Inappropriate
are'nt you all a bunch of idiots ! who cares what koch says or don't say ? who is he ? is he represnting anybody ? exuse me , a ALTER NAR , with a big mouth
43
Aug 06, 2009 at 07:38 AM formally Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ For the most part Dwek did inform on criminals. he created crimes. He went around to politicians and offered "contributions in exchange for favors. others he offered bribes. There no report that a politician solicited a bribe that Dwek then provided. he went to gemach that are set up to aid needy people. if he said "here's $100,000 cash, deposit in the gemach." The gemach has no requirement to ask where it came from. If he says "here's $100,000 that I made in the insurance scam in LA". The gemach has now become an accessory after the fact to a crime in LA. If he says "hold this in the gemach so i don't have to pay taxes on it". The Gemach has now become an accomplice to income tax evasion, even if the guy taking the money doesn't speak English and has no idea what he said. Dwek is no tzaddik HE COMMITTED CRIMES AND ATTEMPTED TO EASE HIS CRIME BY ENTICING OTHERS TO COMMIT CRIMES, THAT IS THE LOWEST OF THE LOW. ”
let see maybe just maybe they could have said no we do not do this, but they didn't.
also they themselves in their own words say we have been doing this for a long time. So they where criminals before he showed up.
But I understand you view and realize no amount o evidence will convince some.
Just like no amount of evidence will convince some that men went to the moon.
I think that some on this board as so deceiving themselves that if hashem comes
down and say they are guilty. You would say this cannot be hashem since we all know they are innocent therefore this is not hashem
44
Aug 06, 2009 at 07:31 AM formally Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ The fact is that he went to people begging to cash checks he went to some ppl who never did this before and if they didn't wanna do it he cried he has a family etc and what u said 500 not 25000 yes the 25k he gets 500 in pocket however regarding messireh I think it says on a musser " who ever kills him the first has no blood on his hand" I am not possitive but if someone knows this mamar chazal please correct me ”
and to #40
again I have real evidence on my side tapes of the discussion where dwek said "I need to kosher money I got this money by criminal acts
and selling counterfeit goods" the rebbies then said OK. Some said we have been doing this for years and making a lot of money .
This is all on tape in their own voice nowhere in the tapes did not say I need money to feed my family. And nowhere did he beg. Please where did you get information on a private conversation.
Where did you hear that from, from someone who heard it from but no evidence to support your theory. Is a nice dream, you have. It nice to convince yourself that they did it just so he can feed his family, does not make it true.
As I stated in other post every time and I mean every time, when a frum yid got arrested, on this board some made things up, gave excuses and said it never happened. Even in the cases when a yid accused a yid, like in the molestation cases. It did not happen, the boy is just mad and the rebbie, he misunderstood
a hug. In every case it turned out that the accused was guilty.
so believe what you want, but if I close my eyes now does not mean I am not in front of a computer because I cannot see it. So with you close your eyes does not change the facts in the case.
45
Aug 06, 2009 at 08:16 AM David Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ so i guess if a reform jewish doctor diagnoses you with some seious ilness, you would just ignore him . right? ”
Well, if the reform jewish doctor would be an expert in his field, of course I will listen, to him,,,,,But what makes this self hating jew, Koch, an expert in Hilchus Mesirah.
46
Aug 06, 2009 at 08:30 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ and to #40
again I have real evidence on my side tapes of the discussion where dwek said "I need to kosher money I got this money by criminal acts
and selling counterfeit goods" the rebbies then said OK. Some said we have been doing this for years and making a lot of money .
This is all on tape in their own voice nowhere in the tapes did not say I need money to feed my family. And nowhere did he beg. Please where did you get information on a private conversation.
Where did you hear that from, from someone who heard it from but no evidence to support your theory. Is a nice dream, you have. It nice to convince yourself that they did it just so he can feed his family, does not make it true.
As I stated in other post every time and I mean every time, when a frum yid got arrested, on this board some made things up, gave excuses and said it never happened. Even in the cases when a yid accused a yid, like in the molestation cases. It did not happen, the boy is just mad and the rebbie, he misunderstood
a hug. In every case it turned out that the accused was guilty.
so believe what you want, but if I close my eyes now does not mean I am not in front of a computer because I cannot see it. So with you close your eyes does not change the facts in the case. ”
You were given all the tapes by the FBI, I see , .How do you know it's the whole clip,or there wasn't a prior coversation?You ignore what rabbi Dovid yosef said about dwek's coming to him.
47
Aug 06, 2009 at 08:45 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
What if his father wasnt a Rabbi but a plain Jew and he decided to sit shiva (which he didnt). WOuld Koch still request the BOR to censure him? This is the disappointment of a father to a son, not a Rabbi to a son. Anyway, Koch, you are getting senile so keep your own counsel. No one wants to hear you anymore.
48
Aug 06, 2009 at 09:33 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ again and how many times do peole have to tell you this
the rebbies where on the radar of the FBI for years
Dwek it is on tape telling rabbi Kassan that I have money from illegal activities and from selling counterfeit goods that I need to kosher. He DID not say I need to cash a 25,000 check to feed my family
The rebbies boasted they have done this for years and laundered millions of dollars.
Their own word incriminate them.
No where did dwek beg them to cash the check to feed his family that is an urban myth. To feed your family you cash a 500 dollar check not 25,000.
I wish if the rabbies where really innocent I could not be happier, but I cannot and will not blind myself to the writing on the wall and the vast amount of evidence
Also I would like quote where exactly does it say in the Torah about mosser
”
Please see Gittin 7b and Bava Kama 117b to start with.
49
Aug 06, 2009 at 09:41 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ so i guess if a reform jewish doctor diagnoses you with some seious ilness, you would just ignore him . right? ”
orthodox jews should most certainly make sure to ignore what a reformed jewish doctor says, since most if not all of them have no regard towards jewish life values whatsoever. how many doctors pressure innocent families to unplug patients when it is simply retzicha!!!!
50
Aug 06, 2009 at 10:34 AM fhu Says:Report as Inappropriate
Who really cares what Koch says when it comes to matters pertaining to the Jewish religion. this is a totally totally assimilated jew who is being buried in a goyishe cemetery according to his own will.
51
Aug 06, 2009 at 10:44 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
"Those who will immediately point to our well known maxim of the presumption of innocence until proven guilty, should know that in no way relates to the court of public opinion. We are entitled to have our own opinions on innocence or guilt before the trial based on what we conclude from the media reports on the government charges."
Yes: but you are a old jew hatter so your opinion counts for zilch.
52
Aug 06, 2009 at 11:23 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Mayor Koch? aha, and what does Mayor Dinkins say?
53
Aug 06, 2009 at 11:29 AM Always guilty?? Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ and to #40
again I have real evidence on my side tapes of the discussion where dwek said "I need to kosher money I got this money by criminal acts
and selling counterfeit goods" the rebbies then said OK. Some said we have been doing this for years and making a lot of money .
This is all on tape in their own voice nowhere in the tapes did not say I need money to feed my family. And nowhere did he beg. Please where did you get information on a private conversation.
Where did you hear that from, from someone who heard it from but no evidence to support your theory. Is a nice dream, you have. It nice to convince yourself that they did it just so he can feed his family, does not make it true.
As I stated in other post every time and I mean every time, when a frum yid got arrested, on this board some made things up, gave excuses and said it never happened. Even in the cases when a yid accused a yid, like in the molestation cases. It did not happen, the boy is just mad and the rebbie, he misunderstood
a hug. In every case it turned out that the accused was guilty.
so believe what you want, but if I close my eyes now does not mean I am not in front of a computer because I cannot see it. So with you close your eyes does not change the facts in the case. ”
Interesting how you always find frum jews to be guilty, always!! in every case, non related one to another, the observant jew would be guilty in your eyes. can you recall in jewish history atleast one instance when jews were innocent? or your hate won't allow this action..?
54
Aug 06, 2009 at 11:37 AM NY Says:Report as Inappropriate
Why is Koch defending Dwek? That is the biggest question of all.
55
Aug 06, 2009 at 11:49 AM formally Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ You were given all the tapes by the FBI, I see , .How do you know it's the whole clip,or there wasn't a prior coversation?You ignore what rabbi Dovid yosef said about dwek's coming to him. ”
No, but i quote from what I read, the defense will be given all the tapes and we will see if dwerk begged, will see if that is part of legal defense. I think not.
You on the other hand are making an assumption with no shred of evidence at all. You have nothing to support you story nothing.
even if it is true what you say (and again you have no bases for it) explain the quote I need it to kosher money, and the rebbies saying they have laundered millions of dollars already for tyhe last few years
56
Aug 06, 2009 at 11:47 AM Shamry Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ and to #40
again I have real evidence on my side tapes of the discussion where dwek said "I need to kosher money I got this money by criminal acts
and selling counterfeit goods" the rebbies then said OK. Some said we have been doing this for years and making a lot of money .
This is all on tape in their own voice nowhere in the tapes did not say I need money to feed my family. And nowhere did he beg. Please where did you get information on a private conversation.
Where did you hear that from, from someone who heard it from but no evidence to support your theory. Is a nice dream, you have. It nice to convince yourself that they did it just so he can feed his family, does not make it true.
As I stated in other post every time and I mean every time, when a frum yid got arrested, on this board some made things up, gave excuses and said it never happened. Even in the cases when a yid accused a yid, like in the molestation cases. It did not happen, the boy is just mad and the rebbie, he misunderstood
a hug. In every case it turned out that the accused was guilty.
so believe what you want, but if I close my eyes now does not mean I am not in front of a computer because I cannot see it. So with you close your eyes does not change the facts in the case. ”
Lot of good points, But Dwek is still a Mosser and Mr. Dwek's Father has all the rights to be upset and condem his son for this terrible behavior casuing this big chilul hashem, let Mr. RIP no need to defnd him
57
Aug 06, 2009 at 11:43 AM formally Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Interesting how you always find frum jews to be guilty, always!! in every case, non related one to another, the observant jew would be guilty in your eyes. can you recall in jewish history atleast one instance when jews were innocent? or your hate won't allow this action..? ”
That is what I am asking you, also I am talking about the major cases that one that make the newspapers not very single case, of course the police and prosecutors make mistakes or sometimes they are evil, Jews defendant or not. but in the case that we speak about here are usually major cases with overwhelming evidence.
So i will ask you again and to others in the last few years when it was a major case please name me one that the person was innocent and or found not guilty.
So far no one has taken the challenge.
Like I said I rather that they be innocent but I am not an idiot when I see the writing on the wall. And I went to yeshiva and I saw for myself how honest the rebbie where (sarcastic)
58
Aug 06, 2009 at 11:42 AM Salmon Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ 'kabel es ha'emes mi'mi she'amro' - accept the truth from whoever says it.
bottom line - kotch is right. there is no excuse in this case for breaking the law. all of the personal attacks on kotch (calling him 'liberal', etc.) do not take away from the truth of his message, just as the 'righteousness' of the rabbis does not make their crimes any better.
instead of responding with nonsensical knee-jerk defenses ('mosser!', etc.), we should all take a step back and cry in shame from the fact that even after this horrific chillul hashem, we still have not learned the lesson. we keep perpetuating it by blaming the messenger, as opposed to doing the serious cheshbon hanefesh we sorely need. ”
Sir - Chilul Heshem was caused by the Mosser, Beside the Point while Katch could of insist that we need to obey the law, he just decided to bash the Jewish religion of denouncing a Mosser, While all you points that we need to be good may be right, thats still don't change the fact that this Dwek is a Mosser and heads up to his father for denouncing him, and Shame on Katch fo disliking jewish law.
59
Aug 06, 2009 at 12:09 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Interesting how you always find frum jews to be guilty, always!! in every case, non related one to another, the observant jew would be guilty in your eyes. can you recall in jewish history atleast one instance when jews were innocent? or your hate won't allow this action..? ”
So well said! there are a few commentators that appear just to be sitting and waiting when some new "news flash" about frum yidden would be released,so they should be able to start pouring their hate and besmirch the charedi communities, accusing them full force, sometimes they would write such non sense, but it obviously has no boundaries since it has one and the same goal.
60
Aug 06, 2009 at 12:17 PM formally Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Interesting how you always find frum jews to be guilty, always!! in every case, non related one to another, the observant jew would be guilty in your eyes. can you recall in jewish history atleast one instance when jews were innocent? or your hate won't allow this action..? ”
no, true I do not know what is going on in the skver camp maybe the county is nitpicking I do not know, or some other cases where the situation in murky like some on the zoning issues etc. Or, in a regular case involving a yid that does not make the papers. But we do not discuss everyday cases here.
But when faced with insurmountable evidence whether in the kolco case Mondrowitz, the lunch programs frauds from years age, the nursing home scandal I could go on and on what am I supposed to do. Am I supposed to suspend realty suspend my mind and live in a fantasy world that it did not happen. Am I supposed to block out of my mind the stuff I saw as a kid what the yeshivas where doing sorry I do not work that way.
Maybe you think Kolco is innocent, mondrowitz, and all the other frum yiddin who where arrested and convicted. of crimes. The starving mom from Israel.
The real shame of all these stories, is not that a few yiddin did criminal acts,
The real shame and tragic part of these stories is that many in the community will fool themselves, make up stories that have no basis in realty or logic and just think these things do not happen in our community. And then of course do nothing to stop it from happening again , since it never happened at all.
One must first be willing to admit that there is a problem and only then can one apply efforts to fix it.
But some want to live in fantasy land that all frum yiddin are angel, and if accused it is antisemitism or other ridiculous reasoning. This is why frauds was happening and rebbies where getting arrested and put in jail when I was a kid and this is why when your grandchildren go to yeshiva it will happen again, since no one whats to fix a problem that does not exist.
61
Aug 06, 2009 at 12:31 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
kochs grandfather would also sit shiva for him have you ever seen a picture of him
62
Aug 06, 2009 at 01:17 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Let's see someone entrapping Koch and his family and then we'll see how he feels about it, its very easy to judge others. ”
Even though you still continue to use the phrase "entrapment" completely wrong.......Why cant you understand the if someone tried to get you to do something illegal and you chose to do it, you are guilty. It is you who has to make the decision of right and wrong when you are challanged. To claim they didnt know (when they themselves are recorded as bragging about being professional launderers) is then bragging that your leaders are not only weak, but dumb! Great legacy.
63
Aug 06, 2009 at 01:57 PM e. grossmann Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Even though you still continue to use the phrase "entrapment" completely wrong.......Why cant you understand the if someone tried to get you to do something illegal and you chose to do it, you are guilty. It is you who has to make the decision of right and wrong when you are challanged. To claim they didnt know (when they themselves are recorded as bragging about being professional launderers) is then bragging that your leaders are not only weak, but dumb! Great legacy. ”
In my country if someone tries to make you do something wrong and you do it, it is called entrapment (or the equivalent term in my language), and evidence related to this kind of maneuver cannot be used in court.
Because government agents are not allowed to break the law themselves, nor to induce anyone into breaking the law.
So I am a bit lost here: What will they do with Dwek's audio a evidence? Will they just use it as a bargaining chip to intimidate the defendents into pleading guilty or what?
64
Aug 06, 2009 at 06:21 PM OMG Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ In my country if someone tries to make you do something wrong and you do it, it is called entrapment (or the equivalent term in my language), and evidence related to this kind of maneuver cannot be used in court.
Because government agents are not allowed to break the law themselves, nor to induce anyone into breaking the law.
So I am a bit lost here: What will they do with Dwek's audio a evidence? Will they just use it as a bargaining chip to intimidate the defendents into pleading guilty or what? ”
Which country are you from? Here is some information from Wikipedia
Entrapment is the act of a law enforcement agent inducing a person to commit an offense which would be illegal and the person would otherwise have been unlikely to commit. In many jurisdictions, entrapment is a possible defense against criminal guilt.
The entrapment defense in the United States has evolved mainly through case law. Two competing tests exist for determining whether entrapment has taken place, known as the "subjective" and "objective" tests. The "subjective" test looks at the defendant's state of mind; entrapment can be claimed if the defendant had no "predisposition" to commit the crime. The "objective" test looks instead at the government's conduct; entrapment occurs when the actions of government officers would have caused a normally law-abiding person to commit a crime.
65
Aug 06, 2009 at 11:27 PM PM writer Says:Report as Inappropriate
Solomon Dwek not only placed many a michshol before others, but did so knowing that it would destroy the people he entrapped, hurt their families beyond description, and cause a Chilul Hashem of epic proportions.
66
Aug 06, 2009 at 11:43 PM KNOW OF ALL Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ no, true I do not know what is going on in the skver camp maybe the county is nitpicking I do not know, or some other cases where the situation in murky like some on the zoning issues etc. Or, in a regular case involving a yid that does not make the papers. But we do not discuss everyday cases here.
But when faced with insurmountable evidence whether in the kolco case Mondrowitz, the lunch programs frauds from years age, the nursing home scandal I could go on and on what am I supposed to do. Am I supposed to suspend realty suspend my mind and live in a fantasy world that it did not happen. Am I supposed to block out of my mind the stuff I saw as a kid what the yeshivas where doing sorry I do not work that way.
Maybe you think Kolco is innocent, mondrowitz, and all the other frum yiddin who where arrested and convicted. of crimes. The starving mom from Israel.
The real shame of all these stories, is not that a few yiddin did criminal acts,
The real shame and tragic part of these stories is that many in the community will fool themselves, make up stories that have no basis in realty or logic and just think these things do not happen in our community. And then of course do nothing to stop it from happening again , since it never happened at all.
One must first be willing to admit that there is a problem and only then can one apply efforts to fix it.
But some want to live in fantasy land that all frum yiddin are angel, and if accused it is antisemitism or other ridiculous reasoning. This is why frauds was happening and rebbies where getting arrested and put in jail when I was a kid and this is why when your grandchildren go to yeshiva it will happen again, since no one whats to fix a problem that does not exist.
”
It is very easy for the government to entrap people. It is very easy to fabricate evidence,it is very easy to prosecute. But it is very costly,hard, and sometimes impossible to defend yourself. Many people sit in jails for no good reason. I know some former and current ones. They couldn't afford it, and just gave up. Taking a criminal like that Drek , 50 million dollar Freud, and who knows how much more , and he is our main witness, most be something wrong with the system. Don't believe all stories with people waking up 30 years after and blame their Rebe, Principles, and others for their social,family,marital, and mantel problems, or looking for accuses why they are not practising their Jewish religion as they were taught. As I Said, it is very easy to fabricate and accuse others.
67
Aug 06, 2009 at 11:50 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Old Koch, Stay in your nursing home, keep your Jewish religion opinions to yourself. You were no great friend to the hasidic community when you were Mayer. When you needed our votes, you knew us.