Israel – Incredible Story: Iraqi Woman Abducted By Muslim 55 Years Ago, Reunited With Her Jewish Family

    20

    Israel -Fifty-five years after she was abducted from her family’s home in Baghdad by her Muslim neighbor and forced to renounce her Judaism, Hannah Menashe managed to flee Iraq and find her way to one of Israel’s European embassies. Her long, exhausting journey is finally coming to an end these days, as she will soon be reunited with he family in Israel, who thought her murdered all these years.

    Join our WhatsApp group

    Subscribe to our Daily Roundup Email


    Hannah’s fascinating story begins in the 1950s, when her Baghdad-native family – parents and seven siblings – decided to immigrate to Israel. Hannah, already married to a Jewish Iraqi, was also planning to make aliyah, when fate struck: A Muslim neighbor, who was aware of the family’s plans to immigrate, kidnapped the striking Hannah to keep her by his side. Her siblings only have a vague recollection of that horrible day. They went looking for Hannah, they say, but the earth had swallowed her.

    Decades passed, the siblings made aliyah and the family expanded, all the while keeping their bitter secret to themselves. Shortly after arriving in Israel, Hannah’s mother died at 37, her heart broken by losing her child.

    Six months ago, out of the blue, the family received a surprising phone call. The woman on the other side of the line was Ravit Topol from the Ministry of Interior, with an extraordinary story she was looking to verify.

    It turns out Hannah had been forced to become a Muslim and had raised her neighbor’s children for 50 years. No one in the Baghdad neighborhood knew about her secret or her Jewish roots, and she was afraid her husband would kill her if she tried to contact her siblings.

    When her husband died a year ago, the now 76-year-old Hannah escaped Baghdad under the guise of being being a war refugee. She was able to reach Europe through an Arab country and decided to locate an Israeli embassy.

    “I am Jewish, I want to go to Israel,” she said in fluent Arabic and with great excitement. The embassy found it hard to believe her story; but when she named her relatives in Israel, the embassy officials realized the truly incredible nature of the story unfolding before their very eyes and quickly contacted the Ministry of Interior’s population administration.

    What happened? Did they find her?” asked Ephraim Menashe, Hannah’s brother, upon receiving the moving phone call. “We were in shock. Some of us hung up the phone, finding it hard to believe it was real,” Ephraim told Yedioth Ahronoth on Wednesday. “I always kept the faith that one day we would find her, my beloved sister.”

    Meanwhile, the Israeli consul of the European city Hannah had arrived at took her into his private residence until she was able to board the plane taking her to Israel.

    Hannah will be arriving in Israel shortly, where she will be acknowledged as the long-lost sister of a Jewish family and be granted new immigrant status.

    Her relatives gathered late Wednesday at her brother Ephraim’s home in Ramat-Gan. “He hasn’t slept a wink from all the excitement,” his wife said. “My heart is loaded, but I don’t want to say too much right now,” said Ephraim. “I must ask her a questions which only she can answer.”

    According to Hannah’s brother, only he knows the true details of her disappearance, since he was her closest sibling. “As soon as we had reached Israel, I decided to return to Iraq to look for her, but it the timing was wrong, and didn’t make it there.”

    It’s hardly an easy task to make up for 55 lost years, her relatives agreed, especially since Hannah’s parents and some of her brothers and sisters have passed away. “It won’t be easy, but we love her and will help her adjust.”


    Listen to the VINnews podcast on:

    iTunes | Spotify | Google Podcasts | Stitcher | Podbean | Amazon

    Follow VINnews for Breaking News Updates


    Connect with VINnews

    Join our WhatsApp group


    20 Comments
    Most Voted
    Newest Oldest
    Inline Feedbacks
    View all comments
    mark levin
    mark levin
    15 years ago

    what an amaizing story!!!!!

    WELCOME BACK!!!

    Anonymous
    Anonymous
    15 years ago

    wow!

    Anonymous
    Anonymous
    15 years ago

    What about the children she had while in Iraq? Aren’t they Jewish?

    cvm
    cvm
    15 years ago

    How painful for the parents and siblings all these years, and what a sorrow to be held captive in Iraq by a Muslim beast for all those years.

    May hashem grant the family comfort and peace.

    halacha man
    halacha man
    15 years ago

    Was her husband the Iraqi Jew an agunah all those years, and did he remarry and establish a new family…

    a feeling jew
    a feeling jew
    15 years ago

    what a painful story – oh golus how long are you!!

    a Traveler
    a Traveler
    15 years ago

    A man, especially Sfardim, can have more than one wife. They do not hold with the Cherem D’Rabeinu Gershom.

    ASD
    ASD
    15 years ago

    dear halacha man- a man CAN NOT be an agunah.

    -an am ha’aretz

    yatzmach
    yatzmach
    15 years ago

    to halacha man:

    aguna applies to a wife that her husband disappeared. the husband though (especially that they were probably sephardic) is allowed to marry two wives al pi halacha.

    mnuez
    mnuez
    15 years ago

    Sounds unbelievable, but if true, how shockingly sad.

    But let the sadness end, the clouds part and the joyous celebration begin. V’Shavu Vavim L’Gvulam!

    mnuez

    Chacham Mah Nishtanah
    Chacham Mah Nishtanah
    15 years ago

    Anonymous 11:58 am Says:

    What about the children she had while in Iraq? Aren’t they Jewish?

    ———

    Jewish, but Mamzerim according to most Rishonim (except for Rabeinu Tam), as she was a married women.

    shmendrik
    shmendrik
    15 years ago

    who says she had children with him? all the article says “Hannah had been forced to become a Muslim and had raised her neighbor’s children for 50 years.

    Nebech
    Nebech
    15 years ago

    Who ever said she had children in Iraq? The story just says she was abducted and raised other’s children.

    Chacham Mah Nishtanah
    Chacham Mah Nishtanah
    15 years ago

    Shmendrick & Nebach Say

    Who ever said she had children in Iraq? The story just says she was abducted and raised other’s children.

    —-

    Well a Chacham reads between the lines! The article was just saying it in a nice way. “Other’s children” probably was refering to her husbands kids from her.

    Don't Be A Mamzer
    Don't Be A Mamzer
    15 years ago

    I love the way you guys fixate on minor details, AND MISS THE WHOLE POINT OF THE STORY!

    IT’S A MIRACLE!!!!!!!!!

    “She had kids, she didn’t have kids, they’re mamzeirim….” Don’t you people ever allow yourselves to feel the beauty, the pain, the raw emotion and poignancy of an incredible story, a true story unfolding before our very eyes?

    Who made you the Mamzeirim Police?

    Pinky's wife
    Pinky's wife
    15 years ago

    Jewish, but Mamzerim according to most Rishonim (except for Rabeinu Tam), as she was a married women.

    The child of a woman who is forcibly abducted and raped by a Gentile is not a mamzer. A child acquires Mamzer status from the relationship of two Jews who are forbidden to each other (ie incest, adultery).

    A woman who has been abducted and forcibly raped can return to her husband because she is not an adultress.

    Sadly it happens, and even once is too often. Rape happens in Christian countries as well as Muslim countries.

    Rape of religious Jewish women by Gentiles from the FSU has become a problem in Israel. Rape is hate crime of the most horrible sort. Women who are victims of horrible violent crimes are not punished by Rabbis or Batei Din by being forced to break up their families and leave the husbands they love and who love them.

    Mark Levin
    Mark Levin
    15 years ago

    halacha man,

    you should change your name after such a comment. you could have more than one wife especially S’fardim who are not bound by Cherem d’Rabaynu Gershom.

    Chacham Mah Nishtanah
    Chacham Mah Nishtanah
    15 years ago

    Pinky’s wife said…..



    You are right about not being a Mamzer, see Even Haezer 4:19

    As for a victim being permitted to her husband, that will depend if the husband is a Kohen or not. In addition, when living for a long time with Gentile, there may be times that she is not considered forced (See Chazal about Esther Hamalkah on Kasher Avadti Ovodti), and therefore forbidden to husband.

    In any case this is not the right forum for this discussion.

    Matzahlocal101
    Matzahlocal101
    15 years ago

    Pinky’s wife is correct. Regarding mazeirus a relationship with a non jew is not as severe as with a Jew. And as far as ogen (masculine form of agunah) status goes, even an ashkenazi could obtain a heter meah rabbanim if his wife was incapacitated or could not be located to recieve a get.

    Anonymous
    Anonymous
    15 years ago

    BORUCH HASHEM,

    HASHEM NEVER FORGETS ABOUT ANYONE!