Welcome, Guest! - or
Easy to remember!  »  VinNews.com

Jerusalem - Sephardim Switch to 'Ashkenazi' Surnames to Ensure Their Children's Admission to Charedi Schools

Published on:   September 9, 2009 12:47 PM
News Source:  Ynet By Kobi Nahshoni
Change text size Text Size  
Bookmark and Share

Jerusalem - As the public and legal struggle to curb discrimination within haredi educational institutions continues, many still face difficulties in enrolling their children to desirable ultra-Orthodox schools, and some parents of Sephardic descent have resorted to changing their last names just to fit in.

Haredi weekly “Mishpacha” (“Family”) reported in its most recent edition a growing trend of ultra-Orthodox families of eastern descent Hebraizing or “Ashkenizing” their surnames in order to increase their children’s chances of being accepted to Ashkenazi seminaries and yeshivas.

The clerks at the Interior Ministry’s population registry are already used to the practice: The family name Turjeman is changed to Truzman, Mussayev to Moskovitch, Shavo to Shavan, and so on.

“It’s no secret that Sephardic quotas in Ashkenazi educational institutions are limited,” said David Rot (pseudonym), formerly Shitreet. “Every Sephardic parent that registers their son to an educational institution is met with a stack of difficulties, unless they have a well known reputation or are well connected, or if they place a hefty donation on the table and the money makes up for the name.”

Advertisement:

Yair Lev (pseudonym) who also changed his last name said, “I would rather not have taken this step, but in this world, everyone just looks at the outer wrapping of the name. If you don’t have to right name, things are harder for you.”

Both Rot and Lev said they had encountered much criticism from neighbors and members of their communities, with comments such as, “What’s so bad about being Moroccan?”, “The world isn’t stupid, who are you fooling? You were born Moroccan and you will stay that way,” but they said they had received some positive reinforcement as well.

Yoav Lalom, of the “Halacha Youth” organization for the struggle against discrimination in the haredi sector, told Ynet he is familiar with the phenomenon, saying, “It exists, but is not widespread.”

Lalom said he opposes the practice, which he calls “the easy solution”, adding that in many cases it ends up being counterproductive, as principals have been known to discover the truth about certain students’ origin during the school year and begun to pick on the “Ashkenized” children.

Headmasters of Ashkenazi institutions seem to regret the situation: “It is a shame that such prominent Sephardic families find themselves in this kind of situation,” an Ashkenazi rabbi from a well-known Jerusalem yeshiva told Ynet. “They are God-fearing Jews, even more so than us, and I guarantee that.”

His own institution, he stressed, does not discriminate: “For some Sephardic families changing the name will not do any good, since their mentality is completely different and unsuitable for our establishment.

“It has nothing to do with descent – past experience has proven that they just don’t assimilate well. It’s a shame to have everyone frustrated over it.

“We have in our school pupils with the most obvious Sephardic names. The only admission criterion is coming from a true God-fearing home,” he continued. “You can’t generalize the Sephardic community – some are adequate and some are not and it doesn’t matter whether they’ve changed their name. We have many Sephardic pupils on our honor roll. We love them.”


More of today's headlines

Brooklyn, NY - The Hebrew Language Academy Charter School (HLA) is now officially open — in a yeshiva. HLA, which is a public school receiving tax dollars as well... Israel - This week, New York Rabbi Yair Hoffman from VIN News sat down with Yoilish Krauss in an exclusive interview in his self-described “operations bunker” in the...

 

Total50

Read Comments (50)  —  Post Yours »

1

 Sep 09, 2009 at 11:53 AM Just Thinking Says:

I hate to compare it to Nazism but that's the closest I can think of. Educating our children that one type of person is better then another type of person, can only lead to disaster. These people are our educators?
And this "Rabbi" has no fear of saying such a stupid comment like "they can't assimilate?" Who's he fooling, G-d?

2

 Sep 09, 2009 at 12:03 PM Sephardic Says:

Amazing, how racist people can be in the name of religion. There is no excuse for this, and there never will be. American Jews have no clue how bad it is. The Israeli system is totally messed up, Avreichim can't get their kids into Preschool! Where are our Gedolim when we need them?

3

 Sep 09, 2009 at 12:02 PM Eli W Says:

Can anybody explain me, how come the Sephardim don't run their own school system and yeshiva's, since they have different minhagim and learning level?

Why are we trying to mix two cultures together, we also run, litfishe, chassidishe, sephardishe, modern orthodox, Etc. yeshivas separately, but when a chasidish bochur wants to study in a litfsh yeshiva, we don't discriminate.....

4

 Sep 09, 2009 at 12:06 PM Persian Prince Says:

Oh buy, this sounds like a form of assimilation. As for me, I would have to ask the question as to why I would take my 2,500 year heritage and ancestry and throw it down the drain so that my kids can get into an "Ultra-Greasy" school. I'm happy being Sephardi and having a long and respectful chain to look back on. Slichot is not easy. But, would I give it up so that my kids can go to an Ashko School? "Fogetaboutit"

5

 Sep 09, 2009 at 12:28 PM Eli W Says:

Thinking about this, not taking sephardim into Ashkenazi yeshivas in not such a big issue to me, how about "Ashkenazim" not being accepted into "Ashkenazi"- yeshivas and schools", and this is happening all over, from Willy, Boro Park, Flatbush to Lakewood, now that's the real chutzpah, first lets settle our own problems with "accepting our children into our yeshivas and schools", and then will worry about the Sephardi community.

6

 Sep 09, 2009 at 12:28 PM Robert Says:

not too long ago jews in the USA would change their names to WASP sounding names in order to be admitted to college or professional schools...

the more things change, the more they stay the same.

7

 Sep 09, 2009 at 12:25 PM Anonymous Says:

These are the same "Rabbis" who will teach their bohrim about viohavta lareiha kamoha and cry about causes of Tisha Baav. What a disgrace.

8

 Sep 09, 2009 at 12:25 PM Fed Up Says:

Don't different Ashkenaz Communities have different customs? Aren't Polish & German Jews quite different? If we could live with that we can live with Sepharadim as well. We can teach Halacha in Schools for both Sephardim & Ashkenazim, no harm can come from it. And our children will learn that Ahavat Yisrael, means what it is, we love ALL jews regardless of their color or culture. So sad!!

9

 Sep 09, 2009 at 12:22 PM Loshon Hora Says:

Why a white won't marry a black has nothing to do with racism. The same white won't marry another white, who doesn't share the same culture & set of mannors & customs.
Not all people nor all nations were created the same.
People should try to get on as well as possible, but why force people into situations that are unbearable?
Imagine you grew up the first 10 years of your life, in Boston in an ultra religious but Modern Orthodox affiliated home. Would you at Bar Mitzvah be able to enroll in your clothing with your background & language to Kiryas Yoel Yeshiva? Would you even dream of it? Imagine they would accept you, how long would it last ? how depressed would you be?
In my opinion calling this racism & going to court about it is unfair, could these kids really succeed in such a different enviroment, can you force this integration? what happens when the kid missbehaves, because he feels he doesn't belong?
What happens when he starts up with other kids for that very reason? & then when one mother after another sends a note asking her kid sit as far away from that kid or go to another parallel?
Is it fair to call it racism & fight it in this manner? is it fair to your own poor little kid?
Boruch Hashem the Sefardim have their own Talmud Torahs who cater to their needs, just like the so called Litaim [ Litvaks who just molded themselves that way over the last half century] & all types of Chasidim have their own.
Forcing this and calling it racism, really needs another fair look.
Not to say that when I was a kid & the kehilla was samll we wearn't made up of all types in school, but it had it's fair share of problems too.

10

 Sep 09, 2009 at 12:43 PM Anonymous Says:

I am an Ashkenazy that goes to a Sefardi Yeshiva.

11

 Sep 09, 2009 at 01:01 PM Anonymous Says:

This phenomenon was discussed in the hakdamah to the new sefer Kol Brisk.

12

 Sep 09, 2009 at 12:49 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #9  
Loshon Hora Says:

Why a white won't marry a black has nothing to do with racism. The same white won't marry another white, who doesn't share the same culture & set of mannors & customs.
Not all people nor all nations were created the same.
People should try to get on as well as possible, but why force people into situations that are unbearable?
Imagine you grew up the first 10 years of your life, in Boston in an ultra religious but Modern Orthodox affiliated home. Would you at Bar Mitzvah be able to enroll in your clothing with your background & language to Kiryas Yoel Yeshiva? Would you even dream of it? Imagine they would accept you, how long would it last ? how depressed would you be?
In my opinion calling this racism & going to court about it is unfair, could these kids really succeed in such a different enviroment, can you force this integration? what happens when the kid missbehaves, because he feels he doesn't belong?
What happens when he starts up with other kids for that very reason? & then when one mother after another sends a note asking her kid sit as far away from that kid or go to another parallel?
Is it fair to call it racism & fight it in this manner? is it fair to your own poor little kid?
Boruch Hashem the Sefardim have their own Talmud Torahs who cater to their needs, just like the so called Litaim [ Litvaks who just molded themselves that way over the last half century] & all types of Chasidim have their own.
Forcing this and calling it racism, really needs another fair look.
Not to say that when I was a kid & the kehilla was samll we wearn't made up of all types in school, but it had it's fair share of problems too.

Your comparing Blacks & Whites not intermarrying is silly if not stupid. First of all, we are Jews and should be above any ahte and racism, regardless of if it exists elsewhere. Aside from that, there is no connection, have you heard of a school or university of Non-Jews who does not accept whites or Blacks? The answer is almost never.
No one is asking you to marry them, but the world is full of different types of people, better get used to it fast. Learning in class with someone a bit different is not pushing it. Maybe put all blond kids in one class, and not "force this" as you say? Over all, all religious Jews have the same needs and wants and we should be able to work and learn together.
Your comparison to Kiryat Yoel is sillier. These Sephardic young children are the children of Avreichem, many of them, who pray at the same places, eat the same food, dress the same way and act the same way. Fact is, the few that get accepted do very well. Don't attempt to excuse this, we need a total outcry!

13

 Sep 09, 2009 at 01:35 PM Anonymous Says:

This is not a new phenomenon. Rabbi Aryeh Kaplan’s zt”l grandfather changed his name to Kaplan from Carmona after arriving in America to more easily integrate into the Ashkenazi world.

14

 Sep 09, 2009 at 01:23 PM Anonymous Says:

What is wrong with sefardic schools that makes parents so insistent upon sending their children to ashkenazi ones?

15

 Sep 09, 2009 at 12:12 PM In the name of Justice Says:

Where are all those "Kanoim" when you need them. Once they are protesting, let them protest for this Huge Chillul Hashem. This is much worse then an open parking lot on Shabbos. We are bringing up the next generation to hate other Jews. Imagine how bad it has to be for a family, that it would go out and change their legal name and all the paperwork that comes with it. God bless them for their courage, all so their kids can get a fair education.
I learned in an Israeli Yeshiva. The hate is there, there is no us edenying it. Let's save the sinking ship before it is too late. We must STOP THE FUNDING to any YESHIVA that puts a cap on any students.

16

 Sep 09, 2009 at 12:11 PM Robert Says:

Reply to #3  
Eli W Says:

Can anybody explain me, how come the Sephardim don't run their own school system and yeshiva's, since they have different minhagim and learning level?

Why are we trying to mix two cultures together, we also run, litfishe, chassidishe, sephardishe, modern orthodox, Etc. yeshivas separately, but when a chasidish bochur wants to study in a litfsh yeshiva, we don't discriminate.....

the reason is money
(i suspect you already knew that)

17

 Sep 09, 2009 at 12:07 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #3  
Eli W Says:

Can anybody explain me, how come the Sephardim don't run their own school system and yeshiva's, since they have different minhagim and learning level?

Why are we trying to mix two cultures together, we also run, litfishe, chassidishe, sephardishe, modern orthodox, Etc. yeshivas separately, but when a chasidish bochur wants to study in a litfsh yeshiva, we don't discriminate.....

Let's not lose the main issue. Even if Sepharadin should not be going to Ashkenazi schools, there is no excuse for a child to be turned away for the color of his eyes and hair. Sinat Chinam at it's best.

18

 Sep 09, 2009 at 12:06 PM Ashamed Says:

" past experience has proven that they just don’t assimilate well"
Assimilate to what? Ashkenazi Culture? And if they don't eat Gefilte fish and sing funny songs, that means they have no right to a Jewish education.?! What a senseless comment, by someone who is supposedly educating kids.

19

 Sep 09, 2009 at 01:46 PM Nathen Says:

So will the Sfardiy Mushiach have an Ashknazy name?

20

 Sep 09, 2009 at 01:45 PM Loshon Hora Says:

Reply to #12  
Anonymous Says:

Your comparing Blacks & Whites not intermarrying is silly if not stupid. First of all, we are Jews and should be above any ahte and racism, regardless of if it exists elsewhere. Aside from that, there is no connection, have you heard of a school or university of Non-Jews who does not accept whites or Blacks? The answer is almost never.
No one is asking you to marry them, but the world is full of different types of people, better get used to it fast. Learning in class with someone a bit different is not pushing it. Maybe put all blond kids in one class, and not "force this" as you say? Over all, all religious Jews have the same needs and wants and we should be able to work and learn together.
Your comparison to Kiryat Yoel is sillier. These Sephardic young children are the children of Avreichem, many of them, who pray at the same places, eat the same food, dress the same way and act the same way. Fact is, the few that get accepted do very well. Don't attempt to excuse this, we need a total outcry!

My comparisons are perfect.
I actually dormed in the Mir with Israeli Sefardi roomates, some were OK, others had such a different culture, that it was murder.
Imagine you roomate not wearing socks & not washing his feet smoking with his half religious freinds in your dorm room sitting on the fllor with a mat eating aish tanur with chumus when you are trying to sleep showing regard or remourse for you.
Why ? becase that is how he grew what he did at home, he can't understand how it could possibly disturb me, and won't even consider acomodating me, he looks at me as if I have serious problems that smoking smelly feet & eating that strong garlic stuff in that manor puke me. Is that a recipe for getting on? However between his type of sefardim that behavior is acceptable, are you going to force it on me?
In a school class with little kids, these things clash,they are living & being babysitted together the same way they do in a dorm room or bedroom. They don't specialy clash learning or davening in the same beis Hamedrash, hearing a shiur of a Gadol, or lehavdil watching basket ball in a hotel lobby or going to a lecture in a college.
If you don't see the difference you obviously never experienced it.
I remember a kid in school that no kid would sit next to, he had serious problems, & mothers didn't want their kids to suffer or get damaged, so we all got notes not letting us sit next to him, imagine how the rebbe had to deal with it.[he did have some Boy to boy problems which were knowen later in life, I guess in his case our mothers may have known and didn't want to explain it to us openly so they just made sure we stayed away.]
You can not force people & cultures together and expect people to be happy.
No way did I ever say that we are not one nation klal Yisroel, I was talking about the topic of forced relationship of different cultures which is doomed to fail.
I remember one of the Rabonim of Moroco's kids learned in the same Yeshiva as me more tyhan one of my yeshivos, I don't know where he is today, but he was a Masmid, Oived Hashem, Tzadik , Ball Midos & a real Ball Chein. I will be honest I never dormed with him, had I he may not have been a problem, being the person he was, even though alittle younger than myself I would stand up for him.
No way am I a racist I know the pain of being forced together & would never wish it on a kid, sefardi or aschkenazi.
Now you Ashkenazi try to get your kid in to a Serian School in the US.

21

 Sep 09, 2009 at 02:23 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #20  
Loshon Hora Says:

My comparisons are perfect.
I actually dormed in the Mir with Israeli Sefardi roomates, some were OK, others had such a different culture, that it was murder.
Imagine you roomate not wearing socks & not washing his feet smoking with his half religious freinds in your dorm room sitting on the fllor with a mat eating aish tanur with chumus when you are trying to sleep showing regard or remourse for you.
Why ? becase that is how he grew what he did at home, he can't understand how it could possibly disturb me, and won't even consider acomodating me, he looks at me as if I have serious problems that smoking smelly feet & eating that strong garlic stuff in that manor puke me. Is that a recipe for getting on? However between his type of sefardim that behavior is acceptable, are you going to force it on me?
In a school class with little kids, these things clash,they are living & being babysitted together the same way they do in a dorm room or bedroom. They don't specialy clash learning or davening in the same beis Hamedrash, hearing a shiur of a Gadol, or lehavdil watching basket ball in a hotel lobby or going to a lecture in a college.
If you don't see the difference you obviously never experienced it.
I remember a kid in school that no kid would sit next to, he had serious problems, & mothers didn't want their kids to suffer or get damaged, so we all got notes not letting us sit next to him, imagine how the rebbe had to deal with it.[he did have some Boy to boy problems which were knowen later in life, I guess in his case our mothers may have known and didn't want to explain it to us openly so they just made sure we stayed away.]
You can not force people & cultures together and expect people to be happy.
No way did I ever say that we are not one nation klal Yisroel, I was talking about the topic of forced relationship of different cultures which is doomed to fail.
I remember one of the Rabonim of Moroco's kids learned in the same Yeshiva as me more tyhan one of my yeshivos, I don't know where he is today, but he was a Masmid, Oived Hashem, Tzadik , Ball Midos & a real Ball Chein. I will be honest I never dormed with him, had I he may not have been a problem, being the person he was, even though alittle younger than myself I would stand up for him.
No way am I a racist I know the pain of being forced together & would never wish it on a kid, sefardi or aschkenazi.
Now you Ashkenazi try to get your kid in to a Serian School in the US.

Welcome to the real world. We cant chose who we are surrounded by! How much of a baby are you that you feel your roomate shouldnt eat something that bothered you? OK, you are jewish, and do not like a certain type of Jew, and it is ok, BUT, when 10,000 obnoxious Syrians invade my town every year and I complain I am an anti-semite?? Just another double standard, huh?

22

 Sep 09, 2009 at 02:32 PM Kaplan Mishpucha Says:

I believe that the Kaplan name is Turkish for the animal - Panther. Is this correct. Therefore, Kaplans all originated in Spain then were exiles to Turkey and eventually went north to Europe. Is this correct?

23

 Sep 09, 2009 at 02:30 PM Everyone is Different Says:

I have learned that everyone is different. I had so many roommates in Yeshiva and Eretz Yisrael that were different, it didn't matter what their background. Everyone becomes a nudnik as the zman goes on. Some of the frummest guys can become a changed person in their room. I am laughing as I remember. How these guys faired as they got married I will never know. That's why Chazal state in Gemara Sota that making a zivug is harder than kriyas yam suf !!! Therefore, it doesn't matter -- ashkenaz or sephard, everyone is different. Middos tovos are the only thing that sets one apart from another. That is why middos are so important. That is why frei divorce rates are 50%.

24

 Sep 09, 2009 at 03:03 PM Loshon Hora Says:

Reply to #21  
Anonymous Says:

Welcome to the real world. We cant chose who we are surrounded by! How much of a baby are you that you feel your roomate shouldnt eat something that bothered you? OK, you are jewish, and do not like a certain type of Jew, and it is ok, BUT, when 10,000 obnoxious Syrians invade my town every year and I complain I am an anti-semite?? Just another double standard, huh?

Come on it isn't eating the thing that bothered me, you take out one drop of ink from the bucket, be real you know what you are.

25

 Sep 09, 2009 at 02:51 PM shimon Says:

Reply to #22  
Kaplan Mishpucha Says:

I believe that the Kaplan name is Turkish for the animal - Panther. Is this correct. Therefore, Kaplans all originated in Spain then were exiles to Turkey and eventually went north to Europe. Is this correct?

Kaplan also means "a priest" in Polish and other Slavic languages. Note that many bearers of this name are kohanim.

26

 Sep 09, 2009 at 03:07 PM Anonymous Says:

In Mexico its the other way around. The Sefardim believe their way is the only way. The Ashkenazim are the minority.

27

 Sep 09, 2009 at 02:14 PM Nathen Says:

So will the Sfardiy Mushiach have an Ashknazy name?

28

 Sep 09, 2009 at 02:19 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #13  
Anonymous Says:

This is not a new phenomenon. Rabbi Aryeh Kaplan’s zt”l grandfather changed his name to Kaplan from Carmona after arriving in America to more easily integrate into the Ashkenazi world.

Hate to point this out to you, but America is NOT the Ashkenazi world!

29

 Sep 09, 2009 at 02:18 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #14  
Anonymous Says:

What is wrong with sefardic schools that makes parents so insistent upon sending their children to ashkenazi ones?

So even the Jews dont like the Syrians?? Wow!

30

 Sep 09, 2009 at 04:19 PM Anonymous Says:

Nice to see that the Rambam, Shulchan Aruch and 80% of the Rishonim wouldn't be accepted. Perhaps Ashkenazim should have quotas on how many are allowed to learn 'Sefardi Torah'

31

 Sep 09, 2009 at 03:34 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #6  
Robert Says:

not too long ago jews in the USA would change their names to WASP sounding names in order to be admitted to college or professional schools...

the more things change, the more they stay the same.

Good point. Alot of immigrants took new names at Ellis Island.

32

 Sep 09, 2009 at 03:20 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #3  
Eli W Says:

Can anybody explain me, how come the Sephardim don't run their own school system and yeshiva's, since they have different minhagim and learning level?

Why are we trying to mix two cultures together, we also run, litfishe, chassidishe, sephardishe, modern orthodox, Etc. yeshivas separately, but when a chasidish bochur wants to study in a litfsh yeshiva, we don't discriminate.....

They do have their own school system at least in EY, but nobody wants to go to a Sephardic school; everyone wants Litvishe which doesn't exist in any pure form any more. Many girls also I don't know about boys, want to marry Ashkenazi boys because the Sephardic minhagim are considered strange by many except the sephardim themselves. Although a Sephardi girl who has gone through the Bais Yakov will also learn how to Daven Ashkenazi and keep Ashkenazi minhagim, so of course her ideal will not be from her own people. All of this is ridiculous of course, and the truth is that the Chareidi school system must be responsive to the needs of the Community or else they are not educating anyone properly. Closing down and limiting by racial profile, setting quotas, barring people is just another way of saying you aren't good enough for us. This attitude is one of the most destructive and divisive problems among us today, and yet chinuch grand masters all agree for the most part that there is no other way. For Shame!

33

 Sep 09, 2009 at 02:12 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #20  
Loshon Hora Says:

My comparisons are perfect.
I actually dormed in the Mir with Israeli Sefardi roomates, some were OK, others had such a different culture, that it was murder.
Imagine you roomate not wearing socks & not washing his feet smoking with his half religious freinds in your dorm room sitting on the fllor with a mat eating aish tanur with chumus when you are trying to sleep showing regard or remourse for you.
Why ? becase that is how he grew what he did at home, he can't understand how it could possibly disturb me, and won't even consider acomodating me, he looks at me as if I have serious problems that smoking smelly feet & eating that strong garlic stuff in that manor puke me. Is that a recipe for getting on? However between his type of sefardim that behavior is acceptable, are you going to force it on me?
In a school class with little kids, these things clash,they are living & being babysitted together the same way they do in a dorm room or bedroom. They don't specialy clash learning or davening in the same beis Hamedrash, hearing a shiur of a Gadol, or lehavdil watching basket ball in a hotel lobby or going to a lecture in a college.
If you don't see the difference you obviously never experienced it.
I remember a kid in school that no kid would sit next to, he had serious problems, & mothers didn't want their kids to suffer or get damaged, so we all got notes not letting us sit next to him, imagine how the rebbe had to deal with it.[he did have some Boy to boy problems which were knowen later in life, I guess in his case our mothers may have known and didn't want to explain it to us openly so they just made sure we stayed away.]
You can not force people & cultures together and expect people to be happy.
No way did I ever say that we are not one nation klal Yisroel, I was talking about the topic of forced relationship of different cultures which is doomed to fail.
I remember one of the Rabonim of Moroco's kids learned in the same Yeshiva as me more tyhan one of my yeshivos, I don't know where he is today, but he was a Masmid, Oived Hashem, Tzadik , Ball Midos & a real Ball Chein. I will be honest I never dormed with him, had I he may not have been a problem, being the person he was, even though alittle younger than myself I would stand up for him.
No way am I a racist I know the pain of being forced together & would never wish it on a kid, sefardi or aschkenazi.
Now you Ashkenazi try to get your kid in to a Serian School in the US.

"Imagine you roomate not wearing socks & not washing his feet smoking with his half religious freinds in your dorm room sitting on the fllor with a mat eating aish tanur with chumus when you are trying to sleep showing regard or remourse for you"

What a wacky generalization, you met one freak in your life, and from then on, every Sephardi u meet is the same to you?
racism at it's best, try to deny it again.

34

 Sep 09, 2009 at 02:10 PM Just Thinking Says:

Reply to #20  
Loshon Hora Says:

My comparisons are perfect.
I actually dormed in the Mir with Israeli Sefardi roomates, some were OK, others had such a different culture, that it was murder.
Imagine you roomate not wearing socks & not washing his feet smoking with his half religious freinds in your dorm room sitting on the fllor with a mat eating aish tanur with chumus when you are trying to sleep showing regard or remourse for you.
Why ? becase that is how he grew what he did at home, he can't understand how it could possibly disturb me, and won't even consider acomodating me, he looks at me as if I have serious problems that smoking smelly feet & eating that strong garlic stuff in that manor puke me. Is that a recipe for getting on? However between his type of sefardim that behavior is acceptable, are you going to force it on me?
In a school class with little kids, these things clash,they are living & being babysitted together the same way they do in a dorm room or bedroom. They don't specialy clash learning or davening in the same beis Hamedrash, hearing a shiur of a Gadol, or lehavdil watching basket ball in a hotel lobby or going to a lecture in a college.
If you don't see the difference you obviously never experienced it.
I remember a kid in school that no kid would sit next to, he had serious problems, & mothers didn't want their kids to suffer or get damaged, so we all got notes not letting us sit next to him, imagine how the rebbe had to deal with it.[he did have some Boy to boy problems which were knowen later in life, I guess in his case our mothers may have known and didn't want to explain it to us openly so they just made sure we stayed away.]
You can not force people & cultures together and expect people to be happy.
No way did I ever say that we are not one nation klal Yisroel, I was talking about the topic of forced relationship of different cultures which is doomed to fail.
I remember one of the Rabonim of Moroco's kids learned in the same Yeshiva as me more tyhan one of my yeshivos, I don't know where he is today, but he was a Masmid, Oived Hashem, Tzadik , Ball Midos & a real Ball Chein. I will be honest I never dormed with him, had I he may not have been a problem, being the person he was, even though alittle younger than myself I would stand up for him.
No way am I a racist I know the pain of being forced together & would never wish it on a kid, sefardi or aschkenazi.
Now you Ashkenazi try to get your kid in to a Serian School in the US.

""Imagine you roomate not wearing socks & not washing his feet smoking with his half religious freinds in your dorm room sitting on the fllor with a mat eating aish tanur with chumus when you are trying to sleep showing regard or remourse for you""

What a description! Being Sephardic and livinga nd learning with Sepharadim most of my life, I have never witnessed anything resembling this. The hate between the lines is overwhelming.
We are talking here of 3rd generation Israeli Sepharadim, sons of Avreichim who themsleves learned in Ashkenazi Yeshivot, live in places like Betar and are still being turned away. Apparently you never learned in a real Israeli Yeshiva, I did, one of the "best" in the world. You might not be aware, but there is a "hate". This is a problem we must deal with, not look away fro. Even if, granted, they are so different like you so beautifully described there is no reason to HATE.

And yes, the few Ashkenazim that tried to get into Syrian schools, do get accepted. I learned in them and there were Ashkenazim in the school, MAgen David has quiet a bit as well. Of course, only rarely would an Ashkenazi try. Please get your facts before falsely accusing.

35

 Sep 09, 2009 at 04:49 PM Shlo Says:

By the way ABRAHAM ABINU was a sefardich and he is the father of all us .

36

 Sep 09, 2009 at 06:07 PM Anonymous Says:

what about syrians accepting morrocans, first fix your own wagon.

37

 Sep 09, 2009 at 06:18 PM Anonymous Says:

rabbi bitton had to close the yeshive he opened for sefardim because no sefardi wanted their child to go there, I asked a few of them why and they ALL said because he's morrocan. seems they hate each other more then any ashkenazi could.

38

 Sep 09, 2009 at 06:49 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #37  
Anonymous Says:

rabbi bitton had to close the yeshive he opened for sefardim because no sefardi wanted their child to go there, I asked a few of them why and they ALL said because he's morrocan. seems they hate each other more then any ashkenazi could.

Sir, I know Rabbi Biton personally, and the reason you stated for his school not succeeding is the furthest from the truth. I am not Moroccon but married a Moroccon. Almost all young Sephardic Jews are mixed from different nationalities.

39

 Sep 09, 2009 at 05:46 PM Anonymous Says:


Imagine today if the Ramnbam lived in Bnei Brak. He wouldn't get his children into any school.

While in yeshiva of Philadelphia in the 60s there were a few Sephardi boys. They were the nicest boys in the yeshiva.

On the flip side Ovadia Yosef's children all learned in litveshe yeshivas even though he is the biggest Sephardi nationalist.

40

 Sep 09, 2009 at 07:29 PM Toras Moshe Emess Says:

Hey, didn't Rav Ovadia Yosef just say the other day that when Moshiach comes he will institute sephardic minhagim for all yidden? I've got an idea! Since that's the case (after all, Rav Ovadia can't possibly be wrong, could he?) why don't we just go ahead and make all yeshivas sephardi?? After all, all of us ashkenazim are just following the wrong minhagim anyway, right? So why not start and get a jump on things and start teaching all of us bigotted, prejudiced, ignorant ashkenazim the right way to do things immediately!!!

Prejudice between Jews is WRONG. It should be condemned. But it not just ashkenazim, it's sephardim too and I am SICK of those that condemn the one while spewing the other.

The TRUTH is that those quotas exist NOT to keep sephardim OUT, but to ensure that sephardim are INCLUDED. The FACT is that these sephardim go to ashkenazi yeshivas because the sephardim don't build enough of their own!!! Their OWN leadership has FAILED to meet the needs of their OWN community!!! The leadership of the ashkenazi community has, FOR YEARS, bent themselves over to ensure space in their yeshivas for sephardim to make up for this and what thanks do they get? They get called ignorant bigots! I say back: "Do something constructive! Build more sephardic yeshivas instead of blaming others (who have tried to help you) for your own failings and stop spreading sinas chinam!!!"

41

 Sep 09, 2009 at 07:22 PM Anonymous Says:

Young children do not know the difference between black, tan, yellow, white, sephardi, ashkenazi, morrocan, syrian, etc. They also do not hate someone else bbecause their skin color is different or they are of a different national or ethnic background. It is adults who teach them to hate and fear differences. Students of all different backgrounds should be taught together. An important part of a child's education is to learn to respect and get along with people who are different than they are. Learning about and respecting other cultures doesn't have to mean giving up your own culture and traditions. The excuses being made for keeping people apart because of different minhagim are pathetic attempts to cover up what, at its core, is racism. It's wrong and has no place in judaism.

42

 Sep 09, 2009 at 09:11 PM a suffering syrian whose only crime was to marry a morrocan "out of the HOLY community" Says:

any syrian who marries a morrocan is shunned by the community, I know this from personal experiance, I never heard of this rabbi bitons yeshiva but I can surely believe that's why it closed. try suggesting a morrocan to a syrian for a shidduch date, its the biggest insult. the ashkenazim don't want us because they learn from us to keep away

43

 Sep 09, 2009 at 08:55 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #41  
Anonymous Says:

Young children do not know the difference between black, tan, yellow, white, sephardi, ashkenazi, morrocan, syrian, etc. They also do not hate someone else bbecause their skin color is different or they are of a different national or ethnic background. It is adults who teach them to hate and fear differences. Students of all different backgrounds should be taught together. An important part of a child's education is to learn to respect and get along with people who are different than they are. Learning about and respecting other cultures doesn't have to mean giving up your own culture and traditions. The excuses being made for keeping people apart because of different minhagim are pathetic attempts to cover up what, at its core, is racism. It's wrong and has no place in judaism.

I agree with you. Today's children are being indoctrinated to hate. This is abusive to the child and to the greater community as a whole. Why do you think the Bamboo Cradle girl had to run out of Israel? The other kids kept calling her "goy". Nebbech on them.

44

 Sep 09, 2009 at 08:53 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #39  
Anonymous Says:


Imagine today if the Ramnbam lived in Bnei Brak. He wouldn't get his children into any school.

While in yeshiva of Philadelphia in the 60s there were a few Sephardi boys. They were the nicest boys in the yeshiva.

On the flip side Ovadia Yosef's children all learned in litveshe yeshivas even though he is the biggest Sephardi nationalist.

Especially since his wife's name was Jamilah, a common Arab name. His wife wouldn't be accepted into any tehillim groups and the ladies would shun her at the bus stop. Poor Jamilah!

45

 Sep 09, 2009 at 08:14 PM Anonymous Says:

One must ask: Why are the Ashkenazi schools considered better? Do they get more funding? Are their graduates assured better jobs? If these are indeed the better schools, would they not want the best students, whether they are Sephardi or Ashkenazi? Why do the administrators automatically classify Ashkenazim as superior? There are good, honest people of all types.

46

 Sep 09, 2009 at 10:05 PM Not just that... Says:

I know of a family that changed its surname name on advice of gedolim so that they could get acceptance by a Lakewood yeshiva ktana. The father is a very choshuv ger tzedek, living the charedi lifestyle. Apparently, there are only 612 mitzvos, onaas devarim doesn't make the cut anymore.

47

 Sep 10, 2009 at 12:07 AM Lowlifes Says:

Elie W, you really need to work on your hatred towards klal israel....what a boosha, that jews even have the nerve to justify this behavior, any head of any school, i dont care how big a rabbi, or learner he is, they are missing the main point of proper chinuch. They already failed by showing their true colors, and how much hatred there is between jews. Disgusting and I say this proudly, ANYONE who thinks they can justify why you cant accept someone to school simply because of their origin, will pay a steep price, when it truly counts! Vilda Chayas Behemas, self hating racists. shame on the ashkenazie community!

48

 Sep 10, 2009 at 07:58 AM FAL Says:

We dont have to look to the non Jews to find anti semitism.....it grows undeterred right within our own 'mishpacha'. It is truly a disgrace.

49

 Sep 10, 2009 at 11:03 PM David Kirschner Says:

My two boys attend a yeshiva and a camp that adheres to ashkenazi minhagim, e.g., nusach, selichos, etc.., which has all types of boys, Sephardim, Ashkenazim, Bucharians, Moroccans, chasidim. Their friends wear kippah sruga, leather, suade, velvet Sephardi caps. There are boys with long payos, no payos and some payos, hats, no hats - you get my point.

Ironic, but somehow, I don't believe any of those bochurim would find any need or desire to make many of the comments posted here. To them, they're all yidden. Of course, they do seem to distinguish each other; according to athletics!

Perhaps on their zechus we will merit th coming of moshiach tzidkeinu, bimheirah, v'yomeinu!!!

50

 Sep 11, 2009 at 01:32 PM NW YID Says:

Reply to #3  
Eli W Says:

Can anybody explain me, how come the Sephardim don't run their own school system and yeshiva's, since they have different minhagim and learning level?

Why are we trying to mix two cultures together, we also run, litfishe, chassidishe, sephardishe, modern orthodox, Etc. yeshivas separately, but when a chasidish bochur wants to study in a litfsh yeshiva, we don't discriminate.....

Ttwo cultures?... who are you kidding, there is only one people. All Minhagim will dissipate by the wayside when we return to Am Israel Ehad. May Hashem bless us this Rosh Hashana by sending us Mashiach Tzidkenu. Sepharadim do have many of there own schools, such as the prominent Syrian community in Jersey and NW. Most elite Kabbalistic Yeshivot in Israel such as Bet El, are Sephardic...... These labels and customs we picked up in Galut are no way to define teh eternal Jewish people. Do you think EL KADOSH BARUCH HU distinguishes between who speaks Yiddish, Ladino, Arabic.... NO. All of us have Brit Milot, we are all sons of Abraham Avinu. Any Jew who does not view all Jews as our Brethren is seriously missing the point. A G-d fearing Yeshiva is for all Jews, regardless of Galut "extraction"

51

Sign-in to post a comment

Scroll Up
Advertisements:

Sell your scrap gold and broken jewelry and earn hard cash sell gold today!