Tel Aviv – In a rare move, the Council of Torah Sages of the haredi Degel HaTorah movement convened late Monday evening in Bnei Brak and called on the government not to enact any mandatory draft into national service of the 54,000 yeshiva students who have until now been able to indefinitely postpone enlistment.
Subscribe to our Daily Roundup Email
The council, headed by the acknowledged leader of the non-hassidic “Lithuanian” haredi community Rabbi Aharon Leib Shteinman, declared that “The Council of Torah Sages deeply regrets the wave of incitement against the haredi community, especially against the holy Torah students, in whose merit the world continues to exist.”
The rabbis went on to call on the on the government “to not change in any way the state of affairs regarding yeshiva students which has been in effect from ancient times here in the Land of Israel.”
The Council of Torah Sages, led by the “gadol hador,” the leading rabbi of the generation, determines the stance of the haredi community on almost every issue of public life, have not been made for many years, and there are several potential new additions.
Degel Hatorah is the non-hassidic faction of the United Torah Judaism political party, which also includes Agudat Yisrael, which represents the hassidic stream of the haredi community.
In attendance at the meeting were also UTJ MKs Moshe Gafni and Uri Maklev, who provided the political background to the absence of any legal framework for yeshiva students to gain deferals from military service, which the Tal Law provided until it expired on August 1.
The meeting, which took place in Shteinman’s residence in Bnei Brak, was intended to serve as a unifying rally for the haredi community in light of what it perceives as threats to its lifestyle regarding the possible drafting of yeshiva students because of the expiration of the Tal Law.
Despite the calls for unity, Rabbi Shmuel Auerbach, an opponent of Shteinman did not turn up to the meeting.
Divisions within the haredi leadership have opened up of late following the illness and death of Rabbi Yosef Shalom Elyashiv, the former leader of the “Lithuanian” haredim, last month.
Rabbi Auerbach, 86, was considered by his supporters to be the natural successor to Elyashiv, but Rabbi Shteinman, 98, succeeded in gaining acknowledgement as the new leader of the community.
The council meeting was also called to admit several new members given the recent deaths of former membes Rabbi Haim Pinchas Scheinberg and Rabbi Nosson Tzvi Fink.
According to reports in the haredi media, Auerbach decided not to attend because his recommendations for new members of the council were not accepted.
The haredi website Behadrei Haredim even reported that Auerbach may step down as a member of the council in protest.
Current members of the current council are Shteinman himself; Rabbi Shmuel Auerbach, dean of the Maalot Hatorah yeshiva in Jerusalem; Rabbi Nissim Karlitz, head of the rabbinical court in Bnei Brak; Rabbi Meir Tzvi Bergman dean of the Rashbi yeshiva in Bnei Brak; dean of the Ponevezh Yeshiva in Bnei Brak Rabbi Gershon Edelstein; and Rabbi Yitzhak Shteiner, the head of the Kamenitz Yeshiva in Jerusalem.
All of the council members were in attendance apart from Auerbach, while Rabbi Haim Kanievsky, another leading rabbi and a supporter of Shteinman who was expected to attend (although not a member), was not present having been briefly hospitalised for a minor complaint and only released on Monday.
The rare meeting of the council Monday evening was slated as a call for “shalom bayit” or familial peace, within the haredi community, but Auerbach’s absence will sour this unity call.
A low-level power struggle between the two became particularly rancorous over the battle the supporters of the respective rabbis fought over Yated Neeman, the daily newspaper of Degel HaTorah.
Shteinman’s supporters succeeded in gaining control of the newspaper which had traditionally favoured Auerbach.
Auerbach’s followers, led by the deposed editor and director of Yated Neeman subsequently established a newspaper, HaPeles, claiming to represent the true path of Degel HaTorah, as established by the movement’s founder Rabbi Elazar Menachem Shach.
Content is provided courtesy of the Jerusalem Post
Theese freeloaders want to have it all have gan aiden in this world and the next,what are they thinking that others will slave for them to live their dream world out with no hardships?.
The rabbis went on to call on the on the government “to not change in any way the state of affairs regarding yeshiva students which has been in effect from ancient times here in the Land of Israel.”
distortion of torah and history
why are they protesting if torah protects you from missile it sure can protect you from a few politicians.
Baruch Hashem that someone has a parnassa from manufacturing and selling sack cloth in 2012. Mi kiamcha Yisroel!
If they really have magical powers, then they should be able to avoid the draft without demonstrating, rioting or wearing burlap. All they need to do is sit and quietly read gemara
Sorry to interrupt the bickering between #1 and #7 .
Here is a real observation. The world existed before the 54,000 Bnai Yeshiva existed and it can exist without them. There is no place in the Torah that says otherwise. But why can they not just do the right thing and serve in the army? We have BalaBatim here in America working in doing all kinds of work. Chasidim, Modern Orthodox, even Yeshivish Lakewood people work for a living and also find time to learn Torah and follow Torah. So did the Tanaim and Amoraim. Israel is doing the right thing by requiring ALL able bodied men to take a turn at defending the country. And save me the explanations about how they are filling that role in the Bais Medrash. The doctors in the hospital save lives, not the guy in Yeshiva across town. And the soldiers guarding the country keep it safe. Chareidim find time for Hatzala, Chevra Kadisha, shnoring, and these are all necessary. Just add army to the list. Do it, get back to Yeshiva when it is done, and everyone lives happily ever after.
We live in a physical world. Everyone on this site would agree on that. It someone gets sick, C”VS, they might give their name for Tehillim, but they will ALSO go to the doctor. They don’t say – I don’t have to go to the doctor – the learning will protect me. You need both.
When a young man goes into Tzahal, his parents and family worry and daven for him. Many mothers’ hair turns white. It is not simple. Their child is at risk to protect the entire country. Everyone in the Jewish world should say a big Thank You to the soldier and the family.
One of the most aggravating parts of these protests is the people protesting don’t acknowledge what sacrifice is entailed for the members of Tzahal and their families.
I urge the Rabbonim and Chachomim to find a way to acknowledge the contributions of Tzahal and find a way to support their efforts. I think that would go a very long way to solving the issue.
You know, Zaka could be a part of Tzahal. Other Chesed organizations could be part of service. Honesty would find a way to work in a unified manner. It would be a win win.
Last I checked, “Veahavta L’Rayacha Kamocha” is a D’Oraisa.
The tribe of Levy sat and learned in yeshiva as FREE MEN in Goshen while the Egyptians enslaved klal Yisroel.