Jerusalem - Charedi Girls Paid $265 Not to Wear Makeup at Their Wedding |
|

Jerusalem - The Darchei Rachel seminary for girls in Jerusalem imposed a new regulation recently: Each girl agreeing not to put on makeup for her wedding will receive a scholarship worth NIS 1,000 (about $265).
Moshe, whose sister studies at Darchei Rachel, says the new plan was initiated by the institution following a rise in the use of makeup among ultra-Orthodox girls.
According to Moshe, before their wedding the girls are exempted from the school’s strict rules, leading many brides to put on heavy makeup.
The managers of the seminary, which is considered one of the most conservative education institutions in the ultra-Orthodox sector and has about 1,500 students, took notice of the trend and decided to try and change it.
A source in the institution reported of a partial response to the scholarship, adding that not enough girls have gotten married yet in order to thoroughly examine the response.
A haredi education official explains, “This education institution is for the sector’s most righteous girls, who are strict about everything. However, I remain skeptical in regards to the initiative’s success, in light of the fact that makeup is acceptable in the haredi society and because it’s a particularly exciting day.”
More of today's headlines
“Washington - President Obama is having one bad summer. Only 46 percent approve of the job Obama is doing -- a 19-point slide since he took over the White House from...”
Washington - President Obama's Poll Numbers In Drastic Slide
New York, NY - City to Give Schoolkids Free Swine Flu Shots



Total149
Read Comments (149) — Post Yours »
1
Sep 01, 2009 at 10:48 AM FVNMS Says:Report as Inappropriate
Please, someone, provide the name(s) of the organization that will be financing this idiocy.
2
Sep 01, 2009 at 10:48 AM whatever Says:Report as Inappropriate
At what point will they pay the married women to wear robes instead of regular clothes (or has that not been instilled yet)? I see communism written all over these people. Thank God for AMERICA!
3
Sep 01, 2009 at 10:44 AM DizzyIzzy Says:Report as Inappropriate
Apparently some in the Charedi world believe that it's a chumra to make Frum girls feel guilty about everything.
It may just be a matter of time before this seminary offers a $265 incentive to girls who pledge to always be 26.5 pounds overweight, because "the most righteous girls" should never be allowed to feel attractive.
4
Sep 01, 2009 at 10:44 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Isnt a Kallah supposed to look her best for her Chosson, especially on their wedding night?! What halachic basis does this "chumra" have even for the "most righteous" girls? Provided that there is a proper mechitzah, only the chosson and the women will see her anyway. The money could be better spent on trivial things like food for starving kollel families.
5
Sep 01, 2009 at 10:43 AM How Stupid Says:Report as Inappropriate
Sure - go ahead and make the kallah look unattractive to their new husband that probably only met her once or twice before. How dumb can they get (and all in the name of frumkeit yet)
These idiots have no place in chinuch
6
Sep 01, 2009 at 10:40 AM Parent Says:Report as Inappropriate
Undue pressure will be put on these Kallah’s who have waited for this auspicious day. Parents who are in great need of this money will be pressuring these girls to “sell themselves” on their wedding day.
7
Sep 01, 2009 at 10:39 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
This is against what Judaism is about. Makeup for a Kallah is a very jewish thing. I can't believe what I'm reading....
These are probably the same people that are instigating the riots in Yerushalayim.
8
Sep 01, 2009 at 10:54 AM chossen Says:Report as Inappropriate
Why? Couldn't the money be put to better use?
9
Sep 01, 2009 at 10:54 AM Tznius Says:Report as Inappropriate
I would say perhaps more importantly would be a campaign against tightly fitted gowns for kallos as well as family members! Unfortunately even with regular clothing this plague has become all too common. And stop wearing flairy skirts that reveal the knees when walking! Why? Not because men can't control themselves, but because that's what Hashem wants! Ask any Rav!
OK all you seculary influenced fanatics, you can start attacking me now!
10
Sep 01, 2009 at 10:50 AM iib001 Says:Report as Inappropriate
I see nothing wrong according to Halacha and modesty for a bride to apply make-up for one of the most important events in her life not to mention to make her self attractive to her future husband!
11
Sep 01, 2009 at 10:50 AM FVNMS Says:Report as Inappropriate
I say bypass all of these amateurish, second-rate attempts at true kedusha and go straight to the burqa.
12
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:00 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
These dreche yiddin want to squeeze out the last semblance of life and joy among their yinglach. They yearn for a dark and bland sameness to everyone in the warped name of daas torah. Let these girls LIVE and feel good about themselves, physically and spiritually, at least for one day of their life.
13
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:00 AM make up your minds Says:Report as Inappropriate
They r crazy down the rd from the hall r ppl who haven't eaten a hot meal since shabbos and they R busy with this narishkiet -let her look good ! Let her wear make up every day and all year too and # 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Above you r all 100% correct !
14
Sep 01, 2009 at 10:59 AM A. Nuran Says:Report as Inappropriate
Typical fanatic trash. One thing that cults and religious extremists all have in common is iron control over sexuality, especially women's sexuality. These black-hatted sorts are no different. They just mumble their lies and poison in Hebrew instead of Arabic or Latin.
15
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:03 AM ibdo hadey Says:Report as Inappropriate
Excellent rule! Let's train the gurls to be unattractive to their hubsands, so they can have an excuse to "look" elsewhere. What a stoopid rule! No make up? Come on! And this is coming from a chinuch institution?
16
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:03 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Shulchan Aruch allows make-up for a Kallah even during periods where it might otherwise be prohibited le-halacha....but then again artscroll never made a shulchan aruch for the hassidic sector: hamenukad ve-hamevo-ar
17
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:03 AM benjamin Says:Report as Inappropriate
What is wrong with make-up? Women in BP wont take out the garbage without a full make-up application. If it is a school rule that they cant wear it in school then they should not make exceptions for students who are engaged, which is what i think the article says when they refer to girls being exempted from the strict rule before their wedding. There should, of course, without a doubt, be an exception for their wedding day - and exceptions made for any other girls who attend the wedding and are being looked over by prospective shadchans. After all, make-up has been used by women for thusands of yrs, this is not a 'new" trend we need to watch out for.
18
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:26 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Just curious how many boys they'll be able to get to marry girls that won't wear makeup to their wedding. Hey! Let's start a new initiative: $265 for every bride that put on a models coat instead of a gown. Good going guys. Pretty soon it will be $1000 not to get married since it brings to so much lust in the world. If they can try to knock out makeup which has been used throughout the generations by all frum Jews than why not abolish marriage?? Take a look through the gemorah. It is actually a ciyuv on a wife to put on makeup just as much as it is a ciyuv for a husband to provide sustenance for his wife. So how's this gonna work,the guests will all have makeup but not the bride?! I'm afraid maybe the choson will find someone more attractive in the crowd.
19
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:24 AM A Yid Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I would say perhaps more importantly would be a campaign against tightly fitted gowns for kallos as well as family members! Unfortunately even with regular clothing this plague has become all too common. And stop wearing flairy skirts that reveal the knees when walking! Why? Not because men can't control themselves, but because that's what Hashem wants! Ask any Rav!
OK all you seculary influenced fanatics, you can start attacking me now! ”
Kol H'kovod on your last statement.
20
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:24 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Whichever deranged rebbe or rebbitzen came up with this rule should be immediately shown the door and never again allowed to come near children. It only serves to reinforce the steretypes of charedim as irrational zealots and encourages the type of behavior we tragically read about this am in another article. They almost beg to be treated in a sub-human way by these actions. They have lost all sense of the beauty and joy of yiddeshkeit.
21
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:23 AM A Yid Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ At what point will they pay the married women to wear robes instead of regular clothes (or has that not been instilled yet)? I see communism written all over these people. Thank God for AMERICA! ”
Buy the way, Wearing a robe in public was long forbiden by very choshivah robonim in both the Litvish and chasidisha sects because of the fact that it clings to the body. So it could be a problem with tznuis.
I can understand where this coming from. The fact is that a lot of tzadikim didn't hold from it. I don't see anything wrong with them trying to keep halacha and manhagim the way it should be.
I personelly feel that writing communism on people that try to be their best in Yidishkeit "shmekd fin Apikorses" from the Fargrebta America Streets"
lets not for get the 3 reasons the yidin where freed from Mitzraim.
Now for those who are worried about them spending money on this. I would assume that its sort of a hachnasas kalah fund and in stead of making the girls feel bad that they are taking money from charity for the chasunah they are geting in a diffrent way.
22
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:21 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Good training; incentivize girls to do things for money!
23
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:20 AM Real Jew Says:Report as Inappropriate
Pay!!!!! Such a secular idea!!!! Real chareidi tzadikim would only use sandpaper
Sandpaper any girl's face that dares to wear makeup.
Just like our friends in Gaza & Teheran do. That works & costs less.
24
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:19 AM YH Says:Report as Inappropriate
Seems not in keeping with the Yiddishe approach to women and looks, "ein isha ela l'yofi."
"Ezra decreed for the Jewish nation that peddlers should go from town to town so that jewelry/cosmetics (both are translations of tachshitin) would be available to Bnos Yisrael."
25
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:17 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
I'm confused, from all the comments in general on Chareidy related issues it appears as though the non chreidy community will be zocha to be the first that Moshiach will come to, and that they are the most beloved to Hashem, However the Chareidy community who invest so little sacrifice to Hashem and look ugly with those big beards, and fat make-up-less overdressed woman will be put in hell and all of us with Shaven beards and oversexed wives will be singled out for special treatment by Hashem and Moshach due to their major contribution for Am Yisroel....... Come on get real.....
26
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:17 AM Reality Check Says:Report as Inappropriate
What is the actual long term goal?
Is this supposed to make the women more tzanua?
To who?
Is this supposed to somehow protect the men?
From who?
From their own wife?
If the husband is accustomed to women who don't put on make-up, will that make him somehow immune from attraction to women?
Is it really a mitzvah to make men lose attraction for women???
This is so mixed up!
In the Torah world in which I was raised, the basic concept was for a man and a woman to get married, and find spiritual, and physical love for each other - largely in private.
The nisoyon of attraction to or jealousy of someone's else's spouse is part of the normal human experience.
The Torah requires that we overcome these feelings in the process of growth.
The process includes (but is not limited to)
Focusing on the positive attributes of your own spouse.
Appreciating the unique inner and outer beauty of your own wife.
Finding the good in your husband, and letting him know that he is special to you.
Maintaining a level of privacy about your own spouse, so as not to flaunt your good fortune.
Developing an ayin tov, to be happy for your friend if you notice the positive attributes in their spouse.
Dismissing and ignoring the attempts of the yetzer hora to make you jealous of someone else's spouse, is a life-long avoda.
Your focus needs to be re-directed to your own life, and how you can make it better.
It takes work by two individuals devoted to each other to build something strong together.
Blaming women (or men) for the reality of the yetzer hora is foolish.
Giving the yetzer hora undue attention actually empowers it.
Aizehu Gibor Hakovesh es Yitzro.
Who ever said it's supposed to be easy?
27
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:15 AM webmom Says:Report as Inappropriate
WOW!!! come on!!!!!!! if they $1,000, it wouldn't be worth it!!!!!!! A kallah should look beautiful!!! think of the term "kallah mekushetes"!!!!! (ok maybe if they offered $10,000 I'd think about it.......)
28
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:13 AM mythoughts Says:Report as Inappropriate
The talibanization of judaism continues. I guess queen esther would not have been "frum" enough for this institution. There is a time and place for everything and a wedding night is definitely the place for makeup.
29
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:08 AM Yossi Says:Report as Inappropriate
I see nothing wrong with a kallah putting on makeup on her most important day of her life..What i see wrong is the American way where we get makeup artists for 1800-2500 dollars and waste it to Fake up those kallahs faces..First they look like clowns with so much Fakeup and a shame of so mush yiddishe $$ put to waste...When you see the kallehs mother walk in to the hall she will throw a quarter for all those erliche ladies collecting tzedukehs for yesoymim or poor kallehs....
30
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:08 AM PMO Says:Report as Inappropriate
We should all make sure that none of our money goes to this place. This is clearly some kind of cult that has nothing to do with yiddishkeit. Additionally, they clearly have more than enough money already to be paying for this nonsense. People starve and they worry about makeup? These are evil people.
31
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:07 AM Use Your Head Says:Report as Inappropriate
Let's just call them out on this very simple: It is against the Torah.
32
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:07 AM Babishka Says:Report as Inappropriate
One of the takonos of Ezra HaSofer was that women should wear cosmetics in order to look attractive for their husbands. It is a mitzvah for a bride to make herself beautiful on her wedding day! Why don't these idiots just give away free burqas while their at it?
33
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:31 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
is this school in afghanistan ?
34
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:30 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
what a stupid thing to do to a kallah. Let the men look their own deeds or the lack thereof, instead of telling women to do this and that.
35
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:50 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I would say perhaps more importantly would be a campaign against tightly fitted gowns for kallos as well as family members! Unfortunately even with regular clothing this plague has become all too common. And stop wearing flairy skirts that reveal the knees when walking! Why? Not because men can't control themselves, but because that's what Hashem wants! Ask any Rav!
OK all you seculary influenced fanatics, you can start attacking me now! ”
I am so glad that you know "what Hashem wants". I do not know any Rav who knows "what Hashem wants". Since you are so smart maybe you can tell us what Hashem wants to happen to my health, that way I don't have to waste any time going to doctors, or even better tell me waht Hasem wants to happen to the stock market?
36
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:02 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
This is chinuch - HORRIBLE chinuch!!! First of all, to imply that a young woman should not look her best for her chosson?? Secondly, to PAY her to do what they think is a mitzvah?? Third, this totally defies Halacha which says it is a mitzvah for a woman to wear eye make up.
These people are SICK, SICK, SICK!!!
37
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:01 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I would say perhaps more importantly would be a campaign against tightly fitted gowns for kallos as well as family members! Unfortunately even with regular clothing this plague has become all too common. And stop wearing flairy skirts that reveal the knees when walking! Why? Not because men can't control themselves, but because that's what Hashem wants! Ask any Rav!
OK all you seculary influenced fanatics, you can start attacking me now! ”
One who is stringent upon himself in Halacha has no right to enforce it on other people. Unfortunately, the concept of "tznius" has been distorted to the extent that people think skirts need to be 3 (maybe more?) inches below the knees. As long as a girl/woman is not following the letter of the law then I am with you 100%. Otherwise, who are you to say this is too tight-fitting to be considered tznius for other people?
38
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:00 PM OJoe Says:Report as Inappropriate
Lets make something clear. This "Chumra" is in fact against the values of the Torah. It is not an "stringency" it is a disrespect for Torah.
As mentioned above, the halacha recognizes the importance of a Kallah wearing makeup and allows it (in other words, encourages it) even when others may not wear it.
This "Chumra" is basically spitting in the face of Chazal and Torah.
I recall once hearing a story that when R Moshe was mattir something relating to these matters, he got complaints from those who wanted to be stricter and he said that the reason he was comfortable being mattir while other weren't was because others were exposed to the "street" and got their ideas of morality (both immorality and modesty) from the street, while he only looked at the Torah and found that it was muttar.
This is just another anti-Torah move by these nuts who need to be considered Reform Jews. They are doing the exact same thing only in the other direction.
39
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:58 AM formally Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I would say perhaps more importantly would be a campaign against tightly fitted gowns for kallos as well as family members! Unfortunately even with regular clothing this plague has become all too common. And stop wearing flairy skirts that reveal the knees when walking! Why? Not because men can't control themselves, but because that's what Hashem wants! Ask any Rav!
OK all you seculary influenced fanatics, you can start attacking me now! ”
but because that's what Hashem wants!
please where does it say in the Torah how long a dress should be and how long a sleeve should be. You must know since you know what hashem wants.
What other secrets are you keeping from us, what should i do please ask hashem for me
40
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:58 AM You're Genius Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Pay!!!!! Such a secular idea!!!! Real chareidi tzadikim would only use sandpaper
Sandpaper any girl's face that dares to wear makeup.
Just like our friends in Gaza & Teheran do. That works & costs less.
”
Your idea to sandpaper the faces of girls who use makeup is just plain old genius, LOL. Thanks for making me laugh so hard :) Next they'll pay the girls to cover faces in bed too, what a sick bunch of losers.
41
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:57 AM Woman who wears makeup for her husband. Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Buy the way, Wearing a robe in public was long forbiden by very choshivah robonim in both the Litvish and chasidisha sects because of the fact that it clings to the body. So it could be a problem with tznuis.
I can understand where this coming from. The fact is that a lot of tzadikim didn't hold from it. I don't see anything wrong with them trying to keep halacha and manhagim the way it should be.
I personelly feel that writing communism on people that try to be their best in Yidishkeit "shmekd fin Apikorses" from the Fargrebta America Streets"
lets not for get the 3 reasons the yidin where freed from Mitzraim.
Now for those who are worried about them spending money on this. I would assume that its sort of a hachnasas kalah fund and in stead of making the girls feel bad that they are taking money from charity for the chasunah they are geting in a diffrent way. ”
Excuse me, but you a quite a big "Am Ho'oretz". It seems you forgot a very important point - the Kiyar was made from the women's mirrors. And what did they use the mirrors for? To make themselves attractive for their husbands in order to perpetuate the Jewish nation. THIS is why the Yidden were freed from Mitzrayim - In the zchus of the Noshim Tzidkoniyus who made themselves attractive for their husbands! The three things you mentioned are Shem, Loshon and Levush. No mention about makeup - Levush is NOT makeup.
Perhaps if they would make some rules about heavy makeup, eye makeup, etc. then I could understand that, but no makeup at all on their wedding day? Misguided tzidkus...
And yes, as my name above suggests, I do wear makeup for my husband. I am not one of those that look like a drek at home and wears makeup only to go out. My husband appreciates when I put on makeup and I make the effort to look good when he's home. By the way, in case you might think otherwise, my husband is a very Choshuve Torahdige person, nothing wrong with his Yiddishkeit because he likes to see me looking attractive. I am his wife after all....
42
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:54 AM Black Hatted Sort Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Typical fanatic trash. One thing that cults and religious extremists all have in common is iron control over sexuality, especially women's sexuality. These black-hatted sorts are no different. They just mumble their lies and poison in Hebrew instead of Arabic or Latin. ”
You obviously have a problem with black hats. And that problem is?
Poison? what poison? Is praying poison?
What are you doing on this Blog, anyway? Are you hear so you can rat on the black hatted sorts on your filthy Blogs?
Go get a life.
43
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:53 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
This is like the Taliban. Where in halacha or minhag did this even come from? Yes, tzniys is "da'as yehudis", and perhaps in that community, no makeup is the norm...and if that's the worst thing these girls are doing, then it's to their credit that the administration couldn't find any worse behaviors to curtail. Yes this strikes me as something just like those "Ateres" tzniyus programs my daughters go to -- where they are told that it's entirely the fault of young girls like them that Moshiach isn't here -- because they haven't outfitted their shirts with an extra "tzniyus" button -- but they make no mention of the fact that a gaggle of girls shreiking in the streets is the furthest thing from tzniyus...nor is chutzpah -- which is in my opinion is the worst threat to our girls...or that perhaps a general focus on bein adam le'chavero would be more in order....it's as if everyone has the right priorities...but they just prioritize their priorities in the wrong order....
44
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:52 AM formally Says:Report as Inappropriate
maybe the men should also wear old suits and look like hobos
it should work both ways somewhat
also am i missing something in many stories in the Torah didn't they people buy jewelry and the woman look nice for their husbands
45
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:28 PM Loshon Hora Says:Report as Inappropriate
look at the gemorah of Aba Chilkiyah the grandson of Choiny Hameagel, whose wife was all dressed up, & he explained the chachomim that it was so that he shopuldn't envy someone elses wife.The Gemorah in Kesuvos Rabon Gamliel gave a gold tooth to a girl & cried that the daughters of Israel are nice, but poverty makes them ugly.
The night of the chasuna is the first impression you only get one chance at that.
I personally believe that this project is against Torah & Chazal, someone should start a project to pay for the make-up & those who do it.
Just my opinion.
46
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:26 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
if i remember correctly it says in gemoroh that the husband has an obligation to see to it that his wife looks good - included in that is providing clothes, makeup, perfume, etc.
(of course all this in a tzniusdik manner)
47
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:18 PM Joel Says:Report as Inappropriate
Yay! We accomplished something, that a girl will look a little (?) less attractive to her choson on the wedding night!! Yay! Allah hu akhbar!
48
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:10 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Looks like most of the comments don't know that chassidishe schools here teach the girls against makeup on the street. The wedding is public. . In navi it says that one of the reasons of the chorban is because the girls colors their eyes. Rashi says with black and blue. . Check it out. You will find many women dont touch their eyes!
49
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:10 PM A frum yid Says:Report as Inappropriate
Why stop there? Offer another $265 for wearing a ski mask
50
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:38 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Okay, so skirts are too long , wigs are not kosher, who sits and thinks up these things? Amazing how these men ,that do to look at women, notice everything women wear!!!
51
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:37 PM yenta Says:Report as Inappropriate
There is makeup and then there is makeup.
There is makeup like my mother wore, and then there is makeup which is "professionally" done, and costs hundreds of dollars for the kalla (not to mention the rest of the family).
I think this incentive is toward the ridiculous waste of money that makeup costs. I hope that flowers (which is essentially a goyishe tradition) is next out the window, two thousand (halevai) dollar gowns, entertainers (leitzim be"laaz), all get stopped, and we go back to having decent respectable heimishe weddings.
My mother got married with a 50-couple wedding, Yom-Tov Erlich z"l zy"a music, and a family member (totally not professional - but did the job) as badchen, and a cousin snapping some pictures. And of course, applied by her mother zz"g as best as she could, but good enough. (Her parents did not have money issues, in case you ask).
52
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:37 PM Gave A Get Says:Report as Inappropriate
Gemera says that If a husband does not allow his wife to wear makeup he is violation of the Kesubah. Does any Halacha matter anymore?
53
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:35 PM Alex Says:Report as Inappropriate
Will they be paying the groom not to dress up as well? This way both of them will look like they just got out of bed.
54
Sep 01, 2009 at 01:01 PM formally Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Yay! We accomplished something, that a girl will look a little (?) less attractive to her choson on the wedding night!! Yay! Allah hu akhbar! ”
maybe he will get cold feet and change his mind in the last second
55
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:59 PM yeapb Says:Report as Inappropriate
The problem was that since they were prohibited from using make-up while in school they were 'applying make-up very heavily' - THAT is the problem, not the actual make-up!! My daughter also went to a seminary that forbad make-up, when she got married we got her made up with just a touch of make up, so light that it was hardly noticeable. Some kallos are so pale that without make up, especially when fasting all day, they look like they're at death's door!! What they could do with a few sessions on how to apply make-up so that it is not noticeable!!
56
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:59 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Buy the way, Wearing a robe in public was long forbiden by very choshivah robonim in both the Litvish and chasidisha sects because of the fact that it clings to the body. So it could be a problem with tznuis.
I can understand where this coming from. The fact is that a lot of tzadikim didn't hold from it. I don't see anything wrong with them trying to keep halacha and manhagim the way it should be.
I personelly feel that writing communism on people that try to be their best in Yidishkeit "shmekd fin Apikorses" from the Fargrebta America Streets"
lets not for get the 3 reasons the yidin where freed from Mitzraim.
Now for those who are worried about them spending money on this. I would assume that its sort of a hachnasas kalah fund and in stead of making the girls feel bad that they are taking money from charity for the chasunah they are geting in a diffrent way. ”
I always loved the term "choshivah robonim". What makes them choshiv? Our grandparents down to the Imoas wore robes. heck, even the Avos wore robes. So now what is wrong with robes? Myabe in BP it doesn't "paist" to were a robe in public, because then your'e not fancy. But there is NOTHING wrong with wearing a robe!
57
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:58 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Why stop there? Offer another $265 for wearing a ski mask ”
that was totally awesome. thanks for the laugh,
58
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:54 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Looks like most of the comments don't know that chassidishe schools here teach the girls against makeup on the street. The wedding is public. . In navi it says that one of the reasons of the chorban is because the girls colors their eyes. Rashi says with black and blue. . Check it out. You will find many women dont touch their eyes! ”
There were numerious reasons provided, however, makeup was not the main one( even if it was one, since I never heard of that shtuss...any source?)
59
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:53 PM Appalled Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Whichever deranged rebbe or rebbitzen came up with this rule should be immediately shown the door and never again allowed to come near children. It only serves to reinforce the steretypes of charedim as irrational zealots and encourages the type of behavior we tragically read about this am in another article. They almost beg to be treated in a sub-human way by these actions. They have lost all sense of the beauty and joy of yiddeshkeit. ”
The same as the deranged Girl's High School Rebbitzen in Monsey that is now eliminating "dance" out of their yearly production. She decided that "dance" is not tznius and it will no longer exist in the production. These girls perform in front of an all women's audience, mostly made up of their mother's, grandmothers, sisters and girl cousins and neighbors. The one outlet that these girls who are blessed with dancing abilities have is being denied them! The chareidi world is going completely bezurk with their fanatic, non halacha based chumros! I would call this and all the other craziness apikosus!
60
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:53 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ There is makeup and then there is makeup.
There is makeup like my mother wore, and then there is makeup which is "professionally" done, and costs hundreds of dollars for the kalla (not to mention the rest of the family).
I think this incentive is toward the ridiculous waste of money that makeup costs. I hope that flowers (which is essentially a goyishe tradition) is next out the window, two thousand (halevai) dollar gowns, entertainers (leitzim be"laaz), all get stopped, and we go back to having decent respectable heimishe weddings.
My mother got married with a 50-couple wedding, Yom-Tov Erlich z"l zy"a music, and a family member (totally not professional - but did the job) as badchen, and a cousin snapping some pictures. And of course, applied by her mother zz"g as best as she could, but good enough. (Her parents did not have money issues, in case you ask). ”
Any Avroham Avenu gave Besual Camals and very expensive jewerly....should we resort to that?
61
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:47 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
I put on my own make up for my wedding, using Maybeline and Cover Girl brands. I put it on sparingly. No one said I didn't look beautiful. What does a young girl with good skin need gobs of makeup for? I would take the $1000 shekels and put just a tad of makeup on if I were a kalla.
62
Sep 01, 2009 at 12:47 PM REALLY? Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Sure - go ahead and make the kallah look unattractive to their new husband that probably only met her once or twice before. How dumb can they get (and all in the name of frumkeit yet)
These idiots have no place in chinuch ”
With all the atrosoties against women in that forsaken country...you are going to make 'make-up' the battle you chose to fight for them?? how about the fact they have only met their husbands once? Arranged marriages? Forced to have kids? More physically abused than not...It is just mind boggeling. But it is the make-up causing an outrage.....that makes sence!
63
Sep 01, 2009 at 01:54 PM Tznius Says:Report as Inappropriate
Reply to #35, Perhaps you only know reform or conservative "rabonim". Do you keep kosher, observe shabbos put on tefillin, daven etc.? If yes, why do you do it? Because that's what Hashem wants, as evidenced by the Torah he gave us, B'ksav & Baal peh, i.e. Mikra, Mishna, Gemara, etc. until the Shulchan Aruch and our present Rabonim and Poskim. How absurd and silly it is to compare basic Halachos with your personal health and your stock portfolio.
64
Sep 01, 2009 at 01:52 PM Come On Says:Report as Inappropriate
If we are going to go against open Gemaras, supposedly in the name of frumkeit, how are we different from the Reform and Conservative Jews? One neededn't go spend thousands on makeup, but of course the Kallah should look nice for her husband. If the school is concerned that some of their girls go overboard, teach them how to pur on makeup tastefully.
65
Sep 01, 2009 at 01:57 PM What? Says:Report as Inappropriate
Oh - how foolish!
66
Sep 01, 2009 at 01:56 PM FVNMS Says:Report as Inappropriate
Judging from the comments here (some of which are over the top) it is clear: we don't want anymore of this stupid, false and even counter-halacha/intiuition nonsense to adulterate our commitment to Hashem and the Torah. Hey, askanim and neviei sheker, you have destroyed so much of klal yisrael that Hitler YM"S would want to join your fan clubs. What's next? Beating up kallas who don't comply (I'm sure they'll be issued heartfelt pleas beforehand). Iran is a short trip from Me'ah She'arim and I hear there's a Mehadrin bus for your traveling pleasure. Don't let the door slam you on the (ahem) on your way out.
67
Sep 01, 2009 at 01:47 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
what does putting on makeup have to do with frumkeit? How is this not tzniusdik? I think this school has gone way too far. I also think that $265.00 is not enough money to give a kallah so that she should look unattractive at her wedding. Shame on this school!
68
Sep 01, 2009 at 01:44 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I put on my own make up for my wedding, using Maybeline and Cover Girl brands. I put it on sparingly. No one said I didn't look beautiful. What does a young girl with good skin need gobs of makeup for? I would take the $1000 shekels and put just a tad of makeup on if I were a kalla. ”
Who in their right mind would tell a Kallah on her wedding day...oh, you don't look so good? Maybe put on some makeup?
69
Sep 01, 2009 at 01:40 PM FVNMS Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I would say perhaps more importantly would be a campaign against tightly fitted gowns for kallos as well as family members! Unfortunately even with regular clothing this plague has become all too common. And stop wearing flairy skirts that reveal the knees when walking! Why? Not because men can't control themselves, but because that's what Hashem wants! Ask any Rav!
OK all you seculary influenced fanatics, you can start attacking me now! ”
Zeesskeit. Why would I need to attack you? I have rachmonus on you. I'm so not mekaneh your outlook on the world. You see, when I'm at a chassunah, I'm busy being mesame'ach chosson vekalla and enjoying good music (hopefully) and delicious food. You, on the other hand, are slowly going insane with bitterness glaring at the baalei simcha looking to find fault with them. I would never attack you, nebech, you must be so tormented thinking about all the ayin haras you direct at people on the happiest days of their lives. By the way are you my shvigger's cousin?
70
Sep 01, 2009 at 01:36 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ There is makeup and then there is makeup.
There is makeup like my mother wore, and then there is makeup which is "professionally" done, and costs hundreds of dollars for the kalla (not to mention the rest of the family).
I think this incentive is toward the ridiculous waste of money that makeup costs. I hope that flowers (which is essentially a goyishe tradition) is next out the window, two thousand (halevai) dollar gowns, entertainers (leitzim be"laaz), all get stopped, and we go back to having decent respectable heimishe weddings.
My mother got married with a 50-couple wedding, Yom-Tov Erlich z"l zy"a music, and a family member (totally not professional - but did the job) as badchen, and a cousin snapping some pictures. And of course, applied by her mother zz"g as best as she could, but good enough. (Her parents did not have money issues, in case you ask). ”
Yenta, you are certainly on to something. I'm not about to quibble over how much make up the girl should apply or should not apply to her face as I believe the kallah should look her best, but I would love to see a change in the way weddings are made. Soooooo much money for a young couple that will now embark on a life (at least for the first few years) of milking their parents for every dollar they have so that they can "sacrifice" for Torah learning. All the rest of the Jewish people who can afford to make expensive weddings and their children will be self supportive, have fun! Enjoy your hard earned money to your heart's consent with my blessings! But to the rest of you previously described, shame on you! The fraud, as my teacher used to say "shtinked ad hashamayim!" Enough already!
71
Sep 01, 2009 at 01:28 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
The reason for this new rule is not that she should be unattractive to her future husband, but that she should not be a turn on to other men.
72
Sep 01, 2009 at 02:07 PM FVNMS Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I'm confused, from all the comments in general on Chareidy related issues it appears as though the non chreidy community will be zocha to be the first that Moshiach will come to, and that they are the most beloved to Hashem, However the Chareidy community who invest so little sacrifice to Hashem and look ugly with those big beards, and fat make-up-less overdressed woman will be put in hell and all of us with Shaven beards and oversexed wives will be singled out for special treatment by Hashem and Moshach due to their major contribution for Am Yisroel....... Come on get real..... ”
So let me try to allay some of your confusion. Extremism and fanaticism have destroyed a large segment of the "charaidim." Hooliganism, leydiggeien, riots, drugs, abuse and other nega'im are rife within that camp. The reason: none of it was ever le'shem shamayim. Sin'ah toward the "tziyoinim," power-lust, and greed lie at the heart of what has become of some of our sects. Using the halachos of tznius as a defense to savage young girls on the street is not anything the RBSO has nachas ru'ach from, any more than the ugly riots that are a regular occurrence in Yerushalayim. And what happened last simchas beis hasho'eiva?
Now, as far as where Moshiach will arrive first... Simple: Tehran! Who has made more sacrifices for Yiddishkeit than Neturei Karta?
73
Sep 01, 2009 at 02:03 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Typical fanatic trash. One thing that cults and religious extremists all have in common is iron control over sexuality, especially women's sexuality. These black-hatted sorts are no different. They just mumble their lies and poison in Hebrew instead of Arabic or Latin. ”
I would say even more - these are sexually repressed fanatics who think this will cure their urges. Tell me if I'm wrong, but didn't the women in Mitzrayim's time get Schar because they used their copper mirrors to make sure they were attractive to their husbands? I guess these people think they are holier than that generation.
74
Sep 01, 2009 at 01:26 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Seems not in keeping with the Yiddishe approach to women and looks, "ein isha ela l'yofi."
"Ezra decreed for the Jewish nation that peddlers should go from town to town so that jewelry/cosmetics (both are translations of tachshitin) would be available to Bnos Yisrael."
”
To be used at home for her husband only not for you to look at
75
Sep 01, 2009 at 01:17 PM torahyid Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I am so glad that you know "what Hashem wants". I do not know any Rav who knows "what Hashem wants". Since you are so smart maybe you can tell us what Hashem wants to happen to my health, that way I don't have to waste any time going to doctors, or even better tell me waht Hasem wants to happen to the stock market?
”
that poster wrote that revealing the knees is not what Hashem wants, we all know this as it states as such in halocho.
76
Sep 01, 2009 at 01:15 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I would say perhaps more importantly would be a campaign against tightly fitted gowns for kallos as well as family members! Unfortunately even with regular clothing this plague has become all too common. And stop wearing flairy skirts that reveal the knees when walking! Why? Not because men can't control themselves, but because that's what Hashem wants! Ask any Rav!
OK all you seculary influenced fanatics, you can start attacking me now! ”
Knees? Really? I have never thought of knees to be the least bit provocative. It is a matter of self control....because what animal would be thrown into a sexual rampage because of seeing a knee? you need to be accountable for your own actions
77
Sep 01, 2009 at 01:06 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I am so glad that you know "what Hashem wants". I do not know any Rav who knows "what Hashem wants". Since you are so smart maybe you can tell us what Hashem wants to happen to my health, that way I don't have to waste any time going to doctors, or even better tell me waht Hasem wants to happen to the stock market?
”
Any Rav who doesn't know what Hashem wants should join the reform congregations.
They for sure don't know and don't want to know what Hashem wants.
Hashem gave us the Torah as our guide and the Torah teaches and instructs us to do what Hashem wants us to. It is forbidden, according to halachah, for a woman to expose her knees.
78
Sep 01, 2009 at 02:14 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
I very much doubt there is even one godol who would agree with this shtuss.
I don't think any daas torah would even think of it, that a kalah should not do whatever possible to look her best when going under the chupa.
Better yet, I don't believe this whole article is true. One would have to be real meshuga to come up with such an idea.
I would rather say, pay her the NIS1,000 to get the best cosmetition in the market.
79
Sep 01, 2009 at 02:10 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
#51, makeup artists for weddings do not charge hundreds of dollars for the kallah, and most gowns, which are generally rented today, do not all cost 2 thousand dollars, most cost less, and then why waste money on a badchen? you run into overtime with a mitzvah tance, and have to pay extra for the music and photographer- a waste of money!!
80
Sep 01, 2009 at 02:09 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I see nothing wrong with a kallah putting on makeup on her most important day of her life..What i see wrong is the American way where we get makeup artists for 1800-2500 dollars and waste it to Fake up those kallahs faces..First they look like clowns with so much Fakeup and a shame of so mush yiddishe $$ put to waste...When you see the kallehs mother walk in to the hall she will throw a quarter for all those erliche ladies collecting tzedukehs for yesoymim or poor kallehs.... ”
Good point - bingo! A little makeup makes women attractive. These makep artist (or fakeup as Yossi so correctly labeled them) make the women look plastic, ugly, and even sometimes - terrifying. That is in addition to the unbeleivable waste of money, as you so correctly write.
What a waste of Yiddishe money
81
Sep 01, 2009 at 02:30 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
makeup can be decieving u see a girl on13th ave and u think she looks prettty with all that makeup but u dont realize underneath that makeup she could be ugly
82
Sep 01, 2009 at 02:26 PM WolfishMusings Says:Report as Inappropriate
I find it interesting that this was presented as an incentive rather than as a ban. I would guess that the administrators figured that an outright ban would simply fail, and so it was presented this way.
Here's a question to ask yourself -- once enough girls "take the bait" and it becomes the "norm" for a bride to not wear makeup, will the incentive then turn into an outright ban?
The Wolf
83
Sep 01, 2009 at 02:24 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I would say perhaps more importantly would be a campaign against tightly fitted gowns for kallos as well as family members! Unfortunately even with regular clothing this plague has become all too common. And stop wearing flairy skirts that reveal the knees when walking! Why? Not because men can't control themselves, but because that's what Hashem wants! Ask any Rav!
OK all you seculary influenced fanatics, you can start attacking me now! ”
I'll take secular normalcy over cultish religious lunacy any day. BTW, I just checked with Hashem, he thinks you're confusing the chumrahs of 17th century shtetl peasantry with all the wonderful opportunity and diversity he has created for us in the modern world. He suggests you get out more.
84
Sep 01, 2009 at 02:24 PM FVNMS Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Any Avroham Avenu gave Besual Camals and very expensive jewerly....should we resort to that? ”
Who'd a'thunk... I'm feeling nostalgic and depressed at the same time...
85
Sep 01, 2009 at 02:38 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
why cant these people let both girls and boys (men and woman) live their life and look how they want to look. if your not happy with the way someone is dressed then look away. i dont think there is anything wrong with girls making themselves attractive for boys and wives for their husband and the other way as well.
86
Sep 01, 2009 at 03:02 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
more madness ...and more madness
87
Sep 01, 2009 at 03:08 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
WHH
I am so disappointed in the respondents posting their opinions on this issue. They are filled with such defensiveness, and such catty venomous remarks, that one can only conclude that our respondents here on this forum are threatened by this very Jewish and very Israeli expression of piety. That you ladies, I imagine mostly, and gentleman in Chutz L'aretz fail to understand that this is a personal choice of the Kallah, and that makeup does not equal beauty in any form. It is shallow to assume that every woman desires the made up look. I wore no makeup to my own wedding by choice, nobody paid me anything neither did i need it. Nor did I get my hair done nor did I wear or purchase a sheitel. And 20 years later, i still don't indulge my time to focus on such ridiculous frivolity. I am also American and had the best education and upbringing and material advantages that the USA has to offer. I think if a woman needs to feel attractive she should do what makes her feel comfortable and content, but you should know that excessive focus is most unattractive on everyone. Thick layers of makeup are used injudiciously in many circles in the West and should not be worn as a badge of honor by anyone. Yes it is a chumrah, either way it's a chumrah, and therefore, a personal decision which you should all keep to yourselves.
88
Sep 01, 2009 at 03:04 PM Gaon Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Looks like most of the comments don't know that chassidishe schools here teach the girls against makeup on the street. The wedding is public. . In navi it says that one of the reasons of the chorban is because the girls colors their eyes. Rashi says with black and blue. . Check it out. You will find many women dont touch their eyes! ”
First of all, the issue is not the TYPE of makeup. rather, its the make-up altogether they have a prob. with, Which obviously goes against the very gemorah that obligates it !
Regardless, the type of make-up you mentioned, is more likely a "relative" matter. As was the custom of "zonos" to wear those kinds, at the time mentioned . Therefore being as an issur in terms of "Bnos Yisrael" which is an relatively issur, which depends on the customs and times. e.g. there were times and places were even single girls covered their heads (see Rambam Shu'"a; mostly in the mid-east ) and was considered as an "issur" to reveal their hair.
89
Sep 01, 2009 at 02:57 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ why cant these people let both girls and boys (men and woman) live their life and look how they want to look. if your not happy with the way someone is dressed then look away. i dont think there is anything wrong with girls making themselves attractive for boys and wives for their husband and the other way as well. ”
"why cant these people let both girls and boys (men and woman) live their life and look how they want to look."
You don't understand. The essence of the hareidi lifestyle is for their leaders to squeeze out and repress every last little bit of life and joy from their followers; By living this dark, painful lifestyle, they somehow believe they will earn a great share of olam haboah. We can only feel sorry for the innocent children who have no choice but to stay in the dark as their parents and teachers insist they must.
90
Sep 01, 2009 at 02:46 PM BS Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I'm confused, from all the comments in general on Chareidy related issues it appears as though the non chreidy community will be zocha to be the first that Moshiach will come to, and that they are the most beloved to Hashem, However the Chareidy community who invest so little sacrifice to Hashem and look ugly with those big beards, and fat make-up-less overdressed woman will be put in hell and all of us with Shaven beards and oversexed wives will be singled out for special treatment by Hashem and Moshach due to their major contribution for Am Yisroel....... Come on get real..... ”
The reason y a woman needs to be attracted to her husband is to have kids....look at the difference in family size b4 u talk
91
Sep 01, 2009 at 02:46 PM Gaon Says:Report as Inappropriate
Ve'Lo Am HaArrotz Chasid!:
According to all poskim a Kallah is clearly permitted, furthermore and so is the husband/father obligated to provide her with the make-up (with amount considered as the reg. norm usage in community residing) as indicated in Mesechet Kesubbos!
92
Sep 01, 2009 at 02:45 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
At a frum chasuna the men and women are separate, so the men don't have to stare at the kalla anyway. So even those frummies who believe that wearing makeup is wrong because it will attract men have nothing to criticize a kalla for, for wearing makeup on her wedding day.
93
Sep 01, 2009 at 02:45 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ They r crazy down the rd from the hall r ppl who haven't eaten a hot meal since shabbos and they R busy with this narishkiet -let her look good ! Let her wear make up every day and all year too and # 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Above you r all 100% correct ! ”
Where all of a sudden does this school have that kind of money to spend? Why don't they give this money towards marrying off poor girls & boys and not send their parents out to the world to collect!
94
Sep 01, 2009 at 02:44 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
When Yishaiyah the Novi criticizes make-up, it is clear as day that he is criticizing those who do it with the intention of being alluring (“Extremely attractive, tempting, or glamorous, and able to arouse strong desire in people”), not attractive to a husband or husband-to-be.
btw, what exactly is so special about some expensive dyed-black rabbit fur plopped on a man's head?
95
Sep 01, 2009 at 02:19 PM chareidi but normal Says:Report as Inappropriate
these criminally insane ignorant savages belong in a insane asylum for the criminally insane,and have no business running a girls school
96
Sep 01, 2009 at 02:14 PM FVNMS Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I see nothing wrong with a kallah putting on makeup on her most important day of her life..What i see wrong is the American way where we get makeup artists for 1800-2500 dollars and waste it to Fake up those kallahs faces..First they look like clowns with so much Fakeup and a shame of so mush yiddishe $$ put to waste...When you see the kallehs mother walk in to the hall she will throw a quarter for all those erliche ladies collecting tzedukehs for yesoymim or poor kallehs.... ”
I hope you don't attend my simchas if that's the evil that goes through your mind while others celebrate.
97
Sep 01, 2009 at 03:32 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
85 and 92 well said
98
Sep 01, 2009 at 04:04 PM elh Says:Report as Inappropriate
1. Every Kallah has a very special inner beauty as the Shechinah rests on her. Why cover it up with makeup?
2. I was told by a Rov that women are forbidden to wear eye makeup - Yeshaya Chapter 3 Posuk 16. It says that eye makeup is an abomination to Hashem and was one of the causes of Golus. I have since been told by one lady it means only eye liner another told me it means only eye shadow.
3. If that is the cause of the golus let us chuck out our makeup!
4. In Sem our Rov used to tell us that every Frum girl has a special Chein why cover it up? The few girls who wore makeup he used to ask what are you trying to cover up?
99
Sep 01, 2009 at 03:54 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Just because you don't believe in this, doesn't make it wrong, crazy or idiotic. Everybody has the right to do what they want. Each person has a right to agree with whomever they please, but belittling the beliefs and views of others is wrong! unless there is something wrong(against the torah perhaps) with what they are implementing then there is no place to put them down. Do i agree with the above article, no. But they are obviously in a different place, and hold different things, so don't just mock what they are doing just because it differs from what your beliefs are.
100
Sep 01, 2009 at 03:35 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I hope you don't attend my simchas if that's the evil that goes through your mind while others celebrate. ”
What exactly did #29 say that got your goat?
101
Sep 01, 2009 at 04:41 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
During the time of the mishkan HaShem told moshe rabeinu to use the mirrors from the women....the mirrors they used to make themselves look pretty for their husbands... even the torah wants women to look good and feel good... just not to flaunt it to other men.... a wedding day is between the chosson and kallh and yes she should do whatever it takes to make herself look beautiful for her chassan. incliding wearing makeup!
judaism is not the same religion they practice in iran or the taliban...
102
Sep 01, 2009 at 04:54 PM Oy Gevald Says:Report as Inappropriate
Very little has actually been said here regarding the Torah's view on make-up for women, so here it is. You're more than welcome to check the source.
Question 1: who was the first woman to wear make-up?
Question 2: Who was the "beautician" that applied that make-up and showed her how to wear make-up?
Answer: Baal Haturim in Bereshis (Perek Bais, pasuk Chof-bais) writes that Hashem adorned Chava with 24 cosmetics. Twenty-four!!!
That having been said, we now know several things. a) Make-up has always been worn by women since creation. b) Hashem showed Chava how to beautify herself with cosmetics. And that's good enough for me!!! How about perfume? Do we have a source permitting perfume for women to wear (its purpose is to be noticed by others)? There are several sources. One great source is Gemora in Yuma (Daf Lamed-tes:) stating that the Ketores in the Bais Hamikdosk was so strongly perfumed that women far away in Yericho didn't have to wear perfume, and even more, a Kallah living in Yerushalayim didn't have to perfume herself at all since just living there the perfume permeated ones body and lasted not just when walking outside but remained on you even in ones home, no additional applications necessary.
So, there you have it. Keep authentic Judaism alive. Wear make-up to look attractive and wear perfume that makes you pleasant-smelling.
103
Sep 01, 2009 at 04:36 PM Frum Lawyer Says:Report as Inappropriate
This article illustrates what has been completely lost in our Masorah: any sense of humility about whether one is fit to keep a chumrah.
The gemara in Chullin quotes an Amora who states (I am paraphrasing from memory): I am like vinegar the son of wine, for my father waited an entire day before eating dairy after meat, whereas I only wait until the next meal. (This is the source for the custom of most Jews to wait 6 hours -- the typical time it takes between meals.)
Anyway, R. Yisroel Salanter once asked -- what is the meaning of this gemara? Did this Amora have so little self-control that he just HAD to eat milchigs? That's absurd -- in fact we could easily imagine keeping a chumro like the father did, i.e. waiting a full day.
Rather, the pshat is that the father was on a much higher level than the son, so for him the chumro was appropriate, whereas for the son (who felt himself on a lower level) it would be inappropriate.
This is what has been lost -- any sense that a chumro is not for every Chaim Yankel (or, in this case, every Sarah Leah.)
104
Sep 01, 2009 at 04:17 PM webmom Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I put on my own make up for my wedding, using Maybeline and Cover Girl brands. I put it on sparingly. No one said I didn't look beautiful. What does a young girl with good skin need gobs of makeup for? I would take the $1000 shekels and put just a tad of makeup on if I were a kalla. ”
I believe in order to get the $1000 shekels, they can't wear any makeup...my opinion: if they offered $10,000 shekels, still not worth it... a kallah should look beautiful...guys: let's all remember the chasunah song that is still played at all--including charedi--weddings: "Kaytzad merakdim....Kallah noeh kachassidah"--the kallah is beautiful as a chassidah (a bird)...
105
Sep 01, 2009 at 05:22 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
How bout 1000 bucks for breast reduction and 2000 to take the entire thing of, sponsord by materna since if no nursing the demand for ther product will go up
106
Sep 01, 2009 at 05:25 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
The "kiyor" in the Mishkan was made from the mirrors that the Noshim Tzidkoniyos in Mitzrayim used to beautify themselves for their husbands. When Moshe Rabbeinu did not want to use them, Hashem instructed him that they were holy and that they indeed deserved to be used in the building of the Mishkan. If Hashem found the women's actions worthy enough to find a place in His home, can we maybe find a place in our homes for a woman to beautify herself for her Chosson/husband?
107
Sep 01, 2009 at 06:13 PM A Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ 1. Every Kallah has a very special inner beauty as the Shechinah rests on her. Why cover it up with makeup?
2. I was told by a Rov that women are forbidden to wear eye makeup - Yeshaya Chapter 3 Posuk 16. It says that eye makeup is an abomination to Hashem and was one of the causes of Golus. I have since been told by one lady it means only eye liner another told me it means only eye shadow.
3. If that is the cause of the golus let us chuck out our makeup!
4. In Sem our Rov used to tell us that every Frum girl has a special Chein why cover it up? The few girls who wore makeup he used to ask what are you trying to cover up? ”
Why was this Rov looking so closely at these young girls' faces? Let him keep his eyes down and only look at his wife.
108
Sep 01, 2009 at 06:40 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Buy the way, Wearing a robe in public was long forbiden by very choshivah robonim in both the Litvish and chasidisha sects because of the fact that it clings to the body. So it could be a problem with tznuis.
I can understand where this coming from. The fact is that a lot of tzadikim didn't hold from it. I don't see anything wrong with them trying to keep halacha and manhagim the way it should be.
I personelly feel that writing communism on people that try to be their best in Yidishkeit "shmekd fin Apikorses" from the Fargrebta America Streets"
lets not for get the 3 reasons the yidin where freed from Mitzraim.
Now for those who are worried about them spending money on this. I would assume that its sort of a hachnasas kalah fund and in stead of making the girls feel bad that they are taking money from charity for the chasunah they are geting in a diffrent way. ”
The Yidden were freed from mitzrayim in zechus of the women who polished a metal to see their reflection to beautify themselves for their husbands.
109
Sep 01, 2009 at 06:35 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Why was this Rov looking so closely at these young girls' faces? Let him keep his eyes down and only look at his wife. ”
and when he does look at his wife make sure there is no makeup on!!
110
Sep 01, 2009 at 06:35 PM Litvak Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I believe in order to get the $1000 shekels, they can't wear any makeup...my opinion: if they offered $10,000 shekels, still not worth it... a kallah should look beautiful...guys: let's all remember the chasunah song that is still played at all--including charedi--weddings: "Kaytzad merakdim....Kallah noeh kachassidah"--the kallah is beautiful as a chassidah (a bird)... ”
webmom Says:Says:
"a kallah should look beautiful...guys: let's all remember the chasunah song that is still played at all--including charedi--weddings: "Kaytzad merakdim....Kallah noeh kachassidah"--the kallah is beautiful as a chassidah (a bird)...”
No that's not what it says, but maybe you sing that! The words are "Kallah Noeh v'Chasudah", (not k'Chassidah). Good laugh though!
111
Sep 01, 2009 at 07:06 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ What is the actual long term goal?
Is this supposed to make the women more tzanua?
To who?
Is this supposed to somehow protect the men?
From who?
From their own wife?
If the husband is accustomed to women who don't put on make-up, will that make him somehow immune from attraction to women?
Is it really a mitzvah to make men lose attraction for women???
This is so mixed up!
In the Torah world in which I was raised, the basic concept was for a man and a woman to get married, and find spiritual, and physical love for each other - largely in private.
The nisoyon of attraction to or jealousy of someone's else's spouse is part of the normal human experience.
The Torah requires that we overcome these feelings in the process of growth.
The process includes (but is not limited to)
Focusing on the positive attributes of your own spouse.
Appreciating the unique inner and outer beauty of your own wife.
Finding the good in your husband, and letting him know that he is special to you.
Maintaining a level of privacy about your own spouse, so as not to flaunt your good fortune.
Developing an ayin tov, to be happy for your friend if you notice the positive attributes in their spouse.
Dismissing and ignoring the attempts of the yetzer hora to make you jealous of someone else's spouse, is a life-long avoda.
Your focus needs to be re-directed to your own life, and how you can make it better.
It takes work by two individuals devoted to each other to build something strong together.
Blaming women (or men) for the reality of the yetzer hora is foolish.
Giving the yetzer hora undue attention actually empowers it.
Aizehu Gibor Hakovesh es Yitzro.
Who ever said it's supposed to be easy? ”
I haven't read such a true and profound comment in a long time...
I wish I could meet you and hear more about your torah-true hashkufas...
112
Sep 01, 2009 at 06:58 PM merkin Says:Report as Inappropriate
last time I lained Shir Ha Shirim, I noticed some nice references to female beauty. So, you are telling me this is ossur? So then why is it in Tanach? And don't tell me it is an allegory of love between Am Yisroel and HaShem. I already know that. But you see the women in Shir HaShirim are described in great deatail as BEAUTOIFUL!
113
Sep 01, 2009 at 06:44 PM Miss Williamsburg Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ "why cant these people let both girls and boys (men and woman) live their life and look how they want to look."
You don't understand. The essence of the hareidi lifestyle is for their leaders to squeeze out and repress every last little bit of life and joy from their followers; By living this dark, painful lifestyle, they somehow believe they will earn a great share of olam haboah. We can only feel sorry for the innocent children who have no choice but to stay in the dark as their parents and teachers insist they must. ”
Truly, you are wasting your pity. Please go feel sorry for innocent children that really need pity. None of us live in the dark and as you call it, a dark painful lifestyle.
Because one school somewhere in E"Y gave out this strange rule doesn't mean that all of us living the Haredi lifestyle will now follow it. Your definition on the essence of the Haredi lifestyle is contrary to my Haredi lifestyle.
114
Sep 01, 2009 at 05:54 PM Raphael Kaufman Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ WHH
I am so disappointed in the respondents posting their opinions on this issue. They are filled with such defensiveness, and such catty venomous remarks, that one can only conclude that our respondents here on this forum are threatened by this very Jewish and very Israeli expression of piety. That you ladies, I imagine mostly, and gentleman in Chutz L'aretz fail to understand that this is a personal choice of the Kallah, and that makeup does not equal beauty in any form. It is shallow to assume that every woman desires the made up look. I wore no makeup to my own wedding by choice, nobody paid me anything neither did i need it. Nor did I get my hair done nor did I wear or purchase a sheitel. And 20 years later, i still don't indulge my time to focus on such ridiculous frivolity. I am also American and had the best education and upbringing and material advantages that the USA has to offer. I think if a woman needs to feel attractive she should do what makes her feel comfortable and content, but you should know that excessive focus is most unattractive on everyone. Thick layers of makeup are used injudiciously in many circles in the West and should not be worn as a badge of honor by anyone. Yes it is a chumrah, either way it's a chumrah, and therefore, a personal decision which you should all keep to yourselves. ”
Every Kallah can chose, as you did, to go under the chupah without adornment. That is their personal choice, but there is nothing particularly pious or even remotely Jewish about it.
115
Sep 01, 2009 at 07:38 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Just because you don't believe in this, doesn't make it wrong, crazy or idiotic. Everybody has the right to do what they want. Each person has a right to agree with whomever they please, but belittling the beliefs and views of others is wrong! unless there is something wrong(against the torah perhaps) with what they are implementing then there is no place to put them down. Do i agree with the above article, no. But they are obviously in a different place, and hold different things, so don't just mock what they are doing just because it differs from what your beliefs are. ”
No. We are supposed to follow the Gemara and the Shulchan Aruch. Where they are silent, perhaps each can do as he or she sees proper. But no one has permission to make up chumrahs that go against an open Gemara!
116
Sep 01, 2009 at 07:57 PM Reality Check Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I haven't read such a true and profound comment in a long time...
I wish I could meet you and hear more about your torah-true hashkufas... ”
Go to shiurim.
Learn Torah from ba'alei mussar.
That's where I got my hashkafos from.
117
Sep 01, 2009 at 07:49 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
"..no one has permission to make up chumrahs that go against an open Gemara!"
What nareshkiet are you spouting....The rabbonim are making up new chumrahs every rosh chodesh to find some new way of making a name for themselves as being more machmir than the rebbe next door. There are numerous takanahs that many feel obligated to follow today that to most yiddin clearly contradict what a an attorney would refer to as "settled law" or in your venacular, "an open g
Gemara".
118
Sep 01, 2009 at 07:48 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Then they find men hanging out in clubs or with other women because their wives don't dress to attract them!
119
Sep 01, 2009 at 08:19 PM mythoughts2 Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ 1. Every Kallah has a very special inner beauty as the Shechinah rests on her. Why cover it up with makeup?
2. I was told by a Rov that women are forbidden to wear eye makeup - Yeshaya Chapter 3 Posuk 16. It says that eye makeup is an abomination to Hashem and was one of the causes of Golus. I have since been told by one lady it means only eye liner another told me it means only eye shadow.
3. If that is the cause of the golus let us chuck out our makeup!
4. In Sem our Rov used to tell us that every Frum girl has a special Chein why cover it up? The few girls who wore makeup he used to ask what are you trying to cover up? ”
Amazing, my Rov said the Golus was caused by the use of foundation, I'm confused. Get a life!!! How in earth can you blame Golus on eye makeup? What happened to Sinas Chinum. I remember learning that this was the main reason for the Churban and the main reason the Golus isn't over. By blaming woman for the Golus because of eye makeup you are definitely perpetuating Sinas Chinum. Live and let live. There are much bigger issues in the world than makeup.
120
Sep 01, 2009 at 08:13 PM BREAKING NEWS Says:Report as Inappropriate
This is old news...There is another seminary that is offering 1000 NIS for the Kallah to "stay home" on the night of her wedding!!!
121
Sep 01, 2009 at 08:35 PM surie Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Shulchan Aruch allows make-up for a Kallah even during periods where it might otherwise be prohibited le-halacha....but then again artscroll never made a shulchan aruch for the hassidic sector: hamenukad ve-hamevo-ar ”
where exactly in Shulchan Aruch? not mocking just curious and wan't to be able to point out to others..
122
Sep 01, 2009 at 08:32 PM shimon Says:Report as Inappropriate
This is not a chumra, this is a tremendous kullah bordering (or breaching) with an issur. Ein am haaretz chassid.
123
Sep 01, 2009 at 08:22 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
they should start paying the boys to not wear hats at their wedding. I am waiting for that to happen. :)
124
Sep 01, 2009 at 08:46 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Why not simply blindfold the chassan and kallah, have a shaliach sign the ketubah on their behalf, and hold the yichud in separate rooms so they cannot peek before the rav is masader kiddushim. This will avoid any risk that the chassan might back out and the last minute and see what the kallah looks like.
126
Sep 01, 2009 at 09:27 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
How many times do we see in chazal 'Lchabeva Al Baala'?
This is the ultimate 'Chossid Shoteh'.
127
Sep 01, 2009 at 09:43 PM Another 5T resident Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Just because you don't believe in this, doesn't make it wrong, crazy or idiotic. Everybody has the right to do what they want. Each person has a right to agree with whomever they please, but belittling the beliefs and views of others is wrong! unless there is something wrong(against the torah perhaps) with what they are implementing then there is no place to put them down. Do i agree with the above article, no. But they are obviously in a different place, and hold different things, so don't just mock what they are doing just because it differs from what your beliefs are. ”
"unless there is something wrong(against the torah perhaps) with what they are implementing then there is no place to put them down"
When I read this aloud to my husband his first reaction was "It is assur to disallow makeup by a kallah" and he proceeded to quote a few gemaras about it, mostly from kesubos. I am sorry that I can't quote you the page numbers.
128
Sep 01, 2009 at 10:21 PM chanaleah Says:Report as Inappropriate
No one is saying that makeup is assur. There was a problem that girls who were normally not allowed to were makeup in school at all, would suddenly go waaaay overboard at the one chance they were allowed to - their wedding. The school didn't want this happening, so they offered an incentive. They couldn't have said, "You get paid if you only wear a little bit of makeup at your wedding", since I don't think most kallos would appreciate the makeup police surveying their eyeshadow under the chuppah, so instead they made a blanket rule which would hopefully change the standard, so even the girls who do wear makeup would wear less.
I'm not saying this was the right way to solve the problem - I'm just explaining their reasoning, to show that they are not as completely crazy and overboard as people are saying.
129
Sep 02, 2009 at 05:03 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I believe in order to get the $1000 shekels, they can't wear any makeup...my opinion: if they offered $10,000 shekels, still not worth it... a kallah should look beautiful...guys: let's all remember the chasunah song that is still played at all--including charedi--weddings: "Kaytzad merakdim....Kallah noeh kachassidah"--the kallah is beautiful as a chassidah (a bird)... ”
aside for being a nice song it can be found in the gemara as the basis of a machloket between beit hillel and beit shamai as to whether you can say that about an ugly bride (go check it out ketubot 17a...wait, i am a female and probably shouldn't know that) furthermore it is kallah na'ah va'chasudah=a beautiful and graceful bride.
not kallah noeh kachassidah=beautiful as a bird.
130
Sep 02, 2009 at 04:11 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Girls should make themselves look beautiful, especially kallas!!! all our mother ancestors put makeup on and rightly so!
131
Sep 02, 2009 at 02:46 AM matzahlocal101 Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ With all the atrosoties against women in that forsaken country...you are going to make 'make-up' the battle you chose to fight for them?? how about the fact they have only met their husbands once? Arranged marriages? Forced to have kids? More physically abused than not...It is just mind boggeling. But it is the make-up causing an outrage.....that makes sence! ”
And the award for the more offensive outrageous comment of all goes to #62.
Who alleges that chareidi girls are subject to
1) arranged marriages after meeting their husband once. After her family has thoroughly checked out the prospective in laws, siblings, and choson without subjective motivation as opposed to the YU guy that trys pick up a girl in a bar because he feel she's physically attractive without knowing anything about her or her family.
2) she is forced to have kids. Once upon a time G-d's blessing of be fruitful and multiply, now a curse because it takes time away from tennis, theatre, travel, and the opera.
3) More physically abused then not. A less scientific, better piece of anti-semitism couldn't have come from Goebbels. All these allegations miss one point. Chareidim get married younger, have more kids, have a lower divorce rate that the Modern orthodox poster who are screaming Taliban because they have no clue what Judaism is about. To chareidi boy that never had a girl friend, doesn't watch TV or movies, and doesn't look at girls, he may not even notice the Kallah isn't wearing make-up, this as opposed to the modern orthodox critic who has been dating since he was twelve, has crowled all over dozens of girls, has seen twenty thousand different women in TV and movies by the time he's eighteen and having been inflkuenced by the goyishe standard what is and what is not beautiful, has decided that he wants ot marry a girl that looks like a super model and performs like a porn star. The problem from a statistical standpoint is that there are only a small number of super model and porn stars to fill the needs of the general population and an even smaller number of "frum" super models and porn stars. So he occupies himself with this search from the time he's 25 to the time he's 40 and he realizes that what he's looking for doesn't exist and he lowers he's goyishe expectations and starts thinking like a Jew and gets engaged. Meanwhile the chareidi Jew who the MO has been ridiculing for the past 20 years, is happily married, has 20 kids, and is preparing for the wedding of his oldest, he will be celebrating the birth of his first granchild, as the MO gets married. The MO on the other hand will likely never see his grandchildren because he follows the current mating habits of the American Goy. So in answer to the above poster, if you think like a Jew, make-up may very well be the main problem. Of course if you think like a Goy getting married at the age stated in the mishnah and shulchan oruch and particpating as a partner with Hashem in the creation of children is terrible thing.
132
Sep 02, 2009 at 02:07 AM women from lakewood Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I see nothing wrong according to Halacha and modesty for a bride to apply make-up for one of the most important events in her life not to mention to make her self attractive to her future husband! ”
but for the husband she should put on makeup at home, you don't need that all man sohuld see her with makeup, in all the gemuras that you see that they used makeup they used it in the house for the husbend not for the street.
133
Sep 02, 2009 at 01:56 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
The true toradige way is to wear make up at home and wash off the excess before walking out on the street. Especially if you are a tichel lady living in boro park like me you would have to be downright stupid and naïve to not wear make up and a nice shaitel in your home.
134
Sep 02, 2009 at 01:25 AM prili Says:Report as Inappropriate
How come these seminary girls are so much more holy than the women in mitsrayim. they wore makeup for their husbands, but these lil pishers are on such a high madraigah that they are above such trivialities. If there was ever a time and place for makeup- the wedding day would be it
135
Sep 02, 2009 at 01:04 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ The reason y a woman needs to be attracted to her husband is to have kids....look at the difference in family size b4 u talk ”
Very funny, they don't believe in birth control so they get pregnant every time they go to the mikvah. That has nothing to do with attraction. Btw I am married for 15 years and my wife doesn't need a drop of make up to gorgeous. A healthy life style with lots of outdoor activity keeps a person in shape and keeps a person naturally beautiful. But a lot of chareidishe leaders decided that exercise is osur and kugel etc is not very helpful with keeping in shape so instead of helping their flock to be more health conscious they come up with all these crazy takoones.
136
Sep 02, 2009 at 12:52 AM Jerusalem Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Every Kallah can chose, as you did, to go under the chupah without adornment. That is their personal choice, but there is nothing particularly pious or even remotely Jewish about it. ”
WHH
As you well know, Sir, No-one is permitted to interfere with what a person does for G-D, or in what specific way they dedicate their lives to avodah. That in your opinion, it is not particularly pious act, is just that, your opinion, but who are you and what is your opinion? Are you G-D who can see into the intent of the hearts of men? Any one who goes against the grain and chooses a higher purpose for their lives solely for the sake of Heaven is in my opinion a pious person, and in addition, judging from the hateful and vicious comments here on this blog, we will have to say a brave person who will suffer the slings and arrows of a pursuer.
By the way, in my case, I did not forgo wearing makeup at my own wedding specifically as an expression of piety, i.e. attaching my deeds for the sake of Heaven. I am personally repulsed by the idea of focus on physicality in a public setting, and I am personally repulsed by the mask like appearance of a made up face, nor do my features require enhancement. Neither do I regard myself as exceptionally pious, only striving for it. However, I take great offense and am quite frankly appalled at the shallowness of the respondents on this forum, Mostly women and men without much benefit from Torah. I applaud any girl who chooses for herself in what special way she will dedicate her life to serve G-D, and it is not for you or anyone else to judge. This is an example of a parade of the grotesque... All ones pathetic attachments to this olam ha sheker are painfully apparent, once, that is, you raise yourself up out of the facts and look with a broader view. And this, Sir, is only my opinion.
137
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:32 PM to number 9 Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I would say perhaps more importantly would be a campaign against tightly fitted gowns for kallos as well as family members! Unfortunately even with regular clothing this plague has become all too common. And stop wearing flairy skirts that reveal the knees when walking! Why? Not because men can't control themselves, but because that's what Hashem wants! Ask any Rav!
OK all you seculary influenced fanatics, you can start attacking me now! ”
I think that it is time for tznius to be handled only by women. It is a disgrace that men tell women how to dress.
138
Sep 01, 2009 at 11:10 PM boroparkyenta Says:Report as Inappropriate
The problem arises when girls are not taught how to wear just a little bit to look naturally better, and are not allowed to wear it during their teens. As soon as they "are free" especially beginning with their wedding night, they want a ton of makeup, not realizing that less is more. A pretty girl needs almost no makeup. A girl that is not naturally beautiful can be made to look more attractive with a little bit of the right kind of makeup. However, a girl with very bad skin or really bad features, would need a professional with full camouflage makeup, and whoever married her hopefully has poor eyesight! Or maybe hopefully he thinks she is beautiful due to her inner beauty.
Regardless, most of the really chareidi girls that have simple weddings, have no makeup anyway, and have less of everything else, no photographer, no flowers, no fancy gowns. I have been to such a wedding in Meah Shearim, where I was the only one there in a shaitel. As the "shiksa" I took the camera and took the photos. There was no photographer. And the kalla, who had absolutely no makeup and wore a braid prior to the chupa, wore a veil while dancing with the women. By the mitzva tantz there was a mechitza, so the men could not see the women. And the kalla wore her veil all night! But she was such a real mench, when she danced with me , and only with me, knowing I came all the way from Boro Park to be with them, she threw back her veil to dance with me the way I was used to it...... she was so warm, and outgoing, and so was the entire family. She is very happily married to a fanatic Toldos Aharon chusid, with two children by now. And although she and her family may be a bit extreme for our American standards, they are the nicest and warmest people once you get to know them. In general, I prefer the less made up kallas, and most of the time I see beautiful girls that have a few pounds of makeup on and they look horrid. They look so much prettier without all those globs of junk on their young and naturally pretty faces.
My sons, who are not ultra fanatic, begged me to ask their kallas not to put on make up to the wedding. They all hate make up. I wear very little makeup, thankfully looking attractive enough without a ton of the stuff.
Of course, I told them that whatever they want they can ask for after the wedding... and they do. Their wives rarely wear anything more than a bit of blush, as their husbands are attracted to them anyway, without the makeup.
A good supper, a clean home, children that are taken care of, and a well rested and patient spouse will endear them to their wives more than the makeup.
And most of the chareidim have great marriages despite the lack of makeup in their lives. At least the ones I know personally.
So the problem is with lack of self esteem in some, and lack of common sense in others.
139
Sep 01, 2009 at 10:56 PM Kiss & make-up Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ where exactly in Shulchan Aruch? not mocking just curious and wan't to be able to point out to others.. ”
surie Says:Says:
“where exactly in Shulchan Aruch? not mocking just curious and want to be able to point out to others..”
This is indeed one of the basic halachos every man is taught right at the beginning.
The source is: Shulchan Aruch Yoreh Deah in Siman Kuf-tzadik-hay, Sif Tes. It is short and clear. Loose translation: With great reluctance, (the Chachomim) were Matir (permitted) cosmetics during her Niddah time only due to reason she should not become "ugly" to her husband. Shelo tisganeh al baaloh (far-ekelt). Look it up or have someone show it to you. Better yet, get ahold of Rabbi Shimon Eider's "Sefer Hilchos Niddah" (volume 2) written in plain English with all sources all along the way. It is not Bubbe Maaseh's but simply the Shulchan Aruch tarnslated into English along with notes from current Poskim etc. Every married couple should own one unless you can't read or speak English. Even if you speak Yiddish but are fkuent in English, you should own this sefer. Check any seforim store (or online at Eichler's.com etc.)
140
Sep 02, 2009 at 08:43 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ surie Says:Says:
“where exactly in Shulchan Aruch? not mocking just curious and want to be able to point out to others..”
This is indeed one of the basic halachos every man is taught right at the beginning.
The source is: Shulchan Aruch Yoreh Deah in Siman Kuf-tzadik-hay, Sif Tes. It is short and clear. Loose translation: With great reluctance, (the Chachomim) were Matir (permitted) cosmetics during her Niddah time only due to reason she should not become "ugly" to her husband. Shelo tisganeh al baaloh (far-ekelt). Look it up or have someone show it to you. Better yet, get ahold of Rabbi Shimon Eider's "Sefer Hilchos Niddah" (volume 2) written in plain English with all sources all along the way. It is not Bubbe Maaseh's but simply the Shulchan Aruch tarnslated into English along with notes from current Poskim etc. Every married couple should own one unless you can't read or speak English. Even if you speak Yiddish but are fkuent in English, you should own this sefer. Check any seforim store (or online at Eichler's.com etc.)
”
Surie,
I am glad you found the sefer you like so much. However, I would be extremely weary of using ANY hilchos nida sefer for anything but refreshing a basic halocha - definitely not for deciding practical matters. It is never a substitute for speaking to a Rav, fully presenting all the facts. You might be surprised that the personal psak is often more lenient, than a "one fit all" approach, inherent to any printed sefer
141
Sep 02, 2009 at 09:30 AM webmom Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Why not simply blindfold the chassan and kallah, have a shaliach sign the ketubah on their behalf, and hold the yichud in separate rooms so they cannot peek before the rav is masader kiddushim. This will avoid any risk that the chassan might back out and the last minute and see what the kallah looks like. ”
actually today it really is possible to totally just do away with marriage--it can now all be done artificially--and have the men and women live on different parts of the city!
142
Sep 02, 2009 at 09:25 AM webmom Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ The true toradige way is to wear make up at home and wash off the excess before walking out on the street. Especially if you are a tichel lady living in boro park like me you would have to be downright stupid and naïve to not wear make up and a nice shaitel in your home. ”
You know, this makes a good sound bite....so next time while I'm cleaning the bathroom, making supper, vacuuming, washing and ironing...I'll make sure to be all made up, dressed in my newest suit, wearing stockings and high heels...hmmmm.. maybe on second thought...not so workable.....then when I go to work i'll go in my snood....hmmmm....defeinitely not so workable either.... (oh I forgot! I work with my husband, so I'll get to "dress" when I go to work too!!!)
143
Sep 02, 2009 at 10:07 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ No one is saying that makeup is assur. There was a problem that girls who were normally not allowed to were makeup in school at all, would suddenly go waaaay overboard at the one chance they were allowed to - their wedding. The school didn't want this happening, so they offered an incentive. They couldn't have said, "You get paid if you only wear a little bit of makeup at your wedding", since I don't think most kallos would appreciate the makeup police surveying their eyeshadow under the chuppah, so instead they made a blanket rule which would hopefully change the standard, so even the girls who do wear makeup would wear less.
I'm not saying this was the right way to solve the problem - I'm just explaining their reasoning, to show that they are not as completely crazy and overboard as people are saying. ”
If the girls all go way overboard as soon as they're "free" from the boundaries of the school then apparently the school's chinuch isn't working. Aren't schools supposed to be teaching us the way of life for the future? If these kids are dropping what they're learning as soon as they're out, then the school better recheck their method of teaching.
144
Sep 02, 2009 at 11:34 AM unbelvbl Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I would say perhaps more importantly would be a campaign against tightly fitted gowns for kallos as well as family members! Unfortunately even with regular clothing this plague has become all too common. And stop wearing flairy skirts that reveal the knees when walking! Why? Not because men can't control themselves, but because that's what Hashem wants! Ask any Rav!
OK all you seculary influenced fanatics, you can start attacking me now! ”
What does this have to do with subject at hand? Isn’t it enough that we make our girls to cut their hair (which BTW has no source in Halacha), like a slave women captured in battle (parshas Ki Sitzie)? What is this that we are treating out own daughters like a Sotah? Do you think that by making them look unappealing you will save the world from sin??? I have news for you: you are fooling yourself, because emaciated Ethiopian women also get raped even though they look to YOU extremely unattractive. We need balance, and having a Kallah not put on makeup is way over the line.
145
Sep 02, 2009 at 11:05 AM Beheimish Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ I'm confused, from all the comments in general on Chareidy related issues it appears as though the non chreidy community will be zocha to be the first that Moshiach will come to, and that they are the most beloved to Hashem, However the Chareidy community who invest so little sacrifice to Hashem and look ugly with those big beards, and fat make-up-less overdressed woman will be put in hell and all of us with Shaven beards and oversexed wives will be singled out for special treatment by Hashem and Moshach due to their major contribution for Am Yisroel....... Come on get real..... ”
You should not be confused ... the Chareidim who make prolific Chillulei Hashem (by rioting like Bulvans in the Streets and brazenly behaving corruptly), don't show Kavod Habrios (e.g. violently throw women to the back of the bus; have zero respect for their Israeli brethren who defend them, fund them, and serve in the army), distort the roots/foundations of Chassidus (tolerance of different flavors of Yiddeshkeit, non-Misnagged-rigidity of behavior, and unconditional love for all Yidden), and, most egregiously, pervert Yahadus and Torah with ignorant, insulting, and nonsensical mores (like encouraging Kallahs not to wear makeup at their weddings) ... will NOT be the catalysts for Moshiach. On the contrary - they are holding it back. There shouldn't be any confusion for you ... as the Yidden who prize Emmes, integrity (e.g. paying taxes and not cheating in business), Kavod Habrios (V'Ahavta Le'Rayacha Kamocha), philanthropy (those who give vs. those who take/grab/demand/steal with disdain), are proactively Makir Tov (e.g. thank and give a seat to a Chayal - like one of Heiligeh Rizhiner Rebbes did years ago), and live by a proper Mesora (not Chassid Shoteh behavior) - will be the ones who bring the Moshiach.
146
Sep 02, 2009 at 12:26 PM MO and Proud Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ And the award for the more offensive outrageous comment of all goes to #62.
Who alleges that chareidi girls are subject to
1) arranged marriages after meeting their husband once. After her family has thoroughly checked out the prospective in laws, siblings, and choson without subjective motivation as opposed to the YU guy that trys pick up a girl in a bar because he feel she's physically attractive without knowing anything about her or her family.
2) she is forced to have kids. Once upon a time G-d's blessing of be fruitful and multiply, now a curse because it takes time away from tennis, theatre, travel, and the opera.
3) More physically abused then not. A less scientific, better piece of anti-semitism couldn't have come from Goebbels. All these allegations miss one point. Chareidim get married younger, have more kids, have a lower divorce rate that the Modern orthodox poster who are screaming Taliban because they have no clue what Judaism is about. To chareidi boy that never had a girl friend, doesn't watch TV or movies, and doesn't look at girls, he may not even notice the Kallah isn't wearing make-up, this as opposed to the modern orthodox critic who has been dating since he was twelve, has crowled all over dozens of girls, has seen twenty thousand different women in TV and movies by the time he's eighteen and having been inflkuenced by the goyishe standard what is and what is not beautiful, has decided that he wants ot marry a girl that looks like a super model and performs like a porn star. The problem from a statistical standpoint is that there are only a small number of super model and porn stars to fill the needs of the general population and an even smaller number of "frum" super models and porn stars. So he occupies himself with this search from the time he's 25 to the time he's 40 and he realizes that what he's looking for doesn't exist and he lowers he's goyishe expectations and starts thinking like a Jew and gets engaged. Meanwhile the chareidi Jew who the MO has been ridiculing for the past 20 years, is happily married, has 20 kids, and is preparing for the wedding of his oldest, he will be celebrating the birth of his first granchild, as the MO gets married. The MO on the other hand will likely never see his grandchildren because he follows the current mating habits of the American Goy. So in answer to the above poster, if you think like a Jew, make-up may very well be the main problem. Of course if you think like a Goy getting married at the age stated in the mishnah and shulchan oruch and particpating as a partner with Hashem in the creation of children is terrible thing. ”
What an insulting way to write about your fellow Jews, modern Orthodox or not. I am so called Modern Orthodox and I don't recognize the nasty caricature you paint with your hateful words. I know many fine loving MO families where the children marry at a young age and grandparents dote on the grandchildren. Who are you to call other Jews "goyishe"? That is just nasty and mean. What happened to caring about your fellow Jew? You just want to trash people. What possible contribution have you made to achdus? Terrible.
147
Sep 02, 2009 at 02:34 PM Beheimish Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ And the award for the more offensive outrageous comment of all goes to #62.
Who alleges that chareidi girls are subject to
1) arranged marriages after meeting their husband once. After her family has thoroughly checked out the prospective in laws, siblings, and choson without subjective motivation as opposed to the YU guy that trys pick up a girl in a bar because he feel she's physically attractive without knowing anything about her or her family.
2) she is forced to have kids. Once upon a time G-d's blessing of be fruitful and multiply, now a curse because it takes time away from tennis, theatre, travel, and the opera.
3) More physically abused then not. A less scientific, better piece of anti-semitism couldn't have come from Goebbels. All these allegations miss one point. Chareidim get married younger, have more kids, have a lower divorce rate that the Modern orthodox poster who are screaming Taliban because they have no clue what Judaism is about. To chareidi boy that never had a girl friend, doesn't watch TV or movies, and doesn't look at girls, he may not even notice the Kallah isn't wearing make-up, this as opposed to the modern orthodox critic who has been dating since he was twelve, has crowled all over dozens of girls, has seen twenty thousand different women in TV and movies by the time he's eighteen and having been inflkuenced by the goyishe standard what is and what is not beautiful, has decided that he wants ot marry a girl that looks like a super model and performs like a porn star. The problem from a statistical standpoint is that there are only a small number of super model and porn stars to fill the needs of the general population and an even smaller number of "frum" super models and porn stars. So he occupies himself with this search from the time he's 25 to the time he's 40 and he realizes that what he's looking for doesn't exist and he lowers he's goyishe expectations and starts thinking like a Jew and gets engaged. Meanwhile the chareidi Jew who the MO has been ridiculing for the past 20 years, is happily married, has 20 kids, and is preparing for the wedding of his oldest, he will be celebrating the birth of his first granchild, as the MO gets married. The MO on the other hand will likely never see his grandchildren because he follows the current mating habits of the American Goy. So in answer to the above poster, if you think like a Jew, make-up may very well be the main problem. Of course if you think like a Goy getting married at the age stated in the mishnah and shulchan oruch and particpating as a partner with Hashem in the creation of children is terrible thing. ”
matzahlocal101 - It sounds like you have an accurate grasp of the YU velt , how modern orthodox people behave, and what they covet. Your depiction of YU graduates is extremely enlightening - for according to you they primarily look to marry porn star (you mentioned "porn star" 3 times) looking/performing women, never check out a prospective spouse's family, primarily pick women up in bars, and don't marry until they are 40. Sounds like you (do you shtam from Goebbels perhaps?) are well-educated and informed, a prolific/erudite Talmid Chochom, a paragon of Menshlachkeit/Ahavas Yisroel, and a fervent disciple of the Chofetz Chaim.
148
Sep 03, 2009 at 12:26 AM matzahlocal101 Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ What does this have to do with subject at hand? Isn’t it enough that we make our girls to cut their hair (which BTW has no source in Halacha), like a slave women captured in battle (parshas Ki Sitzie)? What is this that we are treating out own daughters like a Sotah? Do you think that by making them look unappealing you will save the world from sin??? I have news for you: you are fooling yourself, because emaciated Ethiopian women also get raped even though they look to YOU extremely unattractive. We need balance, and having a Kallah not put on makeup is way over the line. ”
The do not cut their hair like slaves, however that is the reason they pierce their ears. -Pirkei d'Reb Eliezer
149
Sep 03, 2009 at 12:23 AM matzahlocal101 Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ surie Says:Says:
“where exactly in Shulchan Aruch? not mocking just curious and want to be able to point out to others..”
This is indeed one of the basic halachos every man is taught right at the beginning.
The source is: Shulchan Aruch Yoreh Deah in Siman Kuf-tzadik-hay, Sif Tes. It is short and clear. Loose translation: With great reluctance, (the Chachomim) were Matir (permitted) cosmetics during her Niddah time only due to reason she should not become "ugly" to her husband. Shelo tisganeh al baaloh (far-ekelt). Look it up or have someone show it to you. Better yet, get ahold of Rabbi Shimon Eider's "Sefer Hilchos Niddah" (volume 2) written in plain English with all sources all along the way. It is not Bubbe Maaseh's but simply the Shulchan Aruch tarnslated into English along with notes from current Poskim etc. Every married couple should own one unless you can't read or speak English. Even if you speak Yiddish but are fkuent in English, you should own this sefer. Check any seforim store (or online at Eichler's.com etc.)
”
That siman was in vogue when the other siman -samech hay, sif bais, was in vogue. "assur lihistakl bikallah" it is forbidden for a man to look at the bride. However when the bride walks in and all the men stand and turn around to look at her, she is best off without make-up. Save it for the house. Please do not bother quoting the ro"sh. It is of note that the Tur argues on his father the ro'sh and says likewise it is forbidden to look at the kallah.
150
Sep 03, 2009 at 11:05 AM MS Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ Buy the way, Wearing a robe in public was long forbiden by very choshivah robonim in both the Litvish and chasidisha sects because of the fact that it clings to the body. So it could be a problem with tznuis.
I can understand where this coming from. The fact is that a lot of tzadikim didn't hold from it. I don't see anything wrong with them trying to keep halacha and manhagim the way it should be.
I personelly feel that writing communism on people that try to be their best in Yidishkeit "shmekd fin Apikorses" from the Fargrebta America Streets"
lets not for get the 3 reasons the yidin where freed from Mitzraim.
Now for those who are worried about them spending money on this. I would assume that its sort of a hachnasas kalah fund and in stead of making the girls feel bad that they are taking money from charity for the chasunah they are geting in a diffrent way. ”
I am baffled and stupified by what this school wants to do. One should take a look at a fascinating Mishna in Meseches Nedarim, Mishna Tes or Daf 66 in Meseches Nedarim on how the Great Tanna, Rebbi Yishmael cared so deeply for the single Jewish girls that he was personally involved in not only making shidduchim for them but he would buy makeup,clothing or anything else in order that they would look beautiful so they could find a spouse. The Mishna tells us how he cried out for them and said Bnos Yisroel are beautiful but their poverty take away their ability to make themselves beautiful(they are unable to buy makeup,etc to beautify themselves. The Mishna concludes when Rebbi Yishmael passed away, Jewish woman broke out in terrible mourning for him and even composed an elegy(kinah) on his behalf. The woman all knew that Rebbi Yishmael was the champion for their cause. There are great lessons in this Mishna/Gemorah. If Rabbeinu Hakodosh instituted this in the Mishnayos we have to learn how important Chazal felt of the importance and dignity of Jewish woman. No Jewish school has a right to make such a proposal. It goes against the teaches of our Sages and plain common sense.