Welcome, Guest! - or
Easy to remember!  »  VinNews.com

Israel - Thousands of Converts Await High Court Decision on Age-Old Question of "Who Is a Jew"

Published on: November 1, 2008 10:34 PM
By: AP
Change text size Text Size  

Israel - Raised without religion in Maryland, Shannon sought to make a new life for herself as a Jew in Israel.
In a rigorous conversion process, she studied religious law for a year, took a Hebrew name and changed her wardrobe to long skirts and sleeves as dictated by Orthodox Jewish custom. Finally, a panel of rabbis pronounced her Jewish.

But five years later, she and some 40,000 like her have suddenly had their conversions annulled by Israel’s Rabbinical High Court.
The court says the rabbi who heads a government authority set up to oversee conversions is too liberal in approving them.

The issue, now headed to Israel’s Supreme Court, has exposed an intensifying power struggle inside Israel’s religious establishment over the age-old question of “who is a Jew.” It also threatens to deepen the wedge between Israel and American Jews, who largely follow more liberal schools of Judaism.


While 34-year-old Shannon’s Israeli citizenship isn’t in jeopardy, the ruling diminishes her religious rights. Many rabbis will no longer oversee basic Jewish rituals for her, such as getting married or receiving a Jewish burial. If she has children, they might not be considered Jewish.

“I’m very worried. I probably will not be able to get married in Israel,” she said. “God forbid, if I die, will I be allowed a Jewish burial?”
Shannon was the woman’s given name in the small Maryland farm town where she grew up. She asked to withhold her surname and Hebrew first name for fear of antagonizing the rabbis who hold her fate in their hands. Other converts interviewed by The Associated Press made the same request.

The quest for a definition of Jewishness has dogged Israel from its beginning, and has taken on urgency in recent years as immigrants have poured in, primarily from the former Soviet Union and Ethiopia. Many of them have Jewish roots but are not considered Jewish under Orthodox religious law because they weren’t born to Jewish mothers.

Three years ago the government formed the conversion authority to set universal standards, headed by Haim Drukman, a respected Orthodox rabbi who had already overseen tens of thousands of conversions over the years, including Shannon’s.

Born to a Jewish father and Christian mother, Shannon became drawn to her Jewish roots, and in 1995 moved to Israel. She didn’t meet the Orthodox rabbinate’s criteria of Jewishness, so she underwent conversion, approved by Drukman in 2003, and maintains a religious lifestyle to this day, keeping kosher and not working on the Sabbath.

But last March, the state-funded rabbinical court, which has the final say over who is Jewish, reversed her conversion and some 40,000 others overseen by Drukman and his followers.

The rabbis based their ruling on their discovery that a Danish woman whom Drukman converted more than a decade ago did not observe the Sabbath. But the decision was a symptom of a broader struggle.
On one side are ultra-Orthodox hard-liners, who insist converts must embrace their strict interpretation of Judaism for life. On the other side are moderates like Drukman.

“There is a commandment to love every Jew and there is a special commandment to love the convert,” he says.
An important goal of Drukman’s office was to help the more than 300,000 immigrants from the former Soviet Union whose Jewishness was in question.

Rabbi Eliyahu Ben-Dahan, director of the rabbinical courts, said too many people are being converted who aren’t genuinely interested in the religion. “Nobody really checked how many of these 300,000 people really wanted to be Jews,” Ben-Dahan said.

The decision also has threatened ties with those American Jews who belong to the more liberal Reform and Conservative denominations. The ruling on conversions is seen as another blow to their struggle for recognition in Israel.

“Few crises have so divided Israel from the North American Jewish community,” the United Jewish Communities, a U.S. umbrella group that donates hundreds of millions of dollars to Israel each year, wrote to Prime Minister Ehud Olmert in July.
To the group’s plea for action, Olmert replied he was “determined” to solve the conversion crisis.

But the same month, Olmert abruptly fired Drukman. He said the law requires the 76-year-old rabbi to retire, but an official said Olmert felt that Drukman’s rate of conversions — 3,400 in the three years of his authority’s existence — was too slow. The official spoke on condition of anonymity because he was sharing confidential information.

Drukman, speaking to the AP, called the dismissal “foolish and malicious,” saying his contract had been renewed only a year earlier.

The Supreme Court is likely to take up within weeks an action brought by Yael, the Danish woman at the heart of the conflict. She converted to marry an Israeli man she met 20 years ago, but during divorce proceedings last year, she acknowledged she did not live by Orthodox rules. The rabbis then invalidated her conversion and everyone else converted by Drukman.

Yael says the rabbis are acting against the spirit of Judaism.
“There is an unwritten law that we should be nice to each other and be human beings, and I always connected this to religion,” she said.


More of today's headlines

Honolulu , HI - The state's Department of Health director on Friday released a statement verifying the legitimacy of Sen. Barack Obama birth certificate. The state... New York - It's time to fall back. Standard time returns this weekend at 2 a.m. Sunday, so set your clocks back an hour before going to sleep Saturday night. The...



Read Comments (9)  —  Post Yours »


 Nov 02, 2008 at 12:16 AM Anonymous Says:

Since when is a shickse allowed to convert to marry a Jew?


 Nov 02, 2008 at 01:06 AM slanted article Says:

This is a very anti chareidi slanted article. Drukman did invalid conversions for political purposes. The sincere converts among the group that he converted should reapply and they will be accepted.

If the government or anti religious Israeli supreme court force the acceptance of these illegitimate conversions, the Orthodox world will not accept them anyways. In addition, sincere converts will be adversely impacted since an entire group of converts is under question and the converts will not be accepted without rigorous checking.


 Nov 02, 2008 at 08:58 AM Anonymous Says:

"Orthodox" religious law on conversion is the only religious law. Could they have reviewed each case instead of refusing all of Rabbi Drukman's conversions? Some of his conversions seemed legitimate and annulling those may follow into the category of laws to love a ger. It can be a very difficult process for someone to convert and for someone to be told that their conversion is illegitamate because of some conversion that was was questionable that the rabbi did must be extremely upsetting. The government through Torah authorities needs to establish guidelines on conversion-such as no conversion for marriage and the convert must agree to accept halacha.


 Nov 02, 2008 at 11:17 AM schmeel Says:

Reply to #1  
Anonymous Says:

Since when is a shickse allowed to convert to marry a Jew?

You who seek tolerence from others are the most intolerent yourself.Some day you might find yourself in a situation where one of your children seeks to marry a non-jew who is willing to convert.At that time your opinion might change.


 Nov 02, 2008 at 11:34 AM Zeek Says:

Reply to #1  
Anonymous Says:

Since when is a shickse allowed to convert to marry a Jew?

Your comment is outragious.Many frum jews (rosh yeshivas also) originate from marraiges that began in a similar manner. Who are you to question their Jewishness.


 Nov 02, 2008 at 12:07 PM Anonymous Says:

A Jew who neglects their Shabbos obligations is still a Jew.
I can understand annulling the conversion of individual converts who by their actions of not keeping Shabbos shortly after conversion demonstrate that they were not sincere, and are better off not being Jews.
I cannot understand annuling conversions of righteous converts who did keep Shabbos and who the converting rabbis did properly check and monitor, and who had the appropriate authority at the time.

If one rabbi performs one conversion with someone who turned out to not be a proper witness, should that annul all their prior and subsequent conversions as well?


 Nov 02, 2008 at 12:58 PM Anonymous Says:

But the Zionist Rabbinate has no true authority over who a Jew is. Its only a political and legal issue.

The Shomrei Emunim and the Eidah HaChareidis has their own rabbinite that makes conversions independant of the zionist state.


 Nov 02, 2008 at 04:03 PM zelig Says:

Reply to #7  
Anonymous Says:

But the Zionist Rabbinate has no true authority over who a Jew is. Its only a political and legal issue.

The Shomrei Emunim and the Eidah HaChareidis has their own rabbinite that makes conversions independant of the zionist state.

What makes you think that their conversion is valid? It may be less reliable then the 'ZIONIST" conversion.


 Nov 02, 2008 at 10:37 PM LakewoodFallingDown Says:

Only a Jew could hate Israel so much. #7, why don't you love your land?


to post a comment

Click here to sign-in.

Scroll Up

Sell your scrap gold and broken jewelry and earn hard cash sell gold today!