San Francisco, CA – Proposal To Ban ‘Milah’ To Be Put On Ballot For Voters To Decide

    38

    San Francisco, CA – The Board of Supervisors just banned toys in Happy Meals, which drew worldwide attention.

    Join our WhatsApp group

    Subscribe to our Daily Roundup Email


    Now the latest ban being proposed in San Francisco is on male circumcision.

    A proposed ballot measure for the November 2011 ballot – when voters will be electing the San Francisco’s next mayor – would amend The City’s police code “to make it a misdemeanor to circumcise, excise, cut or mutilate the foreskin, testicle or penis of another person who has not attained the age of 18.”

    Doing so would result in a fine of up to $1,000 and up to one year in jail, according to the proposed measure submitted to the Department of Elections.

    The measure was submitted by San Francisco resident Lloyd Schofield, who has spoken up on this issue in the past.

    He was not immediately available for comment.

    For the ordinance to make it on to the November ballot, it would require the collection of 7,168 valid signatures by April 26, 2011.

    It’s unknown if Schofield approached members of the Board of Supervisors asking them to vote on such a measure before deciding to take it to the voters.


    Listen to the VINnews podcast on:

    iTunes | Spotify | Google Podcasts | Stitcher | Podbean | Amazon

    Follow VINnews for Breaking News Updates


    Connect with VINnews

    Join our WhatsApp group


    38 Comments
    Most Voted
    Newest Oldest
    Inline Feedbacks
    View all comments
    deepthinker
    deepthinker
    13 years ago

    What do you expect from San Fransicko, the most crazy Liberal City in america!

    grandson1
    grandson1
    13 years ago

    This is the city that allows gays to do whatever they want and wherever they want to do it but will outlaw Milah. Remember this Nancy pelosi’s city. Good work Dems.

    liberals-are-nuts
    liberals-are-nuts
    13 years ago

    This is Nancy Pelosi place, this is liberalism at his best. And people like Charlie Hall support this ideology.

    ShatzMatz
    ShatzMatz
    13 years ago

    If they agree to outlaw ALL metzitza b’peh then I would have no objection.

    Yerachmiel
    Yerachmiel
    13 years ago

    If by some crazy chance this passes the courts will probably overturn it for the same reason that they protect a woman’s right to choose an abortion. Of course if we get another conservative on the supreme court you can say good bye to constitutional protection of milah. Each locality will be free to pass such laws.

    toolee
    toolee
    13 years ago

    Are we talking about San Francisco in the US of A???
    Or are we talking about Germany???

    festayid
    festayid
    13 years ago

    Most goyim themselves circumcise there children its a known fact that removing the forskin is healthy and has a lower risk of STDs, if they outlaw this its like saying u can’t vaccinate ur baby bec the needle hurts

    toolee
    toolee
    13 years ago

    Wait!!! Those voting are from those who had brisses done on themselves?
    Or only Goim will vote? What about a Noiled Mohel ? Can he vote ot does he get kicked out of SF?

    megaworldly
    megaworldly
    13 years ago

    This is how it begins. Shechita, Milah, Kapporos. We’ve down this road before Hashem Yishmor

    megaworldly
    megaworldly
    13 years ago

    This is very scary!!!

    13 years ago

    The irony is that circumcision reduces the risk of spreading HIV, which presumably is a serious problem in SF.

    Anonymous
    Anonymous
    13 years ago

    San Francisco’s code sets a very low threshold to get a referendum on the ballot. This guy has been pushing the anti-brissin amendment for years and finally got enough signatures. The city is legally obligated to put it on the ballot. If you disagree than simply vote not. Otherwise, the mohels will simply do their thing in Marin county and Oakland. No big deal.

    MrsCharlie
    MrsCharlie
    13 years ago

    now you know it’s time to start packing. Hashem has made the Aliyah movement popular just in time.

    13 years ago

    doctors circumsize all babies anyhow

    13 years ago

    Enough is enough is enough. This dope fed city has got to be brought back to reality.
    Do anything and everything against religion. but being a freak is permissible. They insulted a church communion and anything else. Where is the self respect which is totally missing. Republicans find something on Pelosi and send her packing. Time to get something normal there. Maybe they all will love to live in a communist country so
    lets help them all move

    mythoughts
    mythoughts
    13 years ago

    Ever notice how liberals are the most intolerant.

    bubii
    bubii
    13 years ago

    the health benefits are almost zero and those who do risky behaviour gays who cares if they get aids, the bill wants that until the age of consent it should be illigal to circumsize it means after the age of 18 you can go ahead and do it if you so choose it

    Kanaim
    Kanaim
    13 years ago

    The real problem is those Jewish parents who have already decided that milah is some kind of torture and have refused to have their sons circumcised. They have no idea how many isurim they are oiver, and thay their son is not even considered Jewish until he is given a bris. So when the boy is a young adult and maybe figures out what’s what, then he has to undergo some real pain. A Jewish council should be formed with the power to snatch these babies, give them a bris, then return them. Too bad if mommy and daddy don’t like it.

    CountryYossi
    CountryYossi
    13 years ago

    Jews have been sanctioned over the last thousands of years from practicing their religion on many Torah laws..We always overcame those times and we will bezras hashem fight this mila restriction and win it….

    basmelech
    basmelech
    13 years ago

    to be a Liberal means being liberal about the government spending tax payer’s money, be liberal about doing all kinds of immoral behavior, simply being immorally liberal.They’re like the people of S’dom.

    victorg
    victorg
    13 years ago

    I have a simple work around. Just tell them the baby is gay. Ahh no problem – if he’s gay anything goes!

    bamba
    bamba
    13 years ago

    What about tonsils? How could they remove them? There’s also piercing and tattooing which should be added.

    Boochie
    Boochie
    13 years ago

    The sad thing is that this guy is probably Jewish himself – how far have we strayed from the path?

    Secular
    Secular
    13 years ago

    Where are Barbara Boxer and Diane feinstein senators from California both Jewish??

    lakewooder
    lakewooder
    13 years ago

    Actually, Kanoi is right. If a father does not want to keep the Mitzvah of Bris Milah, the Beis Din grabs the child and does it. See Yoreh Deah 261. This case is totally different from tonsils. The Torah is true, and if it tells us to circumcise, that is the right thing to do. Removing of tonsils would be a totally unnecessary act and that is all the difference. However, if Jewish people refuse to present the Torah as the ultimate truth and try to couch our mitzvos in language designed to appeal to a goy, we have ourselves to blame when the Goy doesn’t take us seriously.