New York – Storm Was Cruel To Elderly Who Refused To Evacuate

    13

    Sheila and Dominic Traina hug in front of their home which was demolished during Superstorm Sandy in the Staten Island borough of New York, Friday, Nov. 2, 2012.  A Superstorm Sandy relief fund is being created just for residents of the hard-hit New York City borough. Former Mayor Rudolph Giuliani and Borough President James Molinaro say the fund will help residents displaced from their homes. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig)New York – Even with her Coney Island apartment squarely in the path of Superstorm Sandy, Loraine Gore was staying put. At age 90, she said, she had her reasons.

    Join our WhatsApp group

    Subscribe to our Daily Roundup Email


    “I’m tired,” she told a friend who urged her to evacuate. “I don’t want to go.”

    After floodwaters subsided, Gore’s body was found face-down in her home — one of nearly a dozen New Yorkers over the age of 65 who perished in the storm.

    While Sandy claimed victims as young as toddlers, it was crueler to the city’s elderly.

    Some were vulnerable because of poor health. The power failure cut off the oxygen supply for an ailing 75-year woman living in Manhattan’s East Village. Her grandson rushed to a nearby hospital to get a manual tank, but by the time he returned, she had died from an apparent heart attack.

    Others died fleeing the storm. On Wednesday, police discovered the bodies of an 89-year-old man and his 66-year-old wife next to their car in a vacant lot on Staten Island. Police believe the couple died after their car became submerged in water.

    Most drowned alone in bedrooms, living rooms and basements that flooded.

    One 84-year-old victim in Queens was confined to a wheelchair, meaning she probably couldn’t have fled the rising water. But other older victims weren’t homebound. They chose to stay and risk their lives, perhaps too stubborn or too weary to do otherwise.

    Another was 82-year-old Jimmy Rossi, known as “Uncle Jimmy” because so many people in his tight-knit Staten Island community are related. Rossi lived in a beach bungalow and spent much of his time tending to his aging bulldog, Shorty.

    As the water began to rise Monday night, neighbors assumed Rossi had heeded calls to head for higher ground. A niece heard through a friend that he was going to his son’s house. He told his son he was going to a friend’s.

    But when the storm eased Tuesday, it became increasingly clear Rossi had done neither.

    Rossi’s son, Joe, his nephew and some neighbors used a kayak to break the windows of his submerged home in a frantic, failed search. On Wednesday, his body was found in the marsh behind his house, where Shorty had survived.

    Neighbor Richard Quinn, a retired firefighter, speculated that Rossi had left the house to escape the rising water but got swept up in it.

    “Like the rest of us, he probably figured it wasn’t going to be as bad as it was,” said Quinn, who has lived across the street for 50 years. “It was like a tsunami coming.”

    Gore’s final hours were spent in the apartment where she had lived alone since her husband, a former transit worker, died more than a decade ago. She was known as a neighborhood pioneer — one of the first to live at the water’s edge in a complex of 22 two-story townhouses.

    Longtime friend Celina Grant recalled Gore as “a pleasant, humble person” who was a “very, very independent woman.”

    She “loved gardening and loved God,” Grant said.

    In recent years, Gore had the help of a home health care aide after she developed difficulty walking. She told a neighbor she had stopped using the second floor.

    On Monday, a friend tried to coax Gore out of her home, but she refused. Bayside waters later rose, flooding the first floors of all the apartments with 4 feet of water.

    The next day, with no sign of Gore, a man used a screwdriver to pry open her door.

    A moment later, he came back out, shouting: “She’s dead! Call 911!” said neighbor Jenny Brown.

    Brown ventured inside, finding Gore face-down on the floor, her arms spread out, surrounded by overturned furniture and dirt left behind by the receding waters.

    “It was a mess like all of our apartments,” she said. “Maybe she didn’t feel good. Maybe she slept there.”

    The neighbors sought comfort in fond memories of Gore. Some recalled that her favorite flowers were carnations.

    Gore liked “that they last so long,” Grant said.

    She paused for a few seconds before adding: “Like her.”


    Listen to the VINnews podcast on:

    iTunes | Spotify | Google Podcasts | Stitcher | Podbean | Amazon

    Follow VINnews for Breaking News Updates


    Connect with VINnews

    Join our WhatsApp group


    13 Comments
    Most Voted
    Newest Oldest
    Inline Feedbacks
    View all comments
    11 years ago

    These stories are tragic but ultimately, there were warnings for days and days that this could be the storm of the century and people needed to take precautions and evacuate in areas which might be susceptible to flooding. If you look at the NY times on the Friday before the storm, there were forecasts of flooding that could reach or exceed those of Hurricane Irene last year. There were gazillions of warnings about making sure you had emergency supplies of water, food, battery power to last a week or longer. The Con Ed website has a posting from prior to the storm forecasting that the power might not be restored for a week or longer. There is just so much you can do to warn people but ultimately they (or their families) have to take responsiblity for their own actions and those who don’t pay the consequences as we tragically saw earlier this week. But don’t blame the government for not taking care of you when you won’t do it for yourself.

    PaulinSaudi
    PaulinSaudi
    11 years ago

    Exactly, society did all it could, some people decided to one thing, others decided to do another thing. We ought to help them of course, but we cannot help but feel they made their decision.

    eyedoc
    eyedoc
    11 years ago

    Reply to#2 You are the real fool. Seniors do have a way to get to higher ground. First, their families should help them. If they are alone, the city set up shelters that they could get to. Many seniors just didn’t want to heed the warnings. My father in law lives in one of the evacuation zones in Brooklyn and refused to leave becuase he just didn’t want to go. Thank G-d he is okay. But after several days in the dark, his son picked him up and took him to his house away from the area. He wanted to get him before but he had refused. #1 is correct. There is just so much that can be done. Seniors need to take personal responsibility for themselves and if they do not have the mental capacity to do so, then their children must intervene on their behalf.

    Geulah
    Geulah
    11 years ago

    While one can classically blame the victim and others can classically blame the state, the facts on the ground show that all of us are ill prepared to deal with a castrophe of this nature and this magnitude. You can plan, but you don’t drill for these disasters and it takes practice to see where the holes are in plans. We’re too busy waiting for the next 9/11 or London style terrorist attack and forget that nature is something we have to deal with every day. None of us look good. May Hashem welcome these neshomas and elevate them.

    blahblah
    blahblah
    11 years ago

    Many of these victims DID heed warnings for Irene, which turned out to be a big fat nothing (at least in NYC, I am aware that they got hammered upstate). As a result, they decided to chance it this time- can’t say I blame them. There was a young family in SI that stayed because they had left for Irene (which again, was not nearly as bad as the hype) and returned to find they had been robbed. Assuming this would be similar, they decided to stay. The father and 13 year old daughter died, the mother is in the hospital and still unaware of what happened to her family r’l. Don’t judge if you don’t know the whole story.

    yiddishkind
    yiddishkind
    11 years ago

    It should be a crime that goes punished to stay in an evacuation zone. PERIOD
    That mother that put her 2 children in to danger by not evacuating should be charged in contributing to manslaughter.
    Otherwise no one will learn.

    Normal
    Normal
    11 years ago

    This is very very true and the lesson in it should be taken to heart:

    “Jacob is a very religious man. One day, a nearby river floods its banks and rushes into town, forcing Jacob to climb onto his garage roof. Soon, a man in a boat comes along and tells Jacob to get in.
    Jacob says, “That’s very kind of you, but no thanks. God will take care of me.”
    So, the boat leaves.
    The water rises and Jacob has to climb onto the roof of his house. Another man in a boat comes along and tells Jacob to get in.
    Jacob replies, “That’s very kind of you but no thanks. God will take care of me.”
    The boat leaves.
    The water rises further and soon Jacob is clinging to his chimney. Then a helicopter arrives and lowers a ladder. The helicopter pilot tells Jacob to climb up the ladder.
    Jacob replies, “That’s very kind of you but no thanks. God will take care of me.”
    The pilot says, “Are you really sure?”
    Jacob says, “Yes, I’m sure that God will take care of me.”
    Finally, the water rises too high and Jacob drowns. He goes up to Heaven and is met by God.
    Jacob says to God, “You told me you would take care of me. What happened?”
    God replies, “Well, I sent you two boats and a helicopter. What else did you want

    11 years ago

    I agree that government did everything that they could to warn people. I think there was lack of action on government side to forcefully evacuate people with disabilities. A lot of these people live alone. Some of them have home attendants who could not come that day. There was no communication. I feel that all people with severe disabilities have to focefully evacuated to the nearby hospitals particularly if they live alone.