Tripoli, Libya – Exiled Libyan Jew Says Synagogue Efforts Blocked

    11

    David Gerbi gestures in front of the main synagogue in Tripoli, Libya, Sunday, Oct. 2, 2011.  APTripoli, Libya – A Libyan Jewish man who returned from exile to try to restore Tripoli’s main synagogue says he has been blocked from the building a day after knocking down the wall that was blocking its entrance.

    Join our WhatsApp group

    Subscribe to our Daily Roundup Email


    A visibly angry David Gerbi says he went to clean garbage from the synagogue on Monday only to be told by men at the scene that they had warnings he would be targeted by violence. He says they told him to stop his efforts.

    Gerbi, who fled with his family to Italy in 1967, says he was surprised because he had permission from the local sheik. Gerbi’s colleague Richard Peters says several men armed with assault rifles later appeared to guard the building.

    Breaking down in tears, Gerbi says Libya needs to decide if it’s going to be a rascist country or a democratic one.

    THIS IS A BREAKING NEWS UPDATE. Check back soon for further information. AP’s earlier story is below.

    TRIPOLI, Libya (AP) — David Gerbi is a 56-year-old psychoanalyst, but to Libyan rebels he was the “revolutionary Jew.” He returned to his homeland after 44 years in exile to help oust Moammar Gadhafi, and to take on what may be an even more challenging mission.

    That job began Sunday, when he took a sledgehammer to a concrete wall. Behind it: the door to Tripoli’s crumbling main synagogue, unused since Gadhafi expelled Libya’s small Jewish community early in his decades-long rule.

    Gerbi knocked down the wall, said a prayer and cried.
    David Gerbi reacts after he knocked down a wall blocking the door to the main synagogue in Tripoli, Libya, Sunday, Oct. 2,  2011. AP
    “What Gadhafi tried to do is to eliminate the memory of us. He tried to eliminate the amazing language. He tried to eliminate the religion of the Jewish people,” said Gerbi, whose family fled to Italy when he was 12. “I want bring our legacy back, I want to give a chance to the Jewish of Libya to come back.”

    The Star of David is still visible inside and outside the peach-colored Dar al-Bishi synagogue in Tripoli’s walled Old City. An empty ark where Torah scrolls were once kept still reads “Shema Israel” — “Hear, O Israel” — in faded Hebrew. But graffiti is painted on the walls, and the floor and upper chambers are covered in garbage — plastic water bottles, clothes, mattresses, drug paraphernalia and dead pigeon carcasses.

    He and a team of helpers carted in brooms, rakes and buckets to prepare to clean it out.

    It took Gerbi weeks to get permission from Libya’s new rulers to begin restoring the synagogue, which is part of his broader goal of promoting tolerance for Jews and other religions in a new Libya.

    “My hope and wish is to have an inclusive country,” he said. “I want to make justice, not only for me, but for all the people of Libya for the damage that Gadhafi did.”

    Gerbi’s family fled to Rome in 1967, when Arab anger was rising over the war in which Israel captured the West Bank, east Jerusalem and Gaza Strip. Two years later, Gadhafi expelled the rest of Libya’s Jewish community, which at its peak numbered about 37,000.

    Gerbi returned to his homeland this summer to join the rebellion that ousted Gadhafi, helping with strategy and psychological issues. He rode into the capital with fighters from the western mountains as Tripoli fell in late August.

    Now he has hired neighborhood residents to help clean and renovate the synagogue in Hara Kabira, a sandy slum that was once Tripoli’s Jewish quarter. He said he is funding the synagogue renovation himself, and plans to stay until his project is complete.

    He called it a test of tolerance for Libya’s new rulers.

    “I plan to restore the synagogue, I plan to get the passport back, I plan to resolve the problem of the confiscated property, individual and collective,” he said. “I plan to help rebuild Libya, to do my part.”

    Gerbi isn’t sure how many Jewish properties were confiscated, but he hopes to find a way to resolve that issue and build a garden memorial on the site of the former Jewish cemetery, which Gadhafi had covered with high rises and a parking lot.

    Libya’s acting justice minister, Mohammed al-Alagi, said Gerbi could appeal for justice.

    “If he was discriminated at some time, Libyan courts are open for his claims,” he told The Associated Press in an interview.

    Gerbi, who fearlessly wore a yarmulke on Sunday and likes to take walks on the seaside street outside the protective confines of his hotel to clear his head, considers himself a Jewish ambassador of goodwill.

    He said he faced some hostility in the beginning but has been able to overcome it with old-fashioned glad-handing, although he acknowledges concerns are high about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the influence of the Muslim Brotherhood.

    Dar al-Bishi is one of the few Libyan synagogues with the potential to be restored. Others have been demolished or put to other uses. Some were turned into mosques.

    Jews first arrived in what is now Libya some 2,300 years ago. They settled mostly in coastal towns such as Tripoli and Benghazi and lived under a shifting string of rulers, including Romans, Ottoman Turks, Italians and ultimately the independent Arab state that was run by Gadhafi for nearly 42 years.

    Some prospered as merchants, physicians and jewelers. Under Muslim rule, they saw periods of relative tolerance and bursts of hostility. Italy took over in 1911, and eventually the fascist government of Benito Mussolini issued discriminatory laws against Jews, dismissing some from government jobs and ordering them to work on Saturdays, the Jewish day of rest.

    In the 1940s, thousands were sent to concentration camps in North Africa where hundreds died. Some were deported to concentration camps in Germany and Austria.

    In the decades after the war, thousands of Jews left Libya, many of them for Israel.

    Gerbi said his family went to Italy to escape tensions, thinking they would return someday, but those hopes were dashed by Gadhafi’s expulsion order. Some relatives later went to Israel, but he chose to remain in Italy.

    This is not Gerbi’s first trip back to Libya. He returned in 2002, when he agreed to help Gadhafi’s efforts to normalize relations with the international community and helped an ailing aunt leave the country. Gerbi said she had been Libya’s last remaining Jew.

    Gerbi saw the Tripoli synagogue during another trip five years later, and even met Gadhafi in Rome in 2009.

    But in the end, all his efforts were stonewalled.

    “I thought Gadhafi was really with great intentions, but it was all a lie,” he said in a wide-ranging interview Saturday with The Associated Press.

    Gerbi is hopeful about Libya’s future, although he has not yet been allowed to join the National Transitional Council, which is now governing Libya, as a full representative.

    Jalal el-Gallal, an NTC spokesman, said Gerbi’s efforts to restore the synagogue were premature because the government is still temporary and revolutionary forces are fighting Gadhafi supporters on two major fronts.

    “I think it’s just creating a lot more complications at the moment,” he said.

    One endorsement Gerbi has received is from the synagogue neighborhood’s main sheik, who also offered him protection.

    “The NTC says, ‘You have to wait. It’s a sensitive subject,'” Gerbi said. “I don’t want to wait. Why should I wait when I did the revolution?”


    Listen to the VINnews podcast on:

    iTunes | Spotify | Google Podcasts | Stitcher | Podbean | Amazon

    Follow VINnews for Breaking News Updates


    Connect with VINnews

    Join our WhatsApp group


    11 Comments
    Most Voted
    Newest Oldest
    Inline Feedbacks
    View all comments
    Normal
    Normal
    12 years ago

    He obviously loves Libya but I don’t think it is reciprocated. Also sounds like there are no other Jews there and doesn’t sound like a very safe place for a Jew. He should have a good cry and go back to Italy or move to Israel.

    DRE53
    DRE53
    12 years ago

    What a waste of money. Let him send the money to the US or eretz yisroel where he can have a shul or yeshiva named Yeshiva of Tripoly etc.

    SherryTheNoahide
    SherryTheNoahide
    12 years ago

    Wow! I was so inspired by this story! Moved me to tears in more than one places! What courage & conviction! G-d bless this man!

    He is a hero for fighting so hard to restore what the Jewish community had there in Libya, before Momhar Gadhaffi took away everything. Good for him!

    And it sounds like the Sheik at the top was ok with him renovating the place…. but that a band of armed protesters on the bottom, were not.

    He’s right- the people there are going to have to decide for themselves: do they want a tolerant Libya w\freedom of religion… or do they want more totalitarian rule?

    Watching the footage of so many Libyan youth during the expulsion of Gadhaffi- some not much older than my own son who’s only 8- fighting for their country & for their freedom- I had hopes that w\the brutal dictator out, the people could be given a chance to learn a new way of living. One without constant hate or constant violence.

    Let’s pray that mindset takes hold! I would love for the Libyan Yidden who grew up over there to feel comfortable with going back to restore their homeland.

    I cannot imagine how moving it must have been for the man in this story to knock down those Shul walls…wow!

    12 years ago

    A leopard does not change its spots. Even though Quadaffi was overthrown, the entrenched and hostile attitudes of the local populace towards Jews, which goes back decades, has not changed. Libya is judenrein, as is the case in nearly all of the Arab countries, including Syria, Iraq and Lebanon. There are a handful of Jews left in Egypt, but they are not wanted by the local citizenry. There were over 150,000 Jews at one time in those four arab countries, but they were all driven out, and their property was confiscated.

    12 years ago

    New government; same reshomin just with different names and faces. Do you expect anything else from arab countries today

    AKIVAF
    AKIVAF
    12 years ago

    Recent news reports show a steady return of violence against Xtians and other non-Muslims despite previous optimism of a more democratic religiously tolerant Egypt. So this concern by the “authorities” about the opening of a synagogue is not a surprise and may even be doing Gerbi a favor.

    AKIVAF
    AKIVAF
    12 years ago

    Recent news reports show a steady return of violence against Xtians and other non-Muslims despite previous optimism of a more democratic religiously tolerant Egypt. So this concern by the “authorities” about the opening of a synagogue is not a surprise and may even be doing Gerbi a favor.

    my4amos
    my4amos
    12 years ago

    The man wears “I heart Libya” shirt, he can’t be sane, I would be very careful taking whatever he says seriously.