Welcome, Guest! - or
Easy to remember!  »  VinNews.com

New York - Bloomingburg Chasidim Versus Board Of Elections Case To Be Heard Next Winter As Judge Refuses To Dismiss Suit

Published on: June 16, 2015 09:45 PM
Change text size Text Size  
A Charedi man is seen waking the streets of Bloomingburg, NY on Nov. 24, 2014. (Shimon Gifer/VINnews) A Charedi man is seen waking the streets of Bloomingburg, NY on Nov. 24, 2014. (Shimon Gifer/VINnews)

New York - In yet another victory for the fledgling Chasidic community in Bloomingburg, a federal judge has refused to dismiss a motion filed against the Sullivan County Board of Elections, charging that Chasidic voters were deprived of their right to vote.

As previously reported on VIN News, 27 Chasidic residents of Bloomingburg filed a complaint in March alleging that the Sullivan County Board of Elections attempted to cancel the registrations of 184 out of the village’s 285 registered voters.  160 of the voters whose registration was challenged were Chasidic Jews.

The lawsuit also names Board of Elections commissioners Ann Prusinski and Rodney Gaebel  as defendants, and charges that the defendants  required Chasidic residents to fill out lengthy questionnaires designed to make it harder to prove the validity of their registrations, ignored proof of residence supplied by Chasidic villagers, placed exceptional burdens on Chasidic voters who attempted to prove their places of residence, annulled votes of Chasidic voters and conducted bogus investigations and hearings to determine the eligibility of certain Chasidic voters.


Judge Katherine B. Forrest of the United States District Court, Southern District of New York, denied the defendants’ motion to dismiss the lawsuit today, saying that the plaintiffs in the case are entitled to have their complaint heard by a court of law.  The court also stated that at this time, neither Prusinski nor Gaebel are to be granted qualified immunity which would shield them from personal liability in the matter.

Today’s decision comes a week after Judge Forrest green lighted a lawsuit charging the Village of Bloomingburg and the Town of Mamakating with violating federal civil rights and fair housing laws by discriminating against Chasidim who hope to move into the village.  Another positive development for Bloomingburg’s Chasidic community occurred on the same day, when a state court of appeals denied a motion by Bloomingburg’s Rural Community Coalition and the Town of Mamakating  to reverse the annexation of land that provided developer Shalom Lamm’s with the property for his Chestnut Ridge townhouse development.

“I believe plaintiffs have made a strong case that the Sullivan County Board of Elections has engaged in a campaign to disenfranchise them and prevent them from voting and we fully expect that the suit will prevail when it goes to trial,” Michael Fragin of Bloomingburg’s Jewish Community Council told VIN News.

The case against the Sullivan County Board of Elections and its two commissioners is currently scheduled to go to trial on February 29, 2016.

More of today's headlines

New York - U.S. authorities have accused a New York City college student of plotting to set off a pressure cooker bomb in the city in support of the militant group... Seattle, WA – Amazon is once again working on a new project that would speed up delivery by creating an app that would pay regular people to deliver packages to...



Read Comments (1)  —  Post Yours »


 Jun 17, 2015 at 11:22 AM Anonymous Says:

I don't deny all this discrimination. But maybe its time for all of us golus yidden to reconsider and think why all this monsey, KJ Bloomingburg incidents are occuring. Legally we may be correct. But are we considerate of our non chasidish nieghboors? Do we honk, drive wildley, park illegally etc.. Do we keep our lawns clean so that our neighboors can keep the decorm of the block as serine? Do we bargin with the local yukel store owners? Do we think eh they don't cahp anything, we are smarter. I am not crticizing. And to be fair these things are much harder to keep when we live a religous life with many kids. Natrually jugging the many kids with work and religious life leads us to be in hurry, not have time to clean up etc.. Just trying to point out how we must approach life in golus.


to post a comment

Click here to sign-in.

Scroll Up

Sell your scrap gold and broken jewelry and earn hard cash sell gold today!