Detroit, MI - No Perfume, Deodorant for City Employees |
|
Detroit, MI - City officials in Detroit say workers at three city buildings will soon have to monitor their scents or face possible warnings.
The Detroit News said Sunday that placards will be put up in the three Detroit buildings detailing the new guidelines on employees’ use of such scented items as cologne or perfume.
The notices due at the Cadillac Square Building, Coleman A. Young Municipal Center and First National Building will also ask employees to refrain from using air fresheners
and scented candles while on the job.
Other notices will go in the new employee handbook and mentioned in ADA training, according to the settlement.
The new regulations are the result of the city’s settlement of a 2008 lawsuit filed by a city planner, who claimed she had breathing sensitivity due to a co-worker’s perfume.
Attorney Ann Curry Thompson, who represents city planner Susan McBride, said her client’s lawsuit under the Americans with Disabilities Act could prove beneficial to others, the report said.
“It’s unique. I think it should be used as a model for other people who are having similar problems,” Thompson told the News.
More of today's headlines
“Mumbai, India - Police have arrested two men for planning to attack a fuel facility and a shopping centre in India’s financial and entertainment capital Mumbai, where...”
Mumbai, India - Police Arrests Two for Planning 3 to 4 Attacks in City
Lakewood, NJ - Yeshiva Student Settles Suit over Police "Gestapo-Like" Raid




Total24
Read Comments (24) — Post Yours »
1
Mar 14, 2010 at 10:37 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
How aboutsuing for coworkers wearing offensive colors which cause visual hardship......
2
Mar 14, 2010 at 10:41 PM ikey Says:Report as Inappropriate
im allergic to trees and grass time to sue the city for the ones on city property
3
Mar 14, 2010 at 10:52 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
any more ideas out there? I'd like to make some easy money too...
4
Mar 14, 2010 at 11:04 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Oh Brother. If you can't work in a public building, stay home!
5
Mar 14, 2010 at 11:22 PM chassidim Says:Report as Inappropriate
Oooooh, that building will smell like d rebbe's tish!!! Lol...
7
Mar 14, 2010 at 11:36 PM anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
As I too suffer from this condition, I am happy some action is being taken. This is not just about breathing sensitivity, this causes asthma-like symptoms. People feel very sick after being exposed to these scents. This is not just about money, it is very hard to find a solution for this problem, being in today's society we need to interact with others, of whom many are wearing perfume. When I discussed this issue with my doctor, he told me that because this issue is becoming more common many doctors have stopped wearing cologne and/or perfume. Please be sensitive to others with this issue and refrain from wearing these scented deodorants and perfume.
8
Mar 14, 2010 at 11:54 PM smelly Says:Report as Inappropriate
The best smell is no smell.
10
Mar 15, 2010 at 12:37 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Unscented anti-perspirant is the best thing to use. I have gotten a surprise nose- or lung-ful of someone's cologne, and then dissolved into a fit of coughing and/or sneezing (the clincher is getting a dirty look from them!). It's not just a nuisance - it can affect people's ability to breathe. It is scary.
11
Mar 15, 2010 at 12:59 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
america the lawsuit land, when will this stop?
12
Mar 15, 2010 at 01:02 AM bubby green Says:Report as Inappropriate
To tell ya the truth, i really don't know if it will be better or worse without deoderent! It's sipmly not mentshlich for people walking around without taking care of themselves. Maybe the happy medium should be, "ONLY UNSCENTED deoderent"!
13
Mar 15, 2010 at 07:16 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
My hubby recently was sitting at the table when someone walked in. His face turned white, and he stopped talking, I got very scared,, I started to ask him questions, and he just got up and left the room,, when that person left, he came back in, his color back to normal....it was very scary. He said that when she came in, her cheap perfume made him feel like he could not breathe.
14
Mar 15, 2010 at 08:36 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Ever walked into an elevator and have not been able to breathe until you or the offending person got off? I have this sensitivity (to some smells... I dont walk into perfume stores and dont wear any) but I would never dream of suing over it!!!
15
Mar 15, 2010 at 08:43 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ My hubby recently was sitting at the table when someone walked in. His face turned white, and he stopped talking, I got very scared,, I started to ask him questions, and he just got up and left the room,, when that person left, he came back in, his color back to normal....it was very scary. He said that when she came in, her cheap perfume made him feel like he could not breathe. ”
The moral of the story is: Invest in high end good smelling perfume.
I would rather someone were perfume than smell someone without!
When I was in college, during finals, I sat next to someone who did not wear deoderant. The smell literally made me sick and left finals early. Since then, I wear cologne so to avoid that situation again. If someone smells really bad, I smell myself!
Unfortunatly, a lot of frum Jews think that it is a mitzvah to smell bad. Hence, I am constantly smelling myself:)
16
Mar 15, 2010 at 09:54 AM LIBERALISM IS A DISEASE!!! Says:Report as Inappropriate
There is a major difference between scented deodorant & the massive heavy scented perfumes some people - especially those who probably work in that Detroit building - wear.
Ha'mayvin Yovin!
17
Mar 15, 2010 at 10:08 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
I wish our shul would do this. Some shabbos mornings you could gag.
18
Mar 15, 2010 at 10:08 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Doesn't matter whether it's cheap or expensive perfume (OR men's cologne!). If someone pours it on (or even if they didn't) and I get a whiff of it, it can trigger a sneezing and/or coughing spell. Good ol' soap and water work wonders... and yes, unscented anti-perspirant...
19
Mar 15, 2010 at 10:49 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
i suffer from this problem as well.
it doesnt bother me as much in a large open space but if i am in an elevator or small conference room with someone wearing a strong scent i get dizzy and short of breath. i see that some posters find it funnyhowever, if you were the one with these reactions you would not be laughing or making fun.
believe it or not i ahve had the same reaction if i am in a car with someone who has too much garlic. i actually stopped giving someone a ride many years ago due to the garlic smell.
keep laughing but know that i carry an epi pen due to my allergies.
i wont (if at all possible) walk anywhere near the perfume department in stores either.
i do as much as i can to self protect.
the least you clowns can do is respect this problem instead of mocking it.
and for those of you who use perfumes to cover up lack of showering....soap and water and unscented deoderant work much better than dousing yourself with colognes or perfumes no matter how much they cost.
20
Mar 15, 2010 at 11:33 AM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
I too suffer from any scented products. Everything in my household from
Detergents, moisturizers, soaps, cleaning products and the like are
Fragrance Free. There's absolutely no perfume allowed in my house !
I get a migraine headache from scented products. When going to a Simcha
I carry a packet of Advil because I know there's a chance I can become ill from everyones perfume at the wedding. I recall the time I gave my car in for a day for a Pesach cleaning and the cleaning crew happily put a scented packet hanging from my rear view mirror. Even after removing the scented packet I could not drive my car for a week until the smell was somewhat gone. I'm happy to hear that the topic of people suffering from strong scents has come to a public forum.
21
Mar 15, 2010 at 01:01 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
Two years ago I developed chemical sensitivities (allergies) including many perfumes and mens colognes. I have stopped going to shul on shabbos and attending simchas can be a nightmare. I attended a wedding this week and a woman sitting near me wore so much perfume I became totally disoriented and felt really sick. I'm told by a perfume industry specialist that the problem is much worse in recent years because companies are adding stabilizers to the perfumes to make them stay on much longer and be more intense and these chemicals are the real problem.
Another problem is the heavy cleansers and shampoos used in commercial places for carpeting in hotel corridors, office buildings etc. It's time to start eliminating all these powerful chemicals from our envirnment and figure out a healthier way to get the job done. Otherwise more and more people will start developing these sensitivites and who knows how much damage it's doing to our children's development
22
Mar 15, 2010 at 01:42 PM Raphael Kaufman Says:Report as Inappropriate
Multiple chemical sensitivity used to be called by a different name - Hypochondria.
23
Mar 15, 2010 at 03:48 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
#22 i think that instead of raphael kaufman we can just call you cynic. and that is the nicest term i could come up with.
24
Mar 15, 2010 at 04:51 PM Sue Says:Report as Inappropriate
I don't doubt that this perfume issue was a real and legitimate problem for the city planner who filed this lawsuit. I remember sitting in a class in high school breathing the strong scent of cheap Tabu perfume that the girl in front of me marinated in before school every day. It gagged me and I hated it. I'm sure there are people out there much more sensitive than me and prone to breathing difficulties, sneezing, and other problems. My problem with this is that a lawsuit was filed in federal court (that's all of our tax dollars at work) using the ADA as a prybar (don't think that was the purpose of ADA) and someone is getting $100k for this. The article doesn't give us all of the information, so perhaps we'll never know why a supervisor couldn't have handled this or a compromise struck between the employees, but I suppose in this day and age it takes a lawsuit to make policies stick, doesn't it? Sad, disappointing & wrong.
25
Mar 15, 2010 at 05:11 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
“ As I too suffer from this condition, I am happy some action is being taken. This is not just about breathing sensitivity, this causes asthma-like symptoms. People feel very sick after being exposed to these scents. This is not just about money, it is very hard to find a solution for this problem, being in today's society we need to interact with others, of whom many are wearing perfume. When I discussed this issue with my doctor, he told me that because this issue is becoming more common many doctors have stopped wearing cologne and/or perfume. Please be sensitive to others with this issue and refrain from wearing these scented deodorants and perfume. ”
Many years ago my daughter, who suffers from allergies, had a front seat in class, which she liked, but her teacher's heavy use of perfume was making her ill. I called the teacher and politely asked her to curtail her use of perfume. Today, this teacher's daughter is my daughter-in-law, and her mother still remembers my phone call! (Talk about embarrassing!)
26
Mar 15, 2010 at 06:25 PM Anonymous Says:Report as Inappropriate
The best suggestion is to bathe or shower daily and use soap!! Then use the deodorant!! If you do not shower or bathe daily, you will bring in your own perfume!! I hope VIN posts this.