Welcome, Guest! - or
Easy to remember!  »  VinNews.com

Israel - Govt. Backs New Law Against Illegal Immigrants: 20-Month Max Detention Period

Published on: November 30, 2014 11:19 PM
By: Jerusalem Post
Change text size Text Size  
File: An African migrant from South Sudan is being interviewed by an inspector of the Immigration and Population Department, after being arrested, at the Immigration and Population office near Tel Aviv, Israel, 12 June 2012. EPA/ABIR SULTANFile: An African migrant from South Sudan is being interviewed by an inspector of the Immigration and Population Department, after being arrested, at the Immigration and Population office near Tel Aviv, Israel, 12 June 2012. EPA/ABIR SULTAN

Israel - The Government on Sunday gave its approval to a new migrant detention policy in record time after the High Court of Justice struck down as unconstitutional the state’s two previous versions of the bill.

The policy still needs to be approved by the Knesset before it becomes law.

The court told the state in September it must close the Holot open detention center within 90 days and froze aspects of the limits on the movement of illegal migrants. It also struck down the constitutionality of holding newly arrived illegal migrants in the closed Saharonim detention center for one year.


Sunday’s version seeks to amend the policy by shortening the maximum amount of time migrants can be detained in each facility and changing some aspects of their detention conditions.

The policy allows for migrants to be held in the Holot open detention center for a maximum of 20 months, as opposed to the previous version in which they could be detained indefinitely.

At the closed Saharonim detention center, it allows for migrants to be held for a maximum of three months as opposed to a year in the previous version.

In addition, whereas detainees were ordered to sign in three times a day at Holot, the new draft calls on them to sign in just once a day.

While that change somewhat frees-up migrants’ movement, there are still elaborate prohibitions and sanctions designed to prevent migrants from finding employment.

The policy appears to be somewhat of a middle ground between what the High Court seemed to suggest and what recently resigned interior minister Gideon Sa’ar was seeking.

The High Court appeared to strongly suggest a policy based more on integrating migrants than on extended detention periods to deter them from staying in the country. Sa’ar had said he wanted a two-year detention period in Holot and around eight months in Saharonim.

The former interior minister and many other politicians said the court’s ruling undermined a policy that had been effective in dealing with the illegal migrant population, which had dropped to 48,212 as of June 30 – around 10,000 fewer than it was at its height a few years ago.

Attorney-General Yehuda Weinstein appeared to seek a middle path, though it is unclear if even this third policy will pass the High Court’s scrutiny.

Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu said, “Among our national responsibilities is defending our borders. Today, we are submitting to the Cabinet an amended illegal migration law. It fits the reality. It also fits the rulings of the High Court of Justice.” He added, “I remind you that Israel has achieved the extraordinary – which I’m very proud of – in blocking illegal migration across our borders – zero illegal migrants. Part of this entails repatriating illegal migrants. This year we repatriated over 6,000 illegal migrants. This legislation is designed to enable us to continue this trend.” But the Hotline for Refugees and Migrants slammed the changes, saying the government’s new policy was “belittling the High Court of Justice, southern residents of Tel Aviv and the citizens of Israel.” It added that, “for the third time, the government stubbornly continues to lie to the public and to squander a chance to formulate a real solution.” The nongovernmental organization emphasized that the funds the state was putting into detention centers could have been used, and would have been better spent, on integrating the migrants into society.

There is a strong chance that if it goes into law – in its absence, all migrants would need to be freed around December 22 – the NGO will ask the High Court to strike it down again.

In the court’s majority opinion by Justice Uzi Vogelman, he said that in the crucial debate over whether the migrants are here for economic reasons or to escape persecution the court could not ignore that the state was not forcing migrants to go back.

There is at least a serious concern of persecution for Eritreans and the Sudanese are not being sent back because of the lack of diplomatic relations with Sudan, he said.

With nowhere to send most of the migrants, the state needs to figure out a more humane way of dealing with their presence in the country besides throwing them in detention, whether it be open or closed, Vogelman said.

The justice focused on Israel’s international law obligations under conventions relating to refugees and found that its rate of granting refugee status is far lower than most of the world.

The spike in illegal migrants from Africa started about nine years ago and at one point the numbers reached as high as 60,000.

Content is provided courtesy of the Jerusalem Post

More of today's headlines

West Bank - A Palestinian woman stabbed an Israeli in the occupied West Bank on Monday and was then shot and wounded by security forces, the military and police... Israel - Justice Minister Tzipi Livni accused Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Sunday of negotiating his political future behind the backs of his coalition partners...



Read Comments (1)  —  Post Yours »


 Dec 01, 2014 at 08:25 AM tge Says:

This is the issue with the left......they ate their own worst enemy

They want to grant all these people rights and legitimacy and before you know it they'll lose their Jewish majority

Israel needs to send them back to Egypt where they came from


to post a comment

Click here to sign-in.

Scroll Up
Sell your scrap gold and broken jewelry and earn hard cash sell gold today!