New York – Once ‘America’s Mayor,’ Giuliani Emerges As Divisive Figure

    13

    FILE - Former New York City Major, Rudolph Giuliani during a conference, 16 June 2016.  EPA/MARIO RUIZNew York – Rudolph Giuliani, who earned the nickname “America’s Mayor” for his leadership in the wake of the Sept. 11 attacks, has emerged as a far more divisive figure during this tumultuous American summer, advising Donald Trump and scolding activists railing against police violence.

    Join our WhatsApp group

    Subscribe to our Daily Roundup Email


    Giuliani has not held public office since 2001, but he has asserted himself on a pair of inflammatory issues that are helping shape this year’s White House race.

    A former federal prosecutor and a Republican who served eight years leading deeply liberal New York City, Giuliani has long linked himself to law enforcement.

    He took up that mantle again after last week’s two fatal shootings of African-American men by police and then the killing of five police officers in Dallas. Though many public figures followed up with pleas for unity, Giuliani fiercely criticized the Black Lives Matter movement, saying it encouraged violence against police.

    “When you say black lives matter, that’s inherently racist,” Giuliani said Sunday on CBS’ “Face the Nation.” ”Black lives matter. White lives matter. Asian lives matter. Hispanic lives matter. That’s anti-American, and it’s racist.”

    He added: “They sing rap songs about killing police officers, and they talk about killing police officers, and they yell it out at their rallies and the police officers hear it.”

    Giuliani doubled down the next day, touting the aggressive policing tactics he championed while mayor, ones that drove down crime but also inflamed racial tensions.

    “I believe I saved a lot more black lives than Black Lives Matter. I don’t see what Black Lives Matter is doing for blacks other than isolating them,” Giuliani said during an appearance on Fox News. “All it cares about is the police shooting of blacks. It doesn’t care about the 90 percent of blacks that have been killed by other blacks.”

    His comments drew immediate criticism and were rebuffed by Joe Biden. The vice president acknowledged that while there were some militant elements of the Black Lives Matter movement, he accused Giuliani of using “a very broad statement.”

    “There’s nothing inconsistent with supporting the police and acknowledging the problems that exist in terms of dealing with the communities that, in fact, are feeling put upon,” Biden told CNN.

    A spokeswoman for Giuliani told The Associated Press that the former mayor was traveling this week and unavailable to comment.

    Giuliani embraced Trump’s presidential bid early on, and he endorsed Trump in the weeks before the New York primary, which the reality TV star won in a landslide.

    In May, Trump suggested that he planned to tap Giuliani to study his proposal to bar all Muslims from entering the country. Trump has since backed away from it, and Giuliani has taken credit for the shift.

    Giuliani said in an interview last week with NJ Advance Media that he put together a small group of people to study the idea.

    “You can’t have a general ban, but you can have very specific, targeted criteria,” Giuliani said. “You could certainly say ‘We’re not going to take any of the Syrian refugees.'”

    A Trump aide confirmed that the candidate has spoken to Giuliani about the policy but declined to answer whether ex-mayor was a source of the shift. Politico reported Wednesday that Giuliani is slated to address the Republican National Convention in Cleveland next week.

    Always outspoken, Giuliani’s transformation from moderate Republican mayor of an overwhelmingly Democratic city to right-wing hero came in the years after the attacks, as he shifted right on a number of issues — including gun control and public funding of abortions — during his failed run for president in 2008.

    His recent stances only place him further out of step with the city he once led, said Jeanne Zaino, political science professor at Iona College.

    “He was basically universally beloved after 9/11 but the changes are surprising,” Zaino said. “He’s trying to stay relevant, but he’s become a pretty polarizing figure.”


    Listen to the VINnews podcast on:

    iTunes | Spotify | Google Podcasts | Stitcher | Podbean | Amazon

    Follow VINnews for Breaking News Updates


    Connect with VINnews

    Join our WhatsApp group


    13 Comments
    Most Voted
    Newest Oldest
    Inline Feedbacks
    View all comments
    7 years ago

    Guiliani’s role in the aftermath of the 9/11 attack was way overblown. What exactly did he do? I’ll tell you that all he did was walk around and pose for the cameras. In fact, he was against the firefighters receiving overtime pay, during the search for bodies. He had their time and pay cut at the ground zero site, and later had the cops arrest those same firefighters, when they protested the cutting of their hours.

    Liepa
    Liepa
    7 years ago

    Giuliani would have made a great president, unfortunately that wont happen.
    That said, Giuliani is correct in his assessment of Black Lives Matter, they only cry foul when police kill some individuals, who in many cases brought it on themselves by not listening to police instructions etc., but never do they speak out when hundreds of blacks are killed by other blacks annually.
    That really shows their true colors and intentions.

    BTW, when the police orders you to stop, you stop, you certainly don’t try to grab the officer’s weapon and so on because you will end up in a coffin.
    Why is that so hard to comprehend, or maybe they just don’t want to.

    7 years ago

    How is saying all live matter, divisive?

    YossiP
    YossiP
    7 years ago

    Rudy was never liked by the African Americans that don’t like him now.. He hasn’t changed his views (fortunately). He has and is saying the truth.. African Americans that have moved forward from the 60’s love him… Those who haven’t, dislike home. And King O, HilLIARy, and the DNC love to stoke the coals… What a shame.

    eliezer318
    eliezer318
    7 years ago

    More & more, it seems, imho, the AP news service is editorializing so heavily. Is it not supposed to provide news service? Why is it called “polarizing” to state the truth about black-on-black violence and divisive black movements? Hope most people differentiate when reading, between the actual news content and the “spin”.

    DMD45
    DMD45
    7 years ago

    Rudy G is only divisive to those opposing and allergic to the truth !!! DMD

    charliehall
    charliehall
    7 years ago

    He was incredibly divisive while he was mayor!

    BarryLS1
    BarryLS1
    7 years ago

    The definition of “divisive” = telling the truth.

    TruthIsIt
    TruthIsIt
    7 years ago

    I lived in upper Manhattan and before Mayor Giuliani came into office we had drug dealers and prostitution in front of our buildings and surrounding area. Thanks to this Mayor(not like this present fool in city hall) the neighborhood is safe. Don’t believe me? go look at uptown Manhattan, Washington Heights, etc…..

    orchid
    orchid
    7 years ago

    The best mayor we ever had – went to Israel to show solidarity – cleaned up New York – he would make a great president