Welcome, Guest! - or
Easy to remember!  »  VinNews.com

Israel - Maariv's Expose of Rabbi Yitzchak Goldknopf, the Powerful Boycott-Maker and Breaker

Published on:   March 7, 2010 03:34 PM
News Source: VIN News Ezra Reichman Maariv
Change text size Text Size  
Bookmark and Share
Rabbi Yitzchak GoldknopfRabbi Yitzchak Goldknopf

Israel - Maariv published  an expose of Rabbi Yitzchak Goldknopf, a pivotal Gerrer askan who stands at the head of the Igud HaTatim, the Bais Yaakov Kindergarten network, and the Committee to Observe Shabbos.

Not only does Goldknopf, 60 and the father of 10, concentrate immense political power in his hand, but he does so in an aggressive manner that intimidates potential opponents and rivals from chassidic rebbes to businessman. As if that wasn’t enough, he also has key control of the chassidic Hamodia daily, the main information channel for a large part of the chareidi community.

Goldknopf almost singlehandedly crushed the Shefa Shuk mehadrin supermarket chain belonging to the secular Ribua Kachol conglomerate owned by David Weissman. The financial sanctions he implemented speedily brought El Al to agree not to travel on Shabbos.

Advertisement:

As the economic power of the chareidi community has grown, the more power has accrued to the head of the Committee for Shabbos.

“The chareidi public has gray areas which are run by various power bases. Whoever dares to harm them is endangering his status and in certain cases, even his life. Goldknopf and the group that surrounds him are one such power base,” explains a person who has followed Goldknopf’s waxing power in recent years.

Another person who is acquainted with Goldknopf describes him this way: “He a strong man, intelligent, completely discreet, and runs his affairs zealously. He knows the intimate workings of all the different chareidi publics and sits on critical intersections which connect contributions to rabbinical courts.”

Goldknopf sits in his office on Belilius street until the late evening, running his numerous affairs which include real estate and phone companies. His greatest power lays, however, in the public organizations he runs. He is the general director of Petachya, a special education organization; a general director of Igud Hatatim; and a committee member of the Hisachdus Hatatim. These organizations get numerous funds from the government, and Goldknopf is the one who decides how to divvy them.

Slicing the Earnings of Impoverished Kindergarten Teachers

The organization which gives him the greatest power base is the Bais Yaakov kindergarten network which thousands of chareidi children attend. A State Comptroller study carried out in 2008 on the kindergarten network reported that 20% of the kindergarten teachers received only 82-85% of their proper salary, while 38% received only 86-90% of their required salary. Some kindergarten teachers only earned 75% of their legal wages.

How did he pull this off? In the summer months, the network didn’t pay some of the kindergarten teachers and aides in July and none of them received wages in August. Numerous teachers were sent to request unemployment from the government. “The state paid the network twice,” the report says.

“These are women who are working to provide for 7-8 children,” says a furious relative of a kindergarten teacher employed in Goldknopf’s network. “While municipal kindergarten teachers made 4,500 NIS a month, Goldknopf’s made 3,200. He divides the money according to his personal interests - some employees get more, some get less. His attitude is, “I’ll do what’s best for me and to hell with everyone else.”

A Gerrer chosid confirmed, “He employs women who are close to leading members of our community, and doesn’t slice off their wages as he does for others.”

At least 13 members of Goldknopf’s own family have found his organizations an unfailing source of jobs. His 85-year old mother is employed in the Bais Yaakov network in an administrative position, his wife is employed in Petachya, his 4 daughters serve as kindergarten teachers and administrators, his two sisters are also working in Bais Yaakov, as is his daughter-in-law, sister-in-law and nephew’s wife. Another daughter-in-law works in Petachya. “Thirteen family members working in an organization is not proper administration,” the State Comptroller’s Report notes wryly.

Since becoming the head of these organizations in the 1980’s, Goldknopf has attained a pyramid of power among Gerrer chassidim. A close friend says, “He travels abroad a lot, disappears from the office for several days and always travels in first class.”

His Selective Battles Against Shabbos Desecration

The battle of the chareidim against chillul Shabbos took a new turn 4 years ago, when various rabbonim decided that a committee had to be set up to coordinate between the public’s leading rabbonim. The various streams sent their representatives, but from the beginning, the organization was usurped by Goldknopf who turned it into another power base.

“We discovered very quickly that they had taken over the committee and used it as a ‘kardum lachfor boh’,” says a former member of the committee. “They inserted all kinds of people with personal interests and took it to completely different directions, with Goldknopf pulling the strings. This position gives power and money to one who knows how to manipulate. The ways it’s run today, it destroys businesses and doesn’t even promote Shabbos observance.”

A person who worked with him in the past, avers, “Everything is kosher in his eyes and whatever he asks of you, better be done. He doesn’t threaten with words, but he has his people and it’s enough he looks at you.. He’s dangerous. I know a person who couldn’t step foot in his own shul because of him.”

Goldknopf’s first publicized boycott took place in December 2006, and within a month both sides reached a compromise which was hidden from the public. “The fight over El Al flights on Shabbos stunk. Not only didn’t he reveal the compromise he reached with them, but the fact is that the company continues to fly on Shabbos,” says someone close to the committee. Chillul Shabbos continues to be massively carried out by El Al’s subsidiary Sun-dor. Recently, El Al required its workers to carry phony Sun-dor employment papers when they travel on Shabbos, in addition to their regular El Al employment documents which they carry during the week.

“The Committee for Shabbos controls today the two largest media in the chareidi public—Hamodia and Yated Neeman. Whatever they don’t write, the chareidi public doesn’t know. They’re a real mafia,” says the above source.

Despite Goldknopf’s immense power, voices have been raised in the past year against the selective way he chooses who to boycott for chillul Shabbos. Rabbonim have privately expressed their disagreement to his bombastic campaigns that feature prolific street posters, raucous articles in the newspapers and swift consumer boycotts against certain targets, but fear to openly oppose him.

Goldknopf ran an uncompromising struggle against the Shefa Shuk mehadrin supermarkets owned by Dudi Weissman, whose Tel Aviv AM:PM network are open on Shabbos. The success of the struggle can be seen by the fact that half of its 47 flourishing supermarkets were forced to close down.

For inexplicable reasons, however, many other businessmen are not in Goldknopf’s sights. One obvious sample is Nochi Dankner and his chareidi businessman partner Shulam Fischer, who own a supermarket mehadrin network under the Supersol Group, many of whose businesses are mechalel Shabbos. Neither of them have yet felt Goldknopf’s imperious assault. Among the Shabbos desecrating companies run by these two are the Cellcom cellphone company, Natur transportation company, Golf and Kav, Chadera paper and Chugla-Kimberly disposable diapers.

Fischer is a partner of Matthew Bronfman from the Iris Hagilboa Group, who owns Israel IKEA. The Group purchased last December 9.5% of the shares of British Israel, owned by the British religious billionaire Louis Noe, who owns 18% of all the shopping malls around the country. Some are open on Shabbos, such as Chonim-Konim in Rishon Letzion, Dodge shopping mall in Upper Natzeret, Queen of Sheba shopping mall in Eilat, and Bilu Center at the BILU intersection.

Goldknopf’s Targets Respond to the Hypocrisy

Could the reason be because Fischer and Dankner are close to the chareidi public? Dankner is a close donor to Rabbi Yaakov Yisroel Iferghan (the “Xray”) of Netivot, and he also “adopted” Hatzolah Israel to which he contributes millions of shekels.

“Fischer donates lavishly to Gerrer and Belz chassidic organizations, and this is just a fraction of what he gives,” says a man close to Fischer’s charity enterprises. “He gives hundreds of thousands of shekels every month by bank order. Whenever they need a building, mikvah or shul, they go to him. Every holiday, he gives coupons worth 1.5-2 million shekels out to friends and family. He’s very connected to the Gerrer chassidim.”

The fact that Goldknopf is blind to Dankner and Fischer’s Shabbos desecrating businesses rankled on their rivals in the chareidi sector, and a month ago, the streets filled with posters featuring Fischer and Dankner’s pictures and warning the public, “Look who is responsible for the greatest chillul Shabbos in the Holy Land.” Under their pictures was a list of their holdings in companies that desecrate Shabbos. The poster was signed “National Committee to Uphold Shabbos.”

“Some people are fed up with the hypocrisy. The story with Shefa Shuk was sordid. Why did they go against Shefa Shuk but not the others? This was a far-reaching phenomenon but they chose to boycott only one and turned a blind eye to the other,” said one man formerly involved in the struggle to observe Shabbos.

Goldknopf’s Response

Goldknopf refused to address any of the claims made against him and instead issued this response, “I see no reason to respond to things unrelated to me. I don’t know where you extracted all this from. The Rabbinical Committee for Shabbos has done and will continue to do its work faithfully, and there is no need to attribute anything improper to it.”


More of today's headlines

Tel Aviv, Israel - A seven-year-old boy sustained moderate to serious wounds when he was attacked by a dog in a south Tel Aviv park on Sunday. The boy was evacuated to... New York, NY - A former city buildings inspector was busted for selling fake safety training certificates required to work on high-rises. The arrest of Michael...

 

Total69

Read Comments (69)  —  Post Yours »

1

 Mar 07, 2010 at 02:43 PM Anonymous Says:

Actually the kindergarden issue is one major souce of tension between degel hatorah and ger .

2

 Mar 07, 2010 at 02:54 PM yosse nathan Says:

that is what this is , one big jewish mafia and that is why all the frum people can't work together in israel.
its all about the money.

3

 Mar 07, 2010 at 02:58 PM Anonymous Says:

He sounds like a mobster in a beard who fights to control the money of the underground world or else he will lose it all.

4

 Mar 07, 2010 at 03:02 PM Anonymous Says:

ger takes care of their own, good for them.

5

 Mar 07, 2010 at 03:02 PM Anonymous Says:

Threatened with their life??? puleez

6

 Mar 07, 2010 at 03:16 PM Anonymous Says:

Thank you VIN for highlighting this problem. The more I hear the less I give to tzedakas in Israel, of course my paltry few thousand a year is nothing to them but I would imagine that there are many others who feel the same way I do, the smell of corruption stinks across the oceans to these shores. 'Leaders' such as this Goldknopf line their pockets with donations and steal from the people they are supposed to be helping. They've already stolen an education from the masses as well as the ability to create any sort of financial independence, eventually the chareidim in Israel will be worse than the most ignorant savages in third-world countries. All because of the lust for power and greed by their leaders. I spit on Goldknopf and his ilk.

7

 Mar 07, 2010 at 03:16 PM Anonymous Says:

""Why he doesn't go after Fischer who desecrates Shabbos?"" Stupid question. The answer is that Fisher is a brilliant business man who has figured out how the orthodox world operates. You feed their leadership with enough bribes aka chesed money/tzidoka and they will leave you alone. As soon as Fischer won't be able to feed the non working Charedi communities with pet project donations, this "Rabbi" Goldknopf will organize a riot and boycott of Fisher business as well.

8

 Mar 07, 2010 at 03:21 PM Anonymous Says:

Power is the money, money is the power, minute after minute hour after hour........

9

 Mar 07, 2010 at 03:24 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #1  
Anonymous Says:

Actually the kindergarden issue is one major souce of tension between degel hatorah and ger .

Degel just control recently of the ganim system,putting r' yitzchak rice the former mayor of rechasim in charge.

10

 Mar 07, 2010 at 03:30 PM Anonymous Says:

The raid was that the gurys shorted elal before they attackes them then longed the stock before they came out with an agreement
And dudi wisman is an aleksander chusid

11

 Mar 07, 2010 at 03:43 PM lost generation Says:

Forget the money-An entire generation lost an education that would make them financialy viable young men/woman because of leaders that chose to NOT teach us a trade.

I resent you and your "poverty pimp" friends.

12

 Mar 07, 2010 at 03:44 PM Anonymous Says:

Stealing from Bais Yaakov teachers has got to be a new all-time low. The additional benefit of this article is in graphically demonstrating how Socialism destroys a society piece by piece, because one monolithic, monopolistic, all-powerful source controlling the disbursement of every penny effectively kills quality, perseverence, innovation, achievement and self-actualization. Why bother? Life becomes demoralizing and excelling at anything is an exercise in futility. The new form of Socialism is stealing from the Middle Class and giving to the Rich and Ezra Reichman demonstrates this in chilling detail. This would be a great opportunity for those B.Y. teachers to pool their resources and open their own school that competes with the establishment. Nothing like a good competition to break the power of monopolies.

13

 Mar 07, 2010 at 03:45 PM Charlie Hall Says:

It is a chiyuv of the Torah to pay workers their wages on time! How can someone responsible for stiffing employees be considered Orthodox?

14

 Mar 07, 2010 at 04:27 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #13  
Charlie Hall Says:

It is a chiyuv of the Torah to pay workers their wages on time! How can someone responsible for stiffing employees be considered Orthodox?

Because, according to one source, "Everything is kosher in his eyes....", He decides what is kosher and he decides how much to pay and how much to pocket, it's all kosher because it emanated from him. Who is Charlie Hall to question his authority? Get the picture?

15

 Mar 07, 2010 at 04:30 PM BL21 Says:

For those who believe that this article is an unbiased investigative piece, you need a reality check. These people and groups, on both sides, are entrenched in a deep BUSINESS battle with many millions on the line.

To me what is so telling is the absolute lack of an validation to claims, or names of people who stand behind any accusations. These people may depend on aggressive business tactic that may border on illegal, however the articles clear intent is to demonize Goldknopf. WHY NOT INCLUDE THE FACTS, OR PERHAPS THEY DONT WANT TO?

16

 Mar 07, 2010 at 04:43 PM sruli Says:

ger is trying to rule judisim, its a wake up call, get them out before they will control every part of our life!

17

 Mar 07, 2010 at 04:56 PM Dave Says:

My sandek (godfather)

18

 Mar 07, 2010 at 05:15 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #6  
Anonymous Says:

Thank you VIN for highlighting this problem. The more I hear the less I give to tzedakas in Israel, of course my paltry few thousand a year is nothing to them but I would imagine that there are many others who feel the same way I do, the smell of corruption stinks across the oceans to these shores. 'Leaders' such as this Goldknopf line their pockets with donations and steal from the people they are supposed to be helping. They've already stolen an education from the masses as well as the ability to create any sort of financial independence, eventually the chareidim in Israel will be worse than the most ignorant savages in third-world countries. All because of the lust for power and greed by their leaders. I spit on Goldknopf and his ilk.

Your hatred of Frum Jews is almost as great as that of the Germans.

19

 Mar 07, 2010 at 05:15 PM Charlie Hall Says:

Reply to #12  
Anonymous Says:

Stealing from Bais Yaakov teachers has got to be a new all-time low. The additional benefit of this article is in graphically demonstrating how Socialism destroys a society piece by piece, because one monolithic, monopolistic, all-powerful source controlling the disbursement of every penny effectively kills quality, perseverence, innovation, achievement and self-actualization. Why bother? Life becomes demoralizing and excelling at anything is an exercise in futility. The new form of Socialism is stealing from the Middle Class and giving to the Rich and Ezra Reichman demonstrates this in chilling detail. This would be a great opportunity for those B.Y. teachers to pool their resources and open their own school that competes with the establishment. Nothing like a good competition to break the power of monopolies.

B.Y. teachers could pool their resources to start their own school, but they'd have to charge real tuition rather than the nominal fees that most parents pay in Israel for Jewish education thanks to....Socialism! I presume you'd like to eliminate government support for Jewish schools there?

20

 Mar 07, 2010 at 05:26 PM Charaidi Says:

A frumeh madoff, what's new? noch a ganev.

21

 Mar 07, 2010 at 05:56 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #18  
Anonymous Says:

Your hatred of Frum Jews is almost as great as that of the Germans.

Why don't you direct your wrath at the source of the problem rather than the symptoms of the problem? This gentleman is venting his frustration, he is not stealing from anybody or short-changing salaries or putting people out of business!

22

 Mar 07, 2010 at 05:58 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #19  
Charlie Hall Says:

B.Y. teachers could pool their resources to start their own school, but they'd have to charge real tuition rather than the nominal fees that most parents pay in Israel for Jewish education thanks to....Socialism! I presume you'd like to eliminate government support for Jewish schools there?

As a Conservative, I am for smaller govt.; I am for cutting taxes; I am for more freedom and less government intervention and I am for the total elimination of government subsidies. I despise Socialism in whatever form it takes.

23

 Mar 07, 2010 at 06:00 PM Simcha Says:

This man is a goon. Why are you highlighting his sick antics that only encourage machlokes and blackmail. People like this need to be ignored and margionalized.

24

 Mar 07, 2010 at 06:05 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #15  
BL21 Says:

For those who believe that this article is an unbiased investigative piece, you need a reality check. These people and groups, on both sides, are entrenched in a deep BUSINESS battle with many millions on the line.

To me what is so telling is the absolute lack of an validation to claims, or names of people who stand behind any accusations. These people may depend on aggressive business tactic that may border on illegal, however the articles clear intent is to demonize Goldknopf. WHY NOT INCLUDE THE FACTS, OR PERHAPS THEY DONT WANT TO?

What you are saying is nonsense and stupidity. Journalists are allowed to keep their sources secret. Have you never heard of "Deepthroat"? He was the famous secret informant who provided info to the Washington Post that brought down the Nixon Administration.
There are several reasons to protect confidential sources:
a) In some cases serious harm might befall the source if their identity is uncovered.
b) The willingness of other potential sources to share information with reporters may be eroded if confidential sources are identified.
c) The public perception of journalistic integrity is damaged when assurances about confidentiality are breached.
d) The so-called "chilling effect," which serves to dissuade sources in the future from stepping forward with unknown information for fear of reprimand or retaliation.

25

 Mar 07, 2010 at 06:13 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #15  
BL21 Says:

For those who believe that this article is an unbiased investigative piece, you need a reality check. These people and groups, on both sides, are entrenched in a deep BUSINESS battle with many millions on the line.

To me what is so telling is the absolute lack of an validation to claims, or names of people who stand behind any accusations. These people may depend on aggressive business tactic that may border on illegal, however the articles clear intent is to demonize Goldknopf. WHY NOT INCLUDE THE FACTS, OR PERHAPS THEY DONT WANT TO?

Maariv's editors would not have gone to press without absolutely verifying the credibility of the sources and the information. Maariv is a leading tabloid in Israel and has a reputation to protect for not publishing outright lies. According to the CIA, Maariv has been reflecting the national consensus and providing Israelis with the latest news and opinions from this perspective for over fifty years. Sunday through Friday, the paper carries full coverage of politics in Israel. Exactly what facts are you lacking? The names of his sources so you can attack them? Goldknopt was given the chance to negate the accusations; he didn't care enough to utter a single comment.

26

 Mar 07, 2010 at 06:14 PM Anonymous Says:

All I can say after reading this above article, that if all these allegations are true, this is a chilul HaShem of gigantic proportions. This man behaves like a mafia godfather. Cannot understand why he is not investigated by the authorities and also why rabbanim are so afraid of him. Does he engage in violence? This is an oxymoron for someone espousing the holiness of Shabbat and acting in this fashion. Don't know if this is true, but woe unto us as religious Jews that there is such behavior amongst us. Now this makes it easy to understand what it means when it says that 'erev rav' will have infiltrated within the rabbinic world also - wherever there is power, they will fill those power bases, in the time before redemption. Hopefully, the above is unfounded, but from what we read here, doesn't look good. The world has reverted to chaos.

27

 Mar 07, 2010 at 06:19 PM Anonymous Says:

Such "yidden"are a disgrace to klal yisrael these woman are not making ends meat cause this bearded animal has plans for they're money. If he's worried about burning in hell for shefa shuk being open on shabbos he roasting in hell for starving yidishe kids.

28

 Mar 07, 2010 at 06:25 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #23  
Simcha Says:

This man is a goon. Why are you highlighting his sick antics that only encourage machlokes and blackmail. People like this need to be ignored and margionalized.

You can't ignore the guy that holds the purse strings.

29

 Mar 07, 2010 at 06:28 PM Anonymous Says:

Wow, it seems the biggest burglary here is the stealing the wages of the teachers, unbelievable.

30

 Mar 07, 2010 at 06:35 PM Green Tea Says:

Jewish Charlie Rangel.

Think about it....he delivers votes in a block in exchange for the power to dole out govt funds.
Classic poverty pimp.

31

 Mar 07, 2010 at 06:46 PM Tzavua Says:

Unfortunately his so called boycott of El Al for wanting to fly on Shabbos was quite hypocritical. The alternative at the time was Israir who was flying and still flies every Shabbos from Tel Aviv to Eilat and back. nobody ever boycotted them or demonstrated against them.

Arkia flies every Shabbos. Why no boycott/demonstration?

Also at the same time Egged was and is being mechallel Shabbos eevery Shabbos and nobody boycotts them. Maybe no one would be able to come to certain tishes and grandiose weddings without them.

Why are we so selective with our Shabbos boycotts and demostrations? If chillul Shaboos is wrong and warrants a boycott or demonstration then all chillul Shabbos should be boycotted/demonstrated against.

32

 Mar 07, 2010 at 06:46 PM WB Says:

Reply to #6  
Anonymous Says:

Thank you VIN for highlighting this problem. The more I hear the less I give to tzedakas in Israel, of course my paltry few thousand a year is nothing to them but I would imagine that there are many others who feel the same way I do, the smell of corruption stinks across the oceans to these shores. 'Leaders' such as this Goldknopf line their pockets with donations and steal from the people they are supposed to be helping. They've already stolen an education from the masses as well as the ability to create any sort of financial independence, eventually the chareidim in Israel will be worse than the most ignorant savages in third-world countries. All because of the lust for power and greed by their leaders. I spit on Goldknopf and his ilk.

I can read from ur lines: that u only give tzedakah 2 the yankee stadium,
So who really cares about ur opinion of chasidim?

33

 Mar 07, 2010 at 06:50 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #13  
Charlie Hall Says:

It is a chiyuv of the Torah to pay workers their wages on time! How can someone responsible for stiffing employees be considered Orthodox?

This is EXACTLY what I was thinking. Why is it OK for him to be oiver on one mitzvah mid'oraisah and not OK for others to be oiver on another mitzvah mid'oraisah? Stealing from women teachers makes him a gonif!!!

34

 Mar 07, 2010 at 06:55 PM SD Says:

Reply to #27  
Anonymous Says:

Such "yidden"are a disgrace to klal yisrael these woman are not making ends meat cause this bearded animal has plans for they're money. If he's worried about burning in hell for shefa shuk being open on shabbos he roasting in hell for starving yidishe kids.

. . . and when it comes to himself, he always travels first-class.

35

 Mar 07, 2010 at 06:56 PM Stamford Hilly Billy Says:

Everyone reading this needs to take it into perspective and realise this is only one side of the story.

That being said Goldknopf was given a chance to give his take on the allegations and didn`t exactly give a wholesome answer. Generally I believe that there is no smoke without fire and at least some of these allegations must be true at some level for Mariv to have published this article, I like to give the benefit of the doubt and say they wouldn`t have printed something that is totally fictious, although there may be some exggeration to fulfil an agenda, only hashem knows the whole truth.

I must also say that has a ba`al tashuva one reason that I do call myself and identify myself with charedim is because it seems that there is far too much of this sort of thing going on in the charedi world, and if this is authentic torah judaism(whatever that is) then no thank you. It seems to be the culpruits are people like this guy who are just below the rabbonim in the power hireachy and like to influence the rabbonim in ways that will provide and protect themselves with money and power. These people are disgusting mafia type figures who will get their din in shamiyim

36

 Mar 07, 2010 at 06:58 PM SD Says:

Reply to #27  
Anonymous Says:

Such "yidden"are a disgrace to klal yisrael these woman are not making ends meat cause this bearded animal has plans for they're money. If he's worried about burning in hell for shefa shuk being open on shabbos he roasting in hell for starving yidishe kids.

What does it say about the Ger leadership that they seem to be OK with a person like this having so much power and using it in such a cruel, devious, non-Torahdik fashion?

Why aren't they as disgusted as the decent readers of VIN?

37

 Mar 07, 2010 at 07:03 PM #6 Says:

Reply to #18  
Anonymous Says:

Your hatred of Frum Jews is almost as great as that of the Germans.

MY hatred of frum jews? That's laughable. It's not me who oppresses these poor yidden, not me who makes sure they'll never have a chance to better themselves. You, anonymous #18 must be one of these machers that pocket tzedaka money and then convince yourself you're not doing anything wrong. You're like the kapos in the camps that beat other yidden so they could have a little bit more bread than anyone else.

38

 Mar 07, 2010 at 08:28 PM Anonymous Says:

As someone that lives in Israel for 3 years
1) this is what the entire ger chasidus is build upon control control
from the rebbe down to the bochurem who went out against porush by the votes last year
2) about shabbos it's pure buissnes to him look at egged, ger gets the service and they don't care if anyone else does

39

 Mar 07, 2010 at 08:53 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #3  
Anonymous Says:

He sounds like a mobster in a beard who fights to control the money of the underground world or else he will lose it all.

This is what happens if you WORK!
All those commentators sitting on your swivel chair and reading VIN enjoy when u read a hateful piece like this. But keep in mind that this article wouldn't make sense on yourself for one reason... Because you're not busy to help. This is the price that a ASKEN pays for his work to the public

40

 Mar 07, 2010 at 09:31 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #34  
SD Says:

. . . and when it comes to himself, he always travels first-class.

He's a big boy he can't fit into a coach seat.

41

 Mar 07, 2010 at 10:10 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #39  
Anonymous Says:

This is what happens if you WORK!
All those commentators sitting on your swivel chair and reading VIN enjoy when u read a hateful piece like this. But keep in mind that this article wouldn't make sense on yourself for one reason... Because you're not busy to help. This is the price that a ASKEN pays for his work to the public

We need LESS ASKENS and MORE BOCHURS WHO WORK!

42

 Mar 07, 2010 at 10:47 PM bunch of gullible losers Says:

You people. besides for being Mekabel this Trash to be true- you are a bunch of gullible losers who would buy the brooklyn Bridge plus the Triboro if given a 2 for one deal.
Immature gullible grownups. You people are scary. OOOOOOOO- They wrote it so for sure it's true-oooooooooooo-they have No agenda what so ever -oooooo- He didn't choose to deny the allegations so it must be true--ooooooo!!!!!
CHILDREN!

43

 Mar 07, 2010 at 10:58 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #32  
WB Says:

I can read from ur lines: that u only give tzedakah 2 the yankee stadium,
So who really cares about ur opinion of chasidim?

And who cares about your opinion of other posters? Keep your nastiness to yourself, you obviously don't have something nice to say about someone so keep quiet.

44

 Mar 07, 2010 at 11:08 PM #18 Says:

Reply to #37  
#6 Says:

MY hatred of frum jews? That's laughable. It's not me who oppresses these poor yidden, not me who makes sure they'll never have a chance to better themselves. You, anonymous #18 must be one of these machers that pocket tzedaka money and then convince yourself you're not doing anything wrong. You're like the kapos in the camps that beat other yidden so they could have a little bit more bread than anyone else.

I hit the nail right on its head, not only do you hate frum yidden like the Germans did but the way you reply tells me that you are a bitter and lonely person who was abandoned by his wife and children.

45

 Mar 07, 2010 at 11:34 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #42  
bunch of gullible losers Says:

You people. besides for being Mekabel this Trash to be true- you are a bunch of gullible losers who would buy the brooklyn Bridge plus the Triboro if given a 2 for one deal.
Immature gullible grownups. You people are scary. OOOOOOOO- They wrote it so for sure it's true-oooooooooooo-they have No agenda what so ever -oooooo- He didn't choose to deny the allegations so it must be true--ooooooo!!!!!
CHILDREN!

What's up with the zeros?

46

 Mar 07, 2010 at 11:38 PM Moshe Says:

I worked for Yizchok many years. He is a nice honest man and treats his employees with the utmost respect. He is extremely intelligent and successful and that is why so many people envy him. He is and has been fully devoted to the Chareidi public for over three decades and has never taken nor received gratuities in return for his many services. No wonder the secular people and media hate him. They have nobody of his caliber and quality in their midst.

47

 Mar 08, 2010 at 12:09 AM Anonymous Says:

After this article & comments watch this Golbknopf put a boycott on VIN just like he did to Chadrei Chareidim whenever he doesn't like something he uses his bully acts to deal with it

48

 Mar 08, 2010 at 12:40 AM SD Says:

Reply to #46  
Moshe Says:

I worked for Yizchok many years. He is a nice honest man and treats his employees with the utmost respect. He is extremely intelligent and successful and that is why so many people envy him. He is and has been fully devoted to the Chareidi public for over three decades and has never taken nor received gratuities in return for his many services. No wonder the secular people and media hate him. They have nobody of his caliber and quality in their midst.

To Moshe #47:
So, you're saying that the statistics about cheating kindergarten teachers out of their wages are untrue?

Or, are you saying that they might be true, but it's no stirah to his being (in your eyes) a "nice, honest man"?

49

 Mar 08, 2010 at 12:43 AM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #46  
Moshe Says:

I worked for Yizchok many years. He is a nice honest man and treats his employees with the utmost respect. He is extremely intelligent and successful and that is why so many people envy him. He is and has been fully devoted to the Chareidi public for over three decades and has never taken nor received gratuities in return for his many services. No wonder the secular people and media hate him. They have nobody of his caliber and quality in their midst.

Finally someone knows him on a first name basis! Wow, how manu of his employees were not gerers, why are we attacking goldknopf, he is just a shliach of his rebbe (maybe that's what the article was meant to be but the mariv was afraid they can be dangerous) and since they are the largest chasidus this is the way its gonna be, and very possible we in israel should thank hashem that its them and not some other group, for it would be a lot worse, wow he goes first class what a dumb line anybody who flies a couple of times a year with ELAL knows they got a great matmid program, and who else should he give the jobs to if not to his 85 yearold mamash kibud aim
Oy we are living in hard economic times and it brings out the best of people and I'm wondering about the people who were.the sources for this article what do they do for klal yisrarl in an ehrliche fashion and also all "askanim" or at least the good ones menachim purish munya shapiro shlomo lawrence and the belzer askanim and the zanzer one and the viznitz one ect....... All are and have made good money somehow just maybe the gerer goons do it better and a more grober in your face we don't give a dam type of way.

50

 Mar 08, 2010 at 02:16 AM Michael in Seattle Says:

As a Halachah, Ashkenazim are so preoccupied with making money (even on Shabbat) - to the point that it affects their emotional well being. See Sh"A 128:44, Rema

51

 Mar 08, 2010 at 07:36 AM wiseman Says:

Reply to #32  
WB Says:

I can read from ur lines: that u only give tzedakah 2 the yankee stadium,
So who really cares about ur opinion of chasidim?

if half the stuff in the story is true then perhaps giving "tzedakah to Yankee stadium is probably a better thing.

52

 Mar 08, 2010 at 07:38 AM Wiseman Says:

Reply to #34  
SD Says:

. . . and when it comes to himself, he always travels first-class.

First class. i should go into his line of work. I can only afford to travel Business class.

53

 Mar 08, 2010 at 07:41 AM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #43  
Anonymous Says:

And who cares about your opinion of other posters? Keep your nastiness to yourself, you obviously don't have something nice to say about someone so keep quiet.

Sorry #43 but I agree that a guy like this should be publicly thrown out of shul. Just because a guy wears a beard and payos doesn't make him frum.

54

 Mar 08, 2010 at 07:41 AM Nosson Halevi Says:

The tragedy of this story, which remember was originated by the vitriolicly anti-Torah Maariv, is the terrible Chillul Hashem it generates.
All this stems from a support of power hungry leaders. By definition, a Torah leader is not power hungry. Moshe Rabeinu argued for 7 days with the Ribono Shel Olom, not to be selected as the leader.
Our leaders are leaders of the spirit. DRocheho Darchei NOam. Bullying, power groups, violent hafgonos, these are all tools of Esov.
Rebbes who fight to be the next rebbe, Rosh Yeshivas who are interested in the real estate value of the Yeshivah more than the students, Mechanchim who are there only because they don't know how else to put bread on the table. These are all examples of using the Torah as a spade.

55

 Mar 08, 2010 at 08:39 AM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #51  
wiseman Says:

if half the stuff in the story is true then perhaps giving "tzedakah to Yankee stadium is probably a better thing.

If half the story is true, that means that half the story is not true.
Maariv is not exactly the most reliable source of Chareidi news. (You can say that again and again!)

56

 Mar 08, 2010 at 08:47 AM Another Stamford Hiller Says:

Reply to #35  
Stamford Hilly Billy Says:

Everyone reading this needs to take it into perspective and realise this is only one side of the story.

That being said Goldknopf was given a chance to give his take on the allegations and didn`t exactly give a wholesome answer. Generally I believe that there is no smoke without fire and at least some of these allegations must be true at some level for Mariv to have published this article, I like to give the benefit of the doubt and say they wouldn`t have printed something that is totally fictious, although there may be some exggeration to fulfil an agenda, only hashem knows the whole truth.

I must also say that has a ba`al tashuva one reason that I do call myself and identify myself with charedim is because it seems that there is far too much of this sort of thing going on in the charedi world, and if this is authentic torah judaism(whatever that is) then no thank you. It seems to be the culpruits are people like this guy who are just below the rabbonim in the power hireachy and like to influence the rabbonim in ways that will provide and protect themselves with money and power. These people are disgusting mafia type figures who will get their din in shamiyim

No smoke without fire?
I assume you accept that there must be some truth in the allegation that jews make matzos out of the blood of christian children. After all, the story has the backing of hundreds of learned galochim and the overwhelming majority of trials for this offence in medieval Europe resulted in convictions and subsequent execution.
Do you STILL believe "no smoke without fire"?

57

 Mar 08, 2010 at 09:11 AM Anonymous Says:

It was ger that brought down Porush as the frum mayoral candidate, which resulted in all the chillul Shabbos in Jerusalem. That entire chassidus is known for itshysical violence and power brokering, true Yiras Shomayim! Gerrer Rebbe be proud.

58

 Mar 08, 2010 at 10:03 AM Joe Says:

Another reason for not making Aliyah

59

 Mar 08, 2010 at 10:59 AM Anonymous Says:

The El Al boycott he led was great for me and my family - our pilot trip to Israel was scheduled at that time, and we got a great deal on our El Al tickets. And there were plenty of chareidim on that flight as well. I guess when it comes to money, the money wins over boycotts.

60

 Mar 08, 2010 at 11:17 AM Anonymous Says:

rumor has it that this good had great influence on the israeli courtsystem to block the extradition of mondrowitz the molester who btw also happens to be a ger chasid. this goon needs his closets checked by an outside firm becausemost believe at this point thathegot lots of skeletons hiding in them.

61

 Mar 08, 2010 at 12:32 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #60  
Anonymous Says:

rumor has it that this good had great influence on the israeli courtsystem to block the extradition of mondrowitz the molester who btw also happens to be a ger chasid. this goon needs his closets checked by an outside firm becausemost believe at this point thathegot lots of skeletons hiding in them.

Here we go again. Mention Ger and some moron brings up Mondrowitz. Why when you mention Torah Temima isn't Kolko's name brought up. You constantly foment rechilus against Ger. You allow all the canards that exist out there to be published, regardless of value to the article. Yet you edit out any remarks defending anything about Ger.

62

 Mar 08, 2010 at 12:46 PM Anonymous Says:

Reading all this I am reminded of a quote by great (non-jewish) author.
If you want to avoid criticism, say nothing, do nothing, be nothing.

63

 Mar 08, 2010 at 12:50 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #61  
Anonymous Says:

Here we go again. Mention Ger and some moron brings up Mondrowitz. Why when you mention Torah Temima isn't Kolko's name brought up. You constantly foment rechilus against Ger. You allow all the canards that exist out there to be published, regardless of value to the article. Yet you edit out any remarks defending anything about Ger.

just for the record i do very much bring up kolko even when tora t is not mentioned . are you happy now ? . its common knowlege that ger was behind mondrowitz all allong . and its common knowlege that kolko is hiding out in lakewood and rabbi gissinger has no problem letting him into his shul

64

 Mar 08, 2010 at 01:06 PM SD Says:

Reply to #60  
Anonymous Says:

rumor has it that this good had great influence on the israeli courtsystem to block the extradition of mondrowitz the molester who btw also happens to be a ger chasid. this goon needs his closets checked by an outside firm becausemost believe at this point thathegot lots of skeletons hiding in them.

Sounds about right.
Otherwise it would be hard to understand how Modrowitz was protected all these years.
This "askan" sounds like the type of fellow who would put the interest of children last.

65

 Mar 08, 2010 at 02:39 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #6  
Anonymous Says:

Thank you VIN for highlighting this problem. The more I hear the less I give to tzedakas in Israel, of course my paltry few thousand a year is nothing to them but I would imagine that there are many others who feel the same way I do, the smell of corruption stinks across the oceans to these shores. 'Leaders' such as this Goldknopf line their pockets with donations and steal from the people they are supposed to be helping. They've already stolen an education from the masses as well as the ability to create any sort of financial independence, eventually the chareidim in Israel will be worse than the most ignorant savages in third-world countries. All because of the lust for power and greed by their leaders. I spit on Goldknopf and his ilk.

I couldnt agree more with you, i also stopped to donate to IL.
Besides the fact that there is mafaia there, its time for the american people to wake up and start realising that IL is no more in need of our donations, the old days are over, they have enough money, it is time to donate the monies between ourselves.

66

 Mar 08, 2010 at 02:46 PM Anonymous Says:

Reply to #32  
WB Says:

I can read from ur lines: that u only give tzedakah 2 the yankee stadium,
So who really cares about ur opinion of chasidim?

It is time to wake up and start support our brothers here in the US IL is rich enough, there is no need to donate any more to them (excpet to private people you knoe personally the need) I am chasiddish enough!

67

 Mar 08, 2010 at 03:43 PM Chossid Says:

Reply to #56  
Another Stamford Hiller Says:

No smoke without fire?
I assume you accept that there must be some truth in the allegation that jews make matzos out of the blood of christian children. After all, the story has the backing of hundreds of learned galochim and the overwhelming majority of trials for this offence in medieval Europe resulted in convictions and subsequent execution.
Do you STILL believe "no smoke without fire"?

You miss the point. When you see smoke you go looking for the fire. If you find the fire you put it out before it can do any more damage. If after searching properly you find there is no fire you know that the whole thing is false and it is just some scoundrel raising clouds to cover his own nefarious activities. But what you NEVER do is say "Oh I can see smoke so there must be a fire" without checking further.
VeHanimshal Muvan

68

 Mar 08, 2010 at 06:18 PM Shmuel Says:

Reply to #15  
BL21 Says:

For those who believe that this article is an unbiased investigative piece, you need a reality check. These people and groups, on both sides, are entrenched in a deep BUSINESS battle with many millions on the line.

To me what is so telling is the absolute lack of an validation to claims, or names of people who stand behind any accusations. These people may depend on aggressive business tactic that may border on illegal, however the articles clear intent is to demonize Goldknopf. WHY NOT INCLUDE THE FACTS, OR PERHAPS THEY DONT WANT TO?

One of the very few voices of reason on this board. Right on, BL21! From the very first paragraph, this article impressed me as a very poorly written smear attack that only the most gullible reader would take seriously.
Full disclosure: I've never heard of R'Goldknopf before, and if it appears that I am defending him, it is because my life experience taught me that any victiom of such smear attack is probably an upstanding man.

69

 Mar 08, 2010 at 08:39 PM formally Says:

Reply to #54  
Nosson Halevi Says:

The tragedy of this story, which remember was originated by the vitriolicly anti-Torah Maariv, is the terrible Chillul Hashem it generates.
All this stems from a support of power hungry leaders. By definition, a Torah leader is not power hungry. Moshe Rabeinu argued for 7 days with the Ribono Shel Olom, not to be selected as the leader.
Our leaders are leaders of the spirit. DRocheho Darchei NOam. Bullying, power groups, violent hafgonos, these are all tools of Esov.
Rebbes who fight to be the next rebbe, Rosh Yeshivas who are interested in the real estate value of the Yeshivah more than the students, Mechanchim who are there only because they don't know how else to put bread on the table. These are all examples of using the Torah as a spade.

The tragedy of this story, which remember was originated by the vitriolicly anti-Torah Maariv, is the terrible Chillul Hashem it generates.

your comment is hilarious.

It is the actions of Golbknopf that caused a chillul hashem. not the paper 's for reporting it.

Please, for those that are shocked . who must have been blind when you went to yeshiva and not the the corruption that was going on openly.

70

Sign-in to post a comment

Scroll Up
Advertisements:

Sell your scrap gold and broken jewelry and earn hard cash sell gold today!