Welcome, Guest! - or
Easy to remember!  »  VinNews.com

Berlin - German Government Urged To Protect Circumcision

Published on: August 22, 2012 08:54 AM
By: AP
Change text size Text Size  

FILE - A rabbi follows the parliamentary debate on the circumcision of male children from the visitor's gallery at the Bundestag in Berlin, Germany, 19 July 2012.  EPA/WOLFGANG KUMMBerlin - Jewish groups increased pressure on the German government Wednesday to speed up the passage of new legislation protecting the practice of ritual circumcision after a doctor filed a complaint with prosecutors accusing a rabbi of causing a child bodily harm.

A debate in Germany over the Jewish and Muslim practice of ritual circumcision started after a regional court in Cologne ruled in June that the practice amounted to causing criminal bodily harm to a child.

It calmed after the German government pledged to draft new legislation protecting the practice, but flared again this week after a doctor filed the latest complaint with prosecutors in the southern city of Hof.

Even though any German can file such a complaint and it is then up to prosecutors to decide whether to press charges, the Conference of European Rabbis said the legal move showed the need for “immediate action” from lawmakers in Berlin.


“This latest development in Hof, Germany is yet another grave affront to religious freedom and underlines the urgent need for the German government to expedite the process of ensuring that the fundamental rights of minority communities are protected,” said Pinchas Goldschmidt, head of the European Orthodox group and also chief rabbi of Moscow.

The Simon Wiesenthal Center in Los Angeles pledged “all necessary and legal backing” to defend the practice of ritual circumcision of young boys, which is central to the Jewish faith.

It said two of its top officials would meet next week in Berlin with the German justice minister to press her “to move rapidly to create legislation guaranteeing full legal protection of religious rights for Jews and other minorities.”

Hof head prosecutor Gerhard Schmitt said the doctor, who is from the western state of Hesse but whose name was not released, cited the Cologne decision in asking for charges to be brought against the rabbi. Evaluating whether charges are warranted could take weeks, Schmitt said.

Schmitt said he could not confirm German media reports that the doctor was one of a group of 600 doctors and lawyers who wrote an open letter to the government in July in support of the Cologne decision.

The rabbi, David Goldberg, is one of the country’s few mohels — a person trained in the Jewish ritual of circumcision — and has said he has no intention of stopping the practice despite the legal uncertainty.

Meanwhile, German Justice Ministry spokeswoman Anne Zimmermann told reporters Wednesday that a draft law should be ready by the fall.

“We take this request very seriously, of course, and will submit a draft as soon as possible, but also examine all aspects with due diligence,” she said.

German Foreign Minister Guido Westerwelle weighed in while on a trip to Liechtenstein, saying that “Jewish and Muslim traditions must be allowed to be practiced without legal uncertainty.”

“We cannot risk Germany’s reputation in the world as a country of religious tolerance,” he said. “From my perspective it’s necessary now to rapidly come up with clear regulations.”

More of today's headlines

Albany, NY - A Siena College poll shows 80 percent of New York voters want the state's minimum wage raised from $7.25 an hour to $8.50. The poll shows an uptick in... Federal Way, WA - A Washington state man accused of making an email threat against President Barack Obama and brandishing a shotgun at officers who came to his door is...



Read Comments (3)  —  Post Yours »


 Aug 22, 2012 at 09:17 AM Dovid Says:

We need to talk openly with the Authorities. Because there are certain extreme situations on the opposite ends, which we can both agree on, as to, when a Government can outlaw certain Religious activties.

We have to agree that a Gov’t is allowed to forbid, selling one’s young daughter to slavery, to do a Maaseh Akeido on ones child, or to burn ones daughter like Yiftach Hashofet in order to be M’kayem his Nedder, to do the Parshas Ben Sorrer, or Maaseh Soiteh on one’s wife, or Female cicumcission.
We also both agree that any parent is allowed to “brainwash” his child to believe absolutely in his religion; or to persuade his child to Dress in accordance with his religion.
So there are only some in-between situations where we disagree and should try to impress them.


 Aug 22, 2012 at 01:14 PM Wondering Says:

Just wondering what Jews are doing living in Germany after these Amalekim tried and almost succeeded in eradicating the Jewish nation from the world. Why would any Jew want to live in such an evil and tamei place?


 Aug 23, 2012 at 08:55 AM Kzler Says:

Reply to #2  
Wondering Says:

Just wondering what Jews are doing living in Germany after these Amalekim tried and almost succeeded in eradicating the Jewish nation from the world. Why would any Jew want to live in such an evil and tamei place?

As one who smelled the smoke of the crematorium in Buchenwald I agree 100% with you but once there was a Don Abarbanel but today we have others. The issue arose from a circumcision performed on a Muslim boy a by Turkish Muslim doctor and the mother removed the bandage too early and a hemorrhage ensued. However, your question is the underlying issue. Far worse is that a man named Kraus[NK] living in the holy city gave an interview to the Spiegel and blasted E.Y. We have a lot of issues to resolve. The ban was issued by a court in Cologne and not a Bundesgericht or Federal Court.


to post a comment

Click here to sign-in.

Scroll Up
Sell your scrap gold and broken jewelry and earn hard cash sell gold today!