“ Accidents can happen even to the ones on our side. The fact that she was on "wrong side" doesn't make this less of an accident. So sad to see innocents get caught in the quagmires. ”

“ Accidents can happen even to the ones on our side. The fact that she was on "wrong side" doesn't make this less of an accident. So sad to see innocents get caught in the quagmires. ”

“ im as right wing as they come - but this is really not cool ”

“ Yes I have rachomoness on you Emily, but YOU didn't have rachmoness on the Jewish children maimed and killed. You decided to side with your brother and sisters enemies. ”

“ Ahhh, if only she'd have been protesting digging graves, I'm sure that there would be thousands rioting on her behalf right now... ”

“ recuperating at Haddassah hospital - who's paying??? ”

“ Chazal forbid us from having rachmonus on people like her! ”

“ And Gilad Shalit has lost 4 years of his life and possibly his life. ”

“ While I do not gloat over the loss of this woman's eye, i have to note there are considerably less posts when rabid, left wing, self hating, Jews demonstrate, then when the ultra orthodox demonstrate. I can only assume that that is because those who post against the ultra orthodox find some measure of justification for the left wingers whose belief system is obviously close to their own hearts as opposed to when the ultra orthodox demonstrate for Torah principals that they cannot relate to. ”

“ These people are very good at faking injuries and lying. It wouldn't be the first time that they lied about
an injury. And if someone initiates a conflict do they expect that they too will not be at risk for injury. It goes both ways. They go against Israel and Maritime
law and they play the victims. Appalling Chutzpah is
a feature of Erev Moschiach!! ”

“ So many comments. Yet not one even thinks to tread upon the reason of WHY this may have happened! Everything is straight from the one above. The girl and her eye were probably more of a voice for all of US to open OUR EYES! I would imagine that a lot of us do things with our eyes on a daily basis that are worst than her standing in the thick of a bunch of lunatics. Her neshama was already tainted. Ours are not. While I am not a prophet and G-d forbid am i trying to act like the judge of all, I do take away from this incident that it is very important that we should all be careful what we use our eyes for. If just one of us are a little more careful of what we use or eyes for than her loss was worth it. ”

“ I do not pity her. It is forbidden to have pity on fools and kal vachomer on mosrim. ”

“ So many comments. Yet not one even thinks to tread upon the reason of WHY this may have happened! Everything is straight from the one above. The girl and her eye were probably more of a voice for all of US to open OUR EYES! I would imagine that a lot of us do things with our eyes on a daily basis that are worst than her standing in the thick of a bunch of lunatics. Her neshama was already tainted. Ours are not. While I am not a prophet and G-d forbid am i trying to act like the judge of all, I do take away from this incident that it is very important that we should all be careful what we use our eyes for. If just one of us are a little more careful of what we use or eyes for than her loss was worth it. ”

“ These left wing self hating maniacs have to realise that being mean vicous and cruel comes with a price... Just the way it is... ”

“ Accidents can happen even to the ones on our side. The fact that she was on "wrong side" doesn't make this less of an accident. So sad to see innocents get caught in the quagmires. ”

“ For those who are gloating over this young woman's loss of an eye, would you, personally, have exacted such harsh judgment on her if you had had the chance? Who amongst us , does not know, or is not related to, someone who suffers from some such similar misguided instincts against her own people? ”

“ “ recuperating at Haddassah hospital - who's paying???”

Don't worry, it's clearly not you. ”

“ “ recuperating at Haddassah hospital - who's paying???”

Don't worry, it's clearly not you. ”

“ For those who are gloating over this young woman's loss of an eye, would you, personally, have exacted such harsh judgment on her if you had had the chance? Who amongst us , does not know, or is not related to, someone who suffers from some such similar misguided instincts against her own people? ”

“ When a tinnukos shneisbus does something wrong, it's not considered an aveirah. It's a pity most people here are full of sinas chinum. She doesn't know better and yet most people here have not the slightest bit of rachmonos. This doesn't mean that they should let all these anarchists in to add fuel to the fire. They should all be deported. If Israel wasn't so interested in always kissing up to the goyim, this latest fou pah wouldn't have happened. Gaza is part of Eretz Yisroel; they had no right to give it up. If they wouldn't have given it up, no one would be trying to bring them "humanitarian" goods. Secondly, if they had a bunch a ships breaking a naval blockade -you order them to follow you to port by loud speaker and radio; if they don't listen and they don't turn around, then you open fire until they comply or they are destroyed. Boarding vessels is what the Coast Guard does, not the Navy. This is what the US and every other democratic country would have done. The Israelis make themselves into a shmateh and then ask why does the world step on them. Now, because of their stupid blunder, they have made open hunting season on themselves and all Jews (due to association). ”

“ if she would of been protesting in Iran...where would she be now?? She's in Hadash hospital getting the best care...from Israel... ”

“ We have to realize there is a vast increase of young left wing secular Jews who hail from conservative and reform backgrounds who are protesting on many college campuses throughout America on behalf of the arabs. Why? because we did not reach out to be mekarev these millions of neshomas to yiddishkeit. So they supported the likes of Obama and now activly protest for our enemies. We must not forget that the entire ship incident was midah keneged midah. The secular Israeli government beat up Jews protesting for Shabbos thats why their soldiers got beat up. The secular Israeli government unleashed a volley of hatred against charedi Jews so G-d unleashed a hatred from the entire world on them. NO SHABBOS NO PEACE. ”

“ Frum Jew here, and an active Obama supporter. Sorry, we're not all the same in terms of opinions and beliefs. ”

“ There is no concept of "tinuk shenishba" on retzicha! When John Gotti jr goes to yener velt, he'll teina "What are you talking about? I just did what my father did, and his father before him!", but this doesn't work because he should have figured it out!
This poor young Jewish girl should NOT have taken the side of people who kill Jews! She should have known that even if Israel was wrong, we Jews stick together, and that Hamas is a terrorist organization who uses all donated supplies as a means to get more weapons. Even a box of oranges is a deadly weapon in the hands of a Gazan, because he'll sell it and give part of the money to support terrorism.
It may seem cold and harsh for me to say this, and in truth I do feel terrible for this poor girl, but....good! Hashem had rachmunos on her, she deserves to have lost both eyes! ”

“ The name sounds jewish, I really doubt that she was just an innocent person standing at the side, from her comments on facebook it sounds like she was part of the demonstration and self hating jew, I'm not saying she was a violent or peacefull one... ”

“ Poor misguided child, playing in a grownups world. ”

“ If she was standing with terrorists or financially sending them money, you'd be right. You have no proof that she was, she probably was only supporting the local street arabs. NK constantly supports terrorists. So you have no reason to say halachically that she isn't a tinukes shneshbes. The only reason you have no rachmonos on this girl is because you have to be right politically, no matter what. And no, not all arabs have a din Rodef and not all are terrorists. Even though, I politically agree with most bloggers on this site, the only difference between me and you is - I put Torah principles before my nehgios of my politics. One of them is to be "Dan l'caf Zecus" this non-frum girl. ”

“ So then explain with what we are different from other nations that we are hated so if it is not God that's sending us a message to heed his commandments? I'm wiating for an intelligent answer. ”

“ If she was standing with terrorists or financially sending them money, you'd be right. You have no proof that she was, she probably was only supporting the local street arabs. NK constantly supports terrorists. So you have no reason to say halachically that she isn't a tinukes shneshbes. The only reason you have no rachmonos on this girl is because you have to be right politically, no matter what. And no, not all arabs have a din Rodef and not all are terrorists. Even though, I politically agree with most bloggers on this site, the only difference between me and you is - I put Torah principles before my nehgios of my politics. One of them is to be "Dan l'caf Zecus" this non-frum girl. ”

“ Neither Emily nor the NK's are tinoke shenishbos. People who give support, be it monetery, moral or other are traitors, they side with the enemy and in this case it's an enemy who wants to annihilate the Jews.
What do you mean with supporting the local Arabs on the street? You go to the local Arabs on the street and ask them to tell you what they would like to do with the Jews in Israel.
Why doesn't she support her brothers and sisters who are continuously fighting for survival? ”